David Shribman’s “Debunking America’s myths” (Jan. 15) extends the analysis of the book “Myth America” to debunk several myths that many Americans embrace. The first, “Congress is an expression of democratic values,” is belied by the fiasco surrounding the start of our 118th Congress.

Similarly, evidence suggests the Pennsylvania General Assembly has not operated as a representative democracy for years. Instead, its procedural rules empower a handful of leaders to prioritize partisan outcomes over voters’ issues. The new report “Dysfunction by Design” from Fair Districts PA documents the General Assembly’s sad record.

Partisan leaders’ latest procedural trick misuses the state constitution to further erode the democratic process. This past week, the PA Senate passed three bundled constitutional amendments (SB1). Two can be traced to a partisan maneuver they began pursuing after the governor vetoed a highly partisan elections bill in 2021 (HB1300).

By recasting selected failed partisan legislation as constitutional amendments, majority leaders are attempting to enact partisan policy unilaterally, without bipartisan legislative support or the governor’s signature. The governor cannot veto a constitutional amendment. Provided it passes with a simple majority in two legislative sessions, it lands directly on the ballot (usually during low-turnout elections), where it rarely fails.

Advertise with us

Some of our state legislators argue that constitutional amendments “let the people decide.” Don’t buy it. The legislators touting “let the people decide” are the same ones vested in a broken process that impedes bipartisan collaboration and effectively silences voters’ voices.

What the “let the people decide” state legislators are really pushing is one-party rule. Let’s call on them to restore true representative government instead.

Karen Calhoun

Jenner Township