Every presidential election is its own puzzle. But in every presidential election two things happen: The party pros, the opinion elites and large chunks of the national press pick favorites, while the voters — the people, damn them — muck up the plan.
The elites usually pick a horse-race favorite and they also pick a “thinking man's” favorite — the man or woman who would be president if the right people ran the world.
(According to lore, Adlai Stevenson told a lady who gushed that every thinking person was for him: “Yes, madam, but I need a majority.”)
The smart people with the smart money are usually wrong.
The elites knew — knew — that Dewey would defeat Truman.
And they knew Hillary would defeat The Donald.
Read More
Democracy, thank God, is still messy and surprising.
This should reassure us — the people are still sovereign.
And capable of rebellion. Polling, really since Ronald Reagan in 1980, has been getting less and less reliable.
In recent years, it seems that many polled have either lied or declined to respond.
So it is downright dangerous to be an early, anointed front-runner: You could ask Ed Muskie if he were still living, or Big John Connelly if he were, or Rudy Guiliani, or Jeb Bush, or, now, Joe Biden.
Out front is not a safe place to be.
It's not good to be the egghead candidate either. Every four years the editorial writers and columnists anoint one of these, and the list of the favored but forgotten is long: Paul Simon, John Anderson, Bruce Babbitt, Bill Bradley, Jim Webb, John Kasich. Being the thinking candidate for president is like being an intellectual talk show host or the smartest bear in the zoo. The voters almost never care.
Instead, the voters usually surprise us. Starting in Iowa.
In 1976, a little known former Georgia governor and peanut farmer came out of Iowa and shocked the establishment. Averell Harriman said, “He can't be president, I've never met him.”
But Jimmy Carter did become president, and the establishment did not help him. Nor did he help himself much. (He put on a Mister Rogers sweater and said we had “malaise.”)
The front-runner in '76 was supposed to be Henry Jackson, a hawkish labor senator from Washington state. When he faltered, Hubert Humphrey was supposed to stop Mr. Carter. He could not and did not, and neither did the then-young and white hot Jerry Brown.
Voters kept voting for Jimmy Carter.
The thinking man's candidate that year was a run-of-the-mill liberal congressman named Mo Udall, who was known and loved in Washington mostly for being a nice guy with a sense of humor. But like Mr. Kasich in 2016, Udall could not win anywhere but on “Meet the Press.”
Mayor Pete Buttigieg reminds me of Mr. Carter back in '75 and ‘76. He is articulate, self-possessed, complex and contained. Like Mr. Carter then, and like Barack Obama at this stage 12 years ago, he projects moderation and sincerity, and he also has an eye for the jugular.
Mayor Pete doesn’t yell. He speaks in full sentences and, thus, complete thoughts.
Like Mr. Carter then, he is non-ideological and could appeal across a wide spectrum.
The kingmakers in the press have noticed Mayor Pete’s raw talent and there is evidence to suggest that his pivot to the center is paying off.
He is the best debater in the field.
But, most of all, like Mr. Carter in 1976 and Mr. Obama in 2008, Mayor Pete is new, when the country is worn out and down.
And like Mr. Carter then, he is, though brilliant, profoundly inexperienced. South Bend, Ind., is all of 100,000 people. Being mayor of New York might prepare you for the presidency. But the mayor of South Bend?
Yet Mayor Pete could be the Iowa surprise this year.
The scenario runs something like this: Mr. Biden tanks in Iowa and Mayor Pete comes in a surprise first or a strong second. The wind will be at his back and many right-thinkers in his pocket. The center lane will be his.
He will also have money. Mayor Pete is already a prodigious fundraiser.
As for Elizabeth Warren, she is the front-runner now, with many innings, slings and arrows to go. And most of her academic and suburban supporters could live happily with Pete as the Democratic nominee.
But it is just as possible that Mayor Pete is a creation of the commentariat, a candidate who never catches fire — that he is more Udall than Carter. Where is the evidence that he can appeal to labor union members or African Americans, for example?
In any case, someone will surprise us in Iowa and that will change New Hampshire, which, in turn, will change the national contest for the nomination.
If you think politics is rational, consider a candidate for the toughest job in the world who is 78 and just had a heart attack.
Or a 37-year-old mayor of the fourth-largest city in Indiana who could not get elected state treasurer.
Both are vying to be leader of the free world.
It takes a different breed of cat. Jimmy Carter followed Lester Maddox to the governorship of Georgia. Term limited, Lester next ran for lieutenant governor. Jimmy, in the same predicament, chose to run for president — the ultimate act of chutzpah. Or in Mr. Obama's word, “madness.”
The critical transition for a long-shot candidate is going from being perceived as delusional to being perceived as new. It is entirely possible to be both.
Keith C. Burris is executive editor of the Post-Gazette, and vice president and editorial director of Block Newspapers (kburris@post-gazette.com).






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.