Speaking as a “gumbander” who returned home to Pittsburgh after living in different states, I find the UPMC and Allegheny Health Network situation chaotic and costly despite claims to the contrary.

The reasons for UPMC and AHN to establish new medical care facilities throughout the region (most recently the announcement of plans for a new facility in Pleasant Hills) are free-market arguments that benefit each health system and not necessarily our community.

We can learn from how this is handled to the community’s benefit in states that require a Certificate of Need.  This is mandated when hospital beds, facilities and medical equipment are either transferred or created.

Patients still have a choice of which hospital system to use, but hospitals and medical facilities are created and relocated based on an analysis of community need rather than pure free-market economics. In the long-run, costs are controlled to the benefit of the community since expensive facilities and equipment such as MRI and CAT scan systems are maximized rather than sitting one mile apart being underutilized in competition with each other.

Advertise with us

I advocate that the state Legislature quickly consider adopting a Certificate of Need program soon to take control of the adversarial situation in the Pittsburgh region and to address similar situations being considered in the central and eastern parts of the commonwealth.

NICHOLAS J. GIANARIS

Bethel Park