In “Amid turmoil, Israel shows signs of blinking on judicial overhaul” (Mar. 20), the writer stated, “They [changes] would also allow him [the prime minister] to reinstate his longtime ally Aryeh Deri, the leader of an ultra-orthodox party who was removed from his job as both health and interior minister because of multiple criminal convictions.” This is an indirect result. The supreme court ruled Deri’s appointment was “highly unreasonable” due to past convictions. Does Israel have a law making “highly unreasonable” a crime?
About the only thing that Israel’s and the U.S.’s high courts have in common are two words: Supreme Court. Neither Israel’s president nor prime minister nominate potential justices to the court, nor do legislators confirm or reject nominees. Legal briefs do not have to be filed for the court to consider a case; it can pick to review any law it chooses. Also, plaintiffs can skip lower courts and go directly to Israel’s Supreme Court to sue a defendant.
Needed changes to laws governing Israel’s Supreme Court will only strengthen Israel’s democracy. However, the changes should be negotiated and brought for a legislative vote. But if one side will not negotiate, the Knesset will probably only have the ruling coalitions’ recommendations to consider.
Stuart V. Pavilack
Point Breeze
Mr. Pavilack is the executive director of the
Zionist Organization of America: Pittsburgh.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.