In “Is Donald Trump’s MAGA movement true American populism, or a fake?” (Mar. 23), Gillis Harp describes Donald Trump as a fake populist. I appreciated his perspective and understood his arguments. But he pointed out the failings of democratic leaders in a misguided effort to appear fair and balanced.
By giving credence to Trump’s fake populism with the unmerited and off-topic Democratic examples, the professor rationalized, excused, and normalized Trump’s behavior. The basic concept he conveyed was that “all politicians are fake or lie” which is too simplistic and a fallacy and invites the electorate to be apathetic. There are lots of human beings of true character and morals, and yes, some of them are politicians that deserve our vote.
Harp finished his essay with the out of left field, mud-slinging statement “Furthermore, the ill-concealed disrespect that cosmopolitan Democratic leaders show for the local loyalties and traditional religious faith of working-class Americans stands in stark contrast with original Populist leaders.”
Not sure to whom he’s referring, but it’s disingenuous and again takes the focus away from the point that Trump is not and never was a populist. On the contrary, his goal was only narcissistic self- aggrandizement.
Anna Marie Pavone
South Side Flats





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.