Did you catch former President Barack Obama's admonition the other day?
Woke, he said, is not enough.
He said that making judgments about other people and issuing edicts of purity are unhelpful in politics and, really, a kind of anti-politics.
Politics, he suggested, is about getting things done and that requires working with people who see the world differently than you do. (Some of his critics might say that the president talked that game better than he played it. But at least he knew what he was supposed to do — what all our leaders and public officials are supposed to do.)
Life, Mr. Obama said, is complex because people are. Remember, Mr. Obama told his audience, conservatives love their kids, too. Public policy is at least as complex as life. And social progress comes in small steps forward and sometimes reactive large steps backward.
These thoughts seem like almost incontrovertible common sense. But they fell on mostly deaf ears.
Read More
We are living in an upside-down time. The sensible has no firm standing. The fact becomes a bone of contention. And complexity does not have a deep constituency — in either party's core or in the mainstream or alternative media. There is very little gray.
I am not sure that Barack Obama could be nominated by the Democratic Party today. Most of the declared candidates see him as too centrist and compromising. Someone occupying the rhetorical or policy center, even slightly left of center but still center, without Mr. Obama's charisma, would almost certainly have a hard road to the nomination.
Pete Buttigieg is about to find that out.
Indeed, one of the firebrand liberals in the U.S. House said the nomination of Mayor Pete would be “tragic.”
And Mayor Pete himself described the presidency of Mr. Obama, while praising it, as the last presidency of the Reagan era.
Mike Bloomberg? Tell me where he wins a primary. Show me his core constituency in the Democratic Party. He is qualified. He is a person who could actually govern. But I can scarcely imagine him being nominated.
For the Democrats are in the grip of single, unifying visions. And one very popular one right now is: Rich guys are the problem. They should not exist, let alone govern.
There is an illusion reinvented constantly through the ages — it is that a new, truly enlightened age is upon us; a time without folly, self-delusion and self-destruction. All we need to find it is to eliminate the wrong ideas (and people) and uncover the right and true big idea.
We human beings have been telling ourselves this periodically since the Enlightenment.
Some of us told ourselves this in the 1960s: We are about to see the birth of a new politics and a new journalism. The young shall lead the way.
For young people see through dishonesty and are pure and uncorrupted. Maturity and society have not yet spoiled them. Mayor Pete recently voiced this view.
But is this true? Does youth really come with built-in virtue, any more than age comes with built-in wisdom?
How do the 1960s look now?
The late George Harrison once told of going to Haight-Ashbury in the 1960s to see what liberation looked like. He said he found a lot of stoned slobs who had not bathed recently and had ruined their teeth.
We had another version of the new world coming when Mr. Obama was elected in 2008. Hope is always good. And change is often necessary and sometimes good. But many Americans thought Mr. Obama would usher in a trans-political era of good feeling — no more racism or racial posturing; no more economic recessions; no more exploitation or nastiness in politics.
Maybe it would have been better to concentrate on two or three decent pieces of legislation.
The expectation of a radically different politics, country, human race flows from the conviction (wish) that there be “answers” and “solutions.”
If only we eliminated corporate greed, or #MeToo behavior, or money in politics, or globalism, or secularism, or racism, or poverty, or Donald Trump, all would be well.
The desire is that there be one big idea, the magic key, that embodies all solution and from which all progress flows — the guaranteed annual income, the new Bill of Rights, the Green New Deal, the single-payer medical insurance system, or universal pre-K, or universal free college.
There is more than naivete and more than dime-store Utopianism at work in this quest. We are dominated by hedgehogs — a confederacy of hedgehogs.
“The fox knows many things, but the hedgehog knows one big thing.” That's what Isaiah Berlin said.
We Americans are alternately pulled toward each polarity, but the pull toward the single vision — the hedgehog — is stronger. We know, deep down, that eliminating one big problem won't cure all that ails us, and adopting a grand vision and adhering to it will not heal and uplift us. Yet we fall for one “answer” after another. Such is the allure of the big idea. Such is the romance of the hedgehog.
Berlin said that Tolstoy was the greatest fox in the history of literature or thought. He saw infinite complexity and shades of gray. But what he longed for was the one great truth, answer, solution. He longed to be a hedgehog.
So do we Americans, especially in tough or dark times. Democracy is premised on multiple truths and a boundless variety of people, thought and expression. But free people, perhaps because freedom can be terrifying, are constantly tempted by the one big thing that will save them.
Lincoln was a fox. So was FDR. Huey Long and Joe McCarthy were hedgehogs. George Orwell was a fox and so was Churchill. The folks at Breitbart and The Nation are hedgehogs. The choice should be easy. History shows us that it isn't.
Keith C. Burris is executive editor of the Post-Gazette, and vice president and editorial director of Block Newspapers (kburris@post-gazette.com).






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.