Governor DeWine’s comments are a ludicrous knee jerk reaction (“East Palestine residents and officials are still reeling from the aftermath of the train derailment,” Feb. 15). The Emergency Planning and Community Right-to-Know Act (EPCRA) establishes requirements for a facility to provide information necessary for developing and implementing state and local chemical emergency response plans, and requirements for emergency notification of chemical releases involving highly hazardous materials.

Vinyl chloride is not a listed Highly Hazardous Material. This program is administered by EPA, NOT DOT, or Federal Railroad Administration.

Recent statistics show the vast majority of hazardous materials shipped by rail tank car every year arrive safely and without incident. There are approximately 1.7 million shipments of hazardous materials by rail, with just 29 train accidents in which 47 hazardous material cars released some amount of hazardous material. The risk of a release was a tiny fraction of a percent (47/​1,700,000, or 0.0028 percent).

EPCRA applies to fixed facilities. With approximately 1.7 million shipments of hazardous materials every year, you want the railroads to notify every community along its rout of every train carrying hazardous materials? Incidents occur, that’s why state and local emergency management agencies develop plans for dealing with all hazard incidents including hazardous materials.

Advertise with us

These plans appeared to have worked well in the East Palestine response.

Anthony Gaglierd

Munhall