Dr. Oz is running a commercial criticizing John Fetterman for reducing the penalty for felony-murder via pardons from the Board of Pardons. Pennsylvania has the highest number of inmates serving life without parole sentences (over 6,000) of any state in the country. Most of those individuals are serving first degree sentences for committing a murder. More than 1,100 are serving the same sentence despite the fact that they didn’t commit a murder.

The current sentencing scheme gives life without parole for the perpetrator of a homicide and any associates to the crime. Thus if an individual is a driver of the getaway car in a robbery gone bad, he or she gets the same sentence as the perpetrator of the murder. Any individual tangentially involved gets the same sentence.

Black defendants have a 21 times greater chance than whites to be convicted of felony murder. We believe this to be grossly unfair.

John Fetterman is the chairman of the Board of Pardons, which acts as a safety valve for injustices in our criminal justice system. The felony murder cases are frequently reduced by the Board to a set term of years, usually 30 or 40 years. Fetterman has long recognized this injustice and strongly advocated for reduced sentences under these circumstances.

Advertise with us

He also advocates for changing the sentencing laws. There is proposed legislation (HB 135) to address this issue sponsored by Rep. Jordan Harris. We wholeheartedly agree with John and support the legislation.

Angus R. Love

co-chair, Pa. CURE

Narberth