Larry Ceisler’s letter on the state of Downtown, “Pittsburgh is worse than Philadelphia,” published last Sunday, got an extraordinary number of readers and a high number of commenters. Here’s a selection. The names used on the website are used here.
The answer is no
I would take this opinion with a grain of salt. I was in Center City Philly this past April. The area had a lot more activity than Downtown Pittsburgh currently does. However, I can’t say that Center City Philly is cleaner than Downtown Pittsburgh. I run downtown every week and to me it seems like it’s getting cleaner. I see Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership workers cleaning up the streets and taking out the trash.
In terms of safety, I don’t particularly feel unsafe downtown because of sketchy activity. However, I do feel like I need to be more aware of my surroundings because of the lack of people downtown. Recently, I also noticed two police officers patrolling outside of Liberty Center which makes me think that crime is starting to be addressed.
Center City Philly is a toss up. Certain areas I felt totally safe, while others I felt very unsafe. I also met friends for dinner that live in the suburbs who say they don’t visit Center City anymore because of the crime. They actually made a point to walk me back to my hotel.
JOSEPH RITACCO
Incent businesses
Very Sad. The best way to stop vagrancy and crime in the city is to incent businesses to locate in the core center of town. This will do much more to revitalize and clean up the city than all the empathy and giveaways that we can provide unproductive citizens.
JOHN DAVIS
Crime first
Paying businesses to set up downtown does not work. Businesses siphon up the taxpayer subsidies then scoot when the money dries up. Businesses can’t be profitable downtown because of the high crime rate and low sales rates. You have to fix the crime problem before you can fix the business problem, not the other way around.
OINTMENT FLY
Only county-class
No, but the Post-Gazette is worse than the Inquirer. And Philly has a grandeur and patina that Pittsburgh lacks. Pittsburgh is of course worse than Philly because the latter is a world-class city and Pittsburgh is only an Allegheny County-class city. Mellon Square is no Rittenhouse Square, Phipps Conservatory is no Longwood Gardens, Oakland is no University City, Primanti’s is no Pat’s, etc.
But at street level, downtown Pittsburgh is way safer than Center City Philly. The letter writer seems to live at a great remove from reality.
SUBURBAL
Different issue
Are the empty storefronts because of Amazon and the proliferation of online shopping or the Democratic leadership? Gimbel’s and Horne’s have been gone a long time so that tells me that shopping downtown has been on the decline for many more years that just recently. Many think that this is a political problem, where I am convince that it is a capitalism issue. If there were customers and money to be made downtown, retail shopping would flourish.
VOTEBLUE
At one time
We can debate the level to which Downtown Pittsburgh has descended, but it is certainly not what it once was. Looking at the city today, it is hard to believe that in its heyday, there were thriving department stores throughout. Today, many remaining Downtown businesses are anxious to get out of the area. At one time, the Downtown Macy’s did $80 million in business per year.
If Ed Gainey seeks to have any shot at being re-elected as mayor, the state of Downtown must be addressed.
OREN SPIEGLER
Not again
I worked in downtown Pittsburgh for over 40 years. I enjoyed shopping and walking on my lunch break. Until recently, I would get a bus to downtown, get my hair done and walk around, and shop a little. Now that there have been shooting in mid-day, I will not be doing this ever again. I had my husband ride me into town and pick me up after a show at the Benedum. Too scary.
JANIB
Help the homeless
I was in Downtown Pittsburgh last weekend. There were tents right on Grant Street three blocks away from the City County Building. I parked at a garage on Smithfield Street and there appeared to be homeless people on an alley next to the garage. This really needs to be addressed.
BELLA FRIEDMAN
House the homeless
I think what you mean to say is the homeless really need addresses. If they have no place to go, where do you expect them to be? An alleyway near a garage becomes one of the more sensible places. If you solve housing first, addressing the mental illness and addiction that drives so much homelessness becomes easier.
MICHAEL DAVID
Merged problems
The issue is if these people have mental health issues, why did we as a society decide to merge mental health with homelessness? They are two different things that tend to overlap, but through our tax dollars we have spent thousands of dollars to start and maintain shelters throughout the state. If they do have mental health issues, then they should be diagnosed by a licensed professional, not a politician or an activist.
