Editor’s note: The Post-Gazette received an unprecedented number of letters in response to the Supreme Court’s overruling of Roe v. Wade in Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization last Friday, June 24. We have collected many of those letters here, in order to present a cross-section of views from around the Pittsburgh region.
Women of color at risk
As an experienced surgical registered nurse and a Millersville University senior nursing student, I see firsthand what poor health outcomes women experience because of health disparities. The Supreme Court overturning Roe V. Wade negatively affects women of color and the low-income population that already are subjected to limited resources and access to sexual and reproductive healthcare.
Women of color have poorer health outcomes than white women in reproductive health. Black women are dying at 3 to 4 times the rate of white women due to pregnancy related issues. This underrepresented high-risk population will now have an even harder time accessing safe and legal abortions, women’s health, education, screenings, and contraceptives.
I wish candidates like Doug Mastriano and Mehmet Oz would share ideas to help with these health disparities that this ruling will exacerbate.
Celeste Rodriguez
Millersville
No grandstanding
No one is talking about reducing the numbers of abortions, or how to assure safety and well-being of born babies. It’s all show, all grandstanding.
First: let’s address reducing the numbers. I can help with that. Living wage. Affordable housing. Lower costs, not wages. Cut the cost of prescription drugs. Assure that everyone has affordable health care.
Cut the cost of childcare. Provide pre-K for three- and four-year-olds. Reduce taxes for the middle class. Raise the minimum wage to $15 an hour; and extend the Child Tax Credit so no one has to raise a family in poverty. Cut energy costs for families by combatting climate change.
President Biden made these suggestions, and many more, in his State of the Union address.
Second: what about the safety and well-being of born babies? Oklahoma Governor Stitt signed into law a bill criminalizing abortion. The attorney general said: “The womb is now in Oklahoma the safest place for a child to be.” What does that say for the time when the child leaves the womb?
Sister Mary Traupman
Allison Park
The partial justices
The Supreme Court should mirror America, but it doesn’t. Twenty percent of Americans practice Catholicism but 78 percent of the sitting justices grew up and were indoctrinated in the Catholic faith, the very same faith that for the past 50 years have fought against abortion, birth control, same sex marriage and conveniently ignored sexual child abuse. Only 30 percent of Americans wanted Roe repealed.
Growing up we were taught in social study classes that Lady Justice is blindfolded to represent impartiality, but this flawed judgement was not impartial. I suggest some of these “impartial justices” should be made to resign immediately.
William Wells
Scott Township
Down to the county
The status quo for Roe vs. Wade couldn’t remain. I think the Supreme Court was aware that Roe’s weak legal reasoning and over-reaching scope was becoming a national vulnerability, should a power hungry individual use that to exploit a voter base in return for unquestioned loyalty.
I had always assumed that Roe would never be overturned and that only way to end abortion was through a cultural change where it is no longer desired. After Roe that culture change is still necessary. I think the next step is to close the gap between those for whom abortion is a political issue to win or lose and those who actually get them. It is difficult to quantify, but I don’t think that many of the women looking for abortions are really that free to choose because of addictions, mental health issues, or external coercion.
Instead of returning to the abortion law to the state level, I’d like to see it at the county or municipality level. Then the focus would be on the people in crisis and what will work for them and not what side can claim victory or campaign contributions.
Mark Sullivan
Forest Hills
We need more justices
When Donald Trump was in office, he and Mitch McConnell made three lifetime appointments to the Supreme Court. McConnell went so far as to defy Ruth Bader Ginsburg’s dying wish — that the next president appoint her replacement — by packing the Court with Amy Coney Barrett just eight days before the 2020 election.
The result? Today’s Supreme Court has been taken over by a hyperpartisan supermajority that just dismantled abortion care in America.
But there’s something we can do. The Judiciary Act of 2021 would add four seats to the Supreme Court — restoring balance to the court. It’s the solution we need to move away from the extremely partisan rulings that now threaten our fundamental freedoms. Recent polling showed that the majority of voters support expanding the court.
Congress has changed the size of the Supreme Court seven times already in our nation’s history. It’s time to do it again. I’m urging our representatives to back this important bill now so we know they want to protect the rights of the American people. The stakes are too high to stay quiet on this important issue.
Tracy Vargo
Ambridge
The man’s burden
Once again you publish a cartoon by Steve Kelly that unveils the gender bias that has become rampant in our society. The Sunday June 26 cartoon shows a mother talking to her daughter about control of her body beginning before pregnancy while a clueless male looks on. This implicitly places the blame for an unwanted pregnancy fully on the woman.
Biology 101, Mr. Kelly. It takes both a man and woman to have a child, but the burden of that pregnancy falls on the woman. Perhaps women wouldn't need abortions if society pressed men to take control of their bodies and to subsequently bear the burden of an unwanted pregnancy. Or perhaps if there were support services for the poor who have children that didn't simultaneously blame them for becoming burdens on society.
Wake up Mr. Kelly. The problem isn't providing safe abortions to those who need them. The problem is a society that has failed the women who need them.
