“The U.S. National Strategy to Counter Antisemitism would mobilize federal and state officials, educational institutions, community and religious organizations, and the private sector to talk about the contributions of Jewish Americans, teach about the Holocaust, and come together to speak out against antisemitism and other hate” (Jonathan D. Salant, “A tragic pivotal moment,” May 26).
America is a democracy. It is ruled by laws designed to provide equal protection for all. But America does not extend that protection, equally, to its Jewish citizens. Instead of passing laws to protect them against persecution, it proposes discussions of how Jews are nice people and we ought to “tolerate” them. And we all know how well the “go to coffee with some Jews” approach has worked in the past. We’ve tried it, it hasn’t worked, it’s time to move on and resort to an approach that has teeth in it — the law.
There are those who maintain that suppression of antisemitic activity would be an infringement on the right to free speech. United States’ court rulings say otherwise, taking the position that advocacy of force or criminal activity does not receive First Amendment protections if the advocacy is directed to inciting or producing imminent lawless actions and is likely to incite or produce such action. Antisemitism incites violent action, including murder, and is, therefore, not protected speech.
Propagation of antisemitism is a crime. It should be treated as such. That requires laws, not pep talks.
Paul A. Alter
Wilkinsburg





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.