ANONYMOUS
Scary stories
Truly shocking is the ferocity of the collapse of Downtown Pittsburgh in a city that had been on everyone’s “Most Livable” lists until recently. However, are there any cities in America where Downtowns haven’t declined? I am hearing scary stories about San Francisco and Buffalo and even Denver.
BRADLEY EASTERDAY
Entertain them
Despite those who would like to attribute Pittsburgh’s city center decline to something political, the real problems lie in the fact that bricks and mortar retail has suffered greatly — the death of the department stores. The office market has suffered, as in most cities, due to a pandemic shift in working habits. And not enough people live downtown to create a market for restaurants, goods and services.
Attracting retail downtown is not the solution it used to be. But creating entertainment options can work to take the place of what retail used to do. The City should formulate and promote a master plan for making this transformation happen in creative ways. Public-private partnerships are a popular vehicle for making this happen and should be encouraged.
People will choose to live in urban settings where there are good entertainment options and restaurants. And with more downtown residents and a more active city center the breeding ground for crime and vagrancy go away.
It’s been proven over and over again that evening public activity ends crime and vagrancy. These things can’t exist in a vibrant, active setting. You don’t need more cops and jail. For what? An even more dystopian scene - when it’s clear that creating a vibrant, active city center is a more positive and lasting cure..Bad social environments create bad results and police aren’t what fixes them.
CHUCK MINEO
Stores left first
It was easier and less expensive to drive to a suburban mall where parking is free! A lot of comments are trying to make the demise of Pgh to be political. The stores left first with customers preferring to shop the malls, then online shopping put another nail in the coffin. The pandemic with people working from home sealed the deal.
CLARA
Don’t live there
The question on my mind is, will the trend of residing downtown continue? Why would anyone want to live there now? Few office workers need to be in the office anymore, there are few attractions downtown, and if you are not prudent about when you go out and where (downtown) you could be pointlessly exposing yourself to criminal activity. And of course it is a “food desert.” I like an urban environment, but I certainly wouldn’t want to live in downtown Pittsburgh.
DAVE STROUD
Democrats’ fault
Voting out progressive ‘woke’ Democrats would be a great start to bringing back what was once touted as “America’s Most Livable City.”
NOW WHAT?
No it isn’t
Just curious. Who was in charge when we earned that distinction (multiple times)? Try again.
A.B.
Doesn’t matter
Nothing is going to stop Gainey from being re-elected. It’s naive to think otherwise. Downtown could slide into the Mon and he’s still winning 80 percent of the vote.
MICHAEL DAVID
Compare size
Bigger towns tend to offer more cultural resources, not necessarily better but more. More crime also follows & often pollution. Such is life when you compare small/mid vs big cities.
MICHAEL HUGHES
Wonderful Philly
Philadelphia has slums that are frightening and have existed for many years. However, Center City Philadelphia is wonderful and I really think it can’t be compared to Pittsburgh. In Philadelphia, many people live in Center City. It’s a walkable city with excellent public transportation from all regions of the metropolitan area.
Pittsburgh really has less in the way of public transportation — especially from the suburbs. Also, the fact that few people live in Downtown Pittsburgh means the city shuts down early, while in Philly people walk around much later.
I always thought the terrain of Pittsburgh -— the rivers squeeze downtown into a small, geographically awkward triangle —- put limitations on its development. Walking and driving in Pittsburgh, with the angled and one-way streets and shifting numbers is disorienting while Philadelphia is a logical, easy to navigate grid.
KATELYN
Occupied space
Pittsburgh never developed a residential community Downtown because there was only so much space available and a robust array of corporate headquarters and supporting businesses occupied all of it.
BRADLEY EASTERDAY
Alpha fears
The alpha male urge to be scared of downtown cities.
SORRY, YOU’RE WRONG
Capitalist effect
Hate to tell you, but homelessness and income inequality along with the soaring corporate profits with no give back to address mental health and immigration, homelessness issues is the culprit here.
This is a society problem, not a political one. Until we get our priorities straight as a nation, and on the state level, as well as local level, we will have these problems.
It is one of the bad side effects of capitalism. We just need better guardrails and more money and resources put toward our problems. I know my son still lives at home, as well as all my friends’ kids, because of the enormous costs of rent or homes, no matter how much you make, unless you make over $70K.
BUDROW
The city has warts
Pittsburgh certainly has its warts, Larry, but it isn’t worse than Philadelphia.
JOHN FRANKO




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.