Wendy M. Mars
Oakland
Moral no man’s land
Now that the right to discuss and legislate the particulars of abortion practice has been rightly returned to the states, many “pro-choice” folks are hunkering down in the “grey” areas to evade the moral certainty of the following argument: 1) It is, with rare exception, wrong to kill an innocent, helpless human being; 2) Pre-born humans are helpless, innocent human beings; 3) It is wrong, then, to kill helpless, innocent human beings.
The legal boundaries of the moral, newly exposed No-Man’s-Land will now become more freely a matter of debate and codification. The rare exceptions, by the way, pertain to the tragic cases in which a mother’s continuing her pregnancy will likely kill her. And no state that considers this matter responsibly will require a woman to become a martyr.
William Breckenridge
White Oak
How many children?
One question for those celebrating the overturn of Roe v. Wade: How many unwanted children have you adopted?
David Youse
Bethel Park
Never mind Thomas
I am a pro-life, atheist, LGBT+ law student from Duquesne Law frustrated with the fearmongering about the future of LGBT rights that has resulted from the Dobbs v. Jackson decision.
The majority opinion is the only opinion with legal authority, and Alito made clear that “Nothing in this opinion should be understood to cast doubt on precedents that do not concern abortion.” Not only does Alito validate same-sex marriage by consciously choosing to include them as justification for overturning Roe, but LGBT rights are entirely distinguished from abortion: “Abortion destroys what those decisions [Roe/Casey] call ‘potential life’ and what the law…in this case regards as the life of an ‘unborn human being.’”
Thomas’ concurrence is also misconstrued. He critiques a legal theory known as “substantive due process,” as he has always done. Not only is his opinion without authority, but all citations are to previous concurrences/dissents, which are also without authority (and most of which are from him).
My liberation as a marginalized person does not come from the oppression of others, and neither does yours. An expansion of human rights should be celebrated, not used to further fearmonger marginalized communities.
Kaine Spitak
Downtown
Almost Gilead
Welcome to Gilead, the new Christian Republic, replacing the former United States of America, brought to you by the boys (and girl) of the U.S. Supreme Court. It’s been a long time coming, but finally, white, fundamentalist, Christians have the country they want.
Well, almost. The Court still has to void a few more inconvenient rulings concerning contraception, same-sex marriage, and last, but not least, interracial marriage. But not to worry, Judge Thomas and his posse are riding to the rescue.
I hope all the citizens of the new Republic of Gilead appreciate all that the Court, and by extension, the Republican Party, have done for them over the last fifty years to reverse bodily autonomy, and continue to vote Republican. Until we repeal the right to vote, of course. After all, McConnell, Trump, and Thomas (the new Triumvirate) know what is best.
Bill King
Butler
Maybe not happy
I wonder if McConnell and other centrist GOP leadership are really happy? They no longer have a key culture issue to gin up their base, and they may have awakened a movement that will view this matter as more important than the price of gas. We will find out in November.
Peter Konczakowski
Wexford
Back to the 50s
It is instructive to note that in “Pittsburgh Catholics: Decision marks day of ‘great happiness,’” (June 25), the only rank-and-file Catholics quoted were two old men. I wonder how many people the reporters had to talk to before they could get two quotes that would fit the headline.
Bishop David Zubik is correct that the constitution does not (explicitly) guarantee the right to an abortion, and that is why we need Congress to codify that right, once and for all. All the old men will have to realize that, as much as they would like to, they can’t drag us back to the 1950s.
Diane Averill
Highland Park
Split court
In its action regarding New York’s Gun Law, the court clearly struck a blow for individual rights. The court upheld basic civil and constitutional rights. In its abortion decision, the court struck a mighty blow against individual rights. The court’s seemingly split personality is puzzling.
Alan Schultz
Allison Park
Expanded rights
I am so excited to see that the Supreme Court has ruled in favor of justice for the unborn in the Dobbs v. Jackson decision. This should be seen as a monumental expansion of human rights protections.
I affirm what many pro-life people have been saying in the past week: this work is far from over.
Though we should celebrate this win, we must not begin to ignore the real material conditions that many pregnant people in our communities face that lead them to consider abortion. In this moment it is more important than ever to redouble our efforts to meet the needs of our neighbors, born and unborn.
No pregnant person should have to worry about finding a safe place to sleep at night or be concerned that they will not be able to access the healthcare they deserve. We must do whatever possible to eliminate racism and correct the shameful maternal mortality rates in this country, particularly for black and indigenous mothers.
We must work to decriminalize our response to poverty and mental illness and address the particular needs of incarcerated and detained pregnant people, working toward decarceration whenever possible. The needs of all marginalized and disenfranchised people in our communities must be addressed — our shared human dignity demands it.
Herb Geraghty
The writer is executive director of Rehumanize International
If you have enough
The Republican Party hacks on the Supreme Court who lied and perjured themselves during their confirmation hearings have taken away the right for women to control their own bodies. Simultaneously, they took away the rights of all of us to go to the grocery store without having to pack a gun and kindergarten teachers to teach 5-year-olds without keeping a gun in their desks. They are also likely to take away the rights of all of us to breathe clean air and drink clean water.
The lesson here is that if you have enough money, you can buy off everything, including the Supreme Court. What that means for the rest of us is that we have to live in a country where an enormous amount of misery and suffering is just the way it is, a few people get to hoard all of the wealth and power, and voting can never change either of those immutable facts.
Joe Schreiber
Shaler




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.