One of the very real ramifications of our nation being enthralled in an ongoing political soap opera is that public policy gets short shrift.
Let’s define public policy this way: The application of principles and reason to the amelioration of our common problems.
And the way to think about public policy is as a process, even an ongoing conversation.
For whether we are talking about hunger and malnutrition or how to deal with China, there is no static solution. Conditions change. And we learn as we do.
Finally, the instruments of public policy, most of the time, are state, local and national government.
Non-government organizations, churches and philanthropists are often key supporting players. But, generally speaking, it is government that must formulate and implement public policy.
So, how are we doing with public policy in America today?
I think perhaps more poorly than ever in my lifetime.
And I think I know why.
In our lack of public policy seriousness we see the real costs of our political tribalism.
For example: No one on the right is allowed to care about global warming or saving the earth. This at a moment when the earth is crying out in agony. I cannot see, for the life of me, why a true conservative would not want to conserve the planet. But there it is.
The same is true of gun control. There is no other public problem that Americans say cannot be ameliorated (there is that word again) from cancer to unsafe cars. How can it be conservative to do nothing when children are slaughtered in their schools? What other right does the right wing view as absolute?
At the same time, many folks on the left cannot acknowledge that a city without police officers would be a very dangerous place. Or that, though gun availability and the types of guns we allow to be manufactured and sold should be limited, a cop in a school with a gun could be a very useful thing. Why would a liberal not want a woman who is being stalked by a violent abuser to know self-defense as well as, if she desires, how to use a gun?
Our ideological boxes and tribes keep us from conversing and from thinking.
And from making good public policy.
This brings me to the president’s student loan relief program, which is a good thing in that it will bring some relief to many young people, including two of my children.
But it is not good public policy.
First, where is the relief for the people who paid off huge debt at great personal cost? Or whose parents or grandparents took second mortgages or depleted life savings for a kid’s college?
But, mostly, the Biden student loan forgiveness program fails as public policy because it does not deal with the problem — the heart of the matter.
The heart of the matter is the exorbitant cost of higher education in America; what you get for the debt.
The heart of the matter is that a BA in religious studies, political science or business at a cost of $100,000 is simply not worth the money. It is like paying $450 for a tie or $50,000 for a used Ford Focus. Stupidly, wildly uneconomical.
Loan forgiveness does nothing about that.
Higher education, its price and its funding must be reformed.
Pressure must be brought upon public universities not only to contain but to reduce costs. A major way to do this is to reduce college to three years.
Also, states need to start subsidizing public universities again. The feds do too.
If there were federal money to forgive loans for graduates who are underwater there should be federal money to prevent future graduates from acquiring crippling and idiotic debt.
There are at least nine European countries where college is either free or very, very inexpensive. In many of those countries — Germany, Iceland and Poland for example — it is sometimes cheaper for an American to go there than here.
It is not too much to ask that a college degree be affordable and useful.
But this is not the public policy discussion we have had or are having.
A final example: Homelessness.
Again, we are not getting to the heart of the matter.
It’s a growing national problem, deeply intertwined with a nationwide mental health crisis.
Too many of the homeless have nowhere to go on a permanent basis and the large number of homeless who suffer from mental illness are not getting ongoing treatment.
The right’s solution is to ignore the problem or view the homeless as invisible or surplus human beings.
But the fact that some of the cities with the most acute problem are marquee liberal and left-leaning cities shows that we have not figured this problem out yet. Not even close.
Shelters alone are not the answer. “Rapid rehousing” alone is not the answer. And shipping a homeless man to an apartment in the suburbs where he has no support system and no resources does not work.
We need new models, and not just one approach that someone deems an answer.
We need to try small clinics that do both housing and mental health navigation.
We need pop-up mental health clinics and workers.
We need crisis intervention cops, who, with the help of a judge, will get a violent or law breaking person into treatment.
We need compassionate companions who are willing to walk with people who are not ready to be “fixed.”
Most of all, we need to acknowledge the depth and chronic nature of the problem. In Pittsburgh, where the homeless population seems to be growing more severe, there is considerable aid, especially for food, but no real plan. A few people on city council have noticed and want to create a plan. But meaningful action is long overdue.
We need a dispassionate, non-ideological discussion about policy and amelioration.
Our distraction and our echo chambers are making us dumber, delaying or crippling useful action and hurting people.
Keith C. Burris is the former editor, vice president and editorial director of Block Newspapers (burriscolumn@gmail.com).





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.