In “Chief Justice John Roberts defends legitimacy of the Supreme Court” (Sept. 10), it seems that Roberts is suggesting that questioning the legitimacy of the Supreme Court is a mistake. It’s not. It would be better if he were more circumspect as to why there are increasing concerns about its legitimacy and how it has become politicized.

For instance take a look at what the Trump-appointed justices said under oath about Roe v. Wade as precedent or “settled law” during their confirmation hearings. They could have simply declined to answer because a case in which that was an issue might come before them (and of course, everyone knew one would).

Look at how Mitch McConnell has manipulated the “Advise and Consent” role of the Senate in the confirmation process since the nomination of Merrick Garland in 2016. Look at the outsized role the Federalist Society has played in promoting nominations of candidates to the federal judiciary, including the Supreme Court. They believe these candidates will advance their political goals, including the acquisition and presumably the expenditure of billions of dollars, much of it “dark money,” thanks in part to the 2010 decision in Citizens United. And look at Leonard Leo, the Federalist Society’s financial point man, who had a direct line to the Trump White House as an “informal adviser.”

Finally, the chief justice ought to take more seriously the need for a Code of Ethics for members of the Supreme Court.

Advertise with us

Bruce L. Wilder

New Orleans