Elon Musk was once celebrated in the smart media as a wunderkind, even a genius. He is now widely villainized as a right-wing ideologue.

I want to suggest that he is neither.

But he is right about free speech.

Speech ought to be as free as possible.

Advertise with us

The correct position, the American one, is to be near-absolutist on speech.

This seems to be Mr. Musk’s position, however obnoxiously articulated or incoherently applied.

We also ought to agree that the word genius applies to persons like Mozart, Bach, Rembrandt, Renoir, Jane Austen or Stephen Hawking.

But Mr. Musk still might have a useful idea or two.

For instance, his Hyperloop, the fast-speed locomotive concept, might do more for mass transit than any innovation of the past 100 years.

Advertise with us

And a breakthrough in mass transit — something that gets a lot of people from A to B — in something other than their fossil fuel-based cars, might be a big step in fighting global warming.

It may also not be our best high-speed rail option. But it is one.

But, most important: Mr. Musk, jerk though he may be, or sometimes be, is right about free speech and Twitter.

And a lot of people are wrong about free speech or indifferent to it these days. As the late Nat Hentoff used to say, they are for “free speech for me but not for thee.”

That’s the right and the left.

Advertise with us

The cure for stupid and harmful speech is more speech. Not shutting people up or down.

You either believe that — believe in the evolution and triumph of free speech and ideas — or you are led inevitably to the regulation of thought, and souls.

Mr. Musk has restored Donald Trump to Twitter. And for this he will likely never be forgiven.

Well, Donald Trump has done more harm to the fabric of American civility, to what used to be the Republican Party, and to the American presidency, than any single person in our history. I don’t think one can honestly dispute that.

But it does not follow that he should be denied access to a public forum.

Advertise with us

He still has First Amendment rights as an American citizen.

Twitter is not a publication. A publication should be curated for what its owners and editors regard as truth and maybe even, though rarely, enlightenment. And untruths, as well as factual errors, should and must be corrected.

Twitter is a forum — a modern American Hyde Park. Not a publication. If Mr. Trump speaks falsely, or fantastically falsely, it is for the next speaker to refute.

Mind you, even a forum, especially an electronic forum, needs some ground rules and moderation. A bully cannot be allowed to dominate time and space or shout another speaker down.

But hate speech must be strictly and narrowly defined: Advocating violence against one group or another, for example, with aid from racial or ethnic slurs, is hate speech.

Advertise with us

Hate speech is not speech by anyone whom the moderator loathes or suspects has hate in his heart.

Mr. Trump, for example, engages in nonsense and deceitful and dishonest speech but not, generally, hate speech.

(Though calling the press the enemy of the people is certainly incendiary, censorship is a slippery slope. Should the legitimate, curated press not report Mr. Trump’s incendiary remarks?)

So, if Elon Musk is near-absolutist on free speech, and brings this value to Twitter, good for him. He got that one right.

He was right, for example, to restore Jordan Peterson’s speech rights to Twitter. Not only on principle, but because banning Mr. Peterson shows the consequence of getting the principle wrong.

Advertise with us

The principle is free inquiry and discussion.

It is not: Some thought offends many people.

Or, some thought offends a few people deeply.

Some people are offended at talk of trans teens. Some at talk of controlling our borders.

The American answer is: Get over it.

Advertise with us

Engage. Talk back. Maybe even listen.

Not all that offends is intolerable or logically untenable.

Not all that offends, in one moment in time, is the linguistic or moral equivalent of throwing a brick — or yelling fire in a crowded theater.

We must err, when we err, on the side of speech.

Mr. Peterson has been absolutely bludgeoned on social media as a misogynist, a white supremacist and a person of the far right.

Advertise with us

He is none of those things.

He is an arrogant intellectual. And he can be harsh, insensitive and full of himself.

But that does not justify maligning and banishing him.

Moreover, he is also a real thinker and arbiter of important concepts and questions — like the psychology of myth and faith, character, emotional maturity and positive masculinity.

His “sin” is his unwillingness to buckle on the matter of gender pronouns, which I gather he thinks are both dumb and dishonest.

Advertise with us

Personally, I think he is a little hung up on the matter, and the pronoun controversy is less interesting than Mr. Peterson’s study of Jung. I also think he is being unkind. But he is entitled to his view.

And clearly this is a person who should be heard.

Unlike Mr. Trump, Mr. Peterson contributes to collective intellectual and moral life.

But, the point is that, in a free society, no one gets to have the final say about who has a bit of the truth and who does not. It’s impossible to draw sharp lines between the Trumps of the world and the Petersons, at least in all cases. No one is wise enough to draw those lines.

We have to let it run. And keep talking. And searching.

Advertise with us

And that’s partly because both the majority and the elites often get it wrong in the moment. We turn out to be wrong about who someone is; what the situation was; and what seemed true then and what might seem obviously true now.

We always see partially, as “through a glass darkly.” This is the basic problem of human knowledge, understanding and communication, exaggerated, I would say, by short range, reactive and social media.

We only correct our myopia, our temporary blindness, by keeping the ongoing conversation about human knowledge and perception ongoing and dynamic, through time.

Keith C. Burris is the former editor, vice president and editorial director of Block Newspapers (burriscolumn@gmail.com).