Energy Secretary Dan Brouillette, who had a letter published in the PG on Oct. 8 (“Natural Gas Is Key to Pa.’s Economic Future”), came to Pittsburgh recently to extol “the manufacturing comeback across Appalachia driven by abundant, affordable natural gas.”

But where on Earth is the manufacturing comeback he’s talking about? It’s not in Pittsburgh, that’s for sure. Manufacturing employment in the Steel City is at its lowest level in modern history. That’s right: During the decadelong shale boom Mr. Brouillette hypes, the region actually lost thousands of jobs in manufacturing. Meanwhile, cities like Detroit have been adding working-class jobs.

In fact, success stories are hard to find in places that bought into the shale hype. Most of Pennsylvania’s big gas-drilling counties have lost population since 2010, just like Pittsburgh did. Meanwhile, population is booming outside of fracking country, in peer cities like Columbus and Indianapolis, Lexington and Louisville.

Beaver County is an exception, where an uptick in temporary construction jobs at the cracker plant boosted employment, but those won’t last much longer. Full employment at the site will be equivalent to only around 1/​20th of the county’s jobs in in education and health care. Worse yet, not one manufacturing facility located in the region to take advantage of the supposed petrochemical boom.

Advertise with us

Every other petrochemical investment was a fairy tale. The follow-up Exxon project in Beaver? Never materialized. West Virginia’s Braskem project? Vanished. The Appalachia Storage Hub? On ice. The Mountaineer ethane storage project? Nope.

The proposed PTTG cracker plant in Belmont, Ohio, isn’t quite dead yet, but it has lost major investment backing and postponed its final investment decision three times. Financial analysts agree its prospects are grim.

Ten years of data reveal a hard truth: the shale gas and petrochemical industries have failed to deliver prosperity. They have failed to boost total employment and failed to reinvigorate manufacturing. It about time for western Pennsylvania to invest in a different economic course.

ERIC de PLACE

Research Fellow

Advertise with us

Ohio River Valley Institute

Johnstown, Pa.