It is unfortunate that your article Pittsburgh and Pa.’s unreported FBI crime stats did not investigate the analysis of the crime data (“Pittsburgh and Pa.’s unreported FBI crime stats create gaps and raise critical concerns about police transparency,” Dec. 12). Perhaps a follow-up article would be helpful.

I expect that data collection will be re-started. But will we take this opportunity to change how we analyze the data? We must use more rigorous methods to know if initiated programs led to significant change.

In Pittsburgh between 2011 and 2022, there was a high of 65 Criminal Homicides (2014) and a low of 36 (2019). In 2021 and 2022, the incidents were about 50 each year, which coincidentally is about the 10 year average.

Eyeballing this ten year data, we can expect 40 to 60 homicides in Pittsburgh per year. What does it mean if our homicides in 2023 go from 50 to 60 or 50 to 40? It suggests business as usual. The number of homicides can simply vary that much in a given year. If a program was introduced, it likely had no impact, either way.

Advertise with us

The key point is this data needs to be analyzed using the same research techniques that are used in industry and academia, that require a high level of confidence that the program is working. While not a statistician, my experience comes mostly from my work in industry, where many of our new program efforts had to demonstrate that the change we were introducing performed at the 95% confidence level. This is good stewardship for our programs in Pittsburgh and the use of our tax dollars.

We will still have an unfortunate flaw. The people collecting the data are the same ones that are designing and implementing the program. The good news is that this concern is recognized and officers are trained in collecting data. Having said that, from my perspective bias is always a concern in this model.

You may not be aware, but this data is available to the public.

I analyzed 5 years of data, on a block by block basis, in a 1 by 2 mile neighborhood in another city I was living at the time. This deep dive provided a real appreciation for the type of crime and the location where it happened. This helped me learn that our urban neighborhood was mostly safe and with a few precautions, I could make it safer.

Dave Fine

Shadyside