Maybe you missed it and, if so, it's worth a Google search — the Ellen-George W. moment.

We need more of them.

What happened is that Ellen DeGeneres and her spouse attended a Dallas Cowboys football game as guests of the Jones family (owners of the team). And Ellen sat next to former President George W. Bush. And — sin of all sins in the era of uber-correctness and political tribalism — they clowned around and enjoyed the day and the game together.

What then happened, in Ellen's telling, is that a lot of people got angry and “they did what people do when they are angry: they tweet.”

Advertise with us

But the great thing was that Ellen staunchly defended herself. She said that she did not have a litmus test for friends. She wants to live in a society in which people can be friends in spite of the different ways they experience the world.

Come to think of it, isn't this what society is? A plurality of backgrounds, perception and ideas, all interacting, not as enemies but friends?

And is this not what friendship is? Two people who are not alike finding something to enjoy and admire in the other?

Maybe Ellen likes W. for his sense of humor, or admires his quiet, dogged work with wounded vets.

I contend this: For the politics of a free society to work, we need something akin to friendship in the public sphere.

Advertise with us

Free societies need the right structures. And the Madisonian structure of this country is second to none. It checks power with power, horizontally (separate branches) and vertically (federalism).

But we also need “the spirit of the laws,” and that spirit is the spirit of compassionate citizenship — the neighbor.

Compassionate citizenship allows one to say: We are friends anyway. Or, in matters of deep political disagreement, “we will seek fairness anyway.”

To do this, we must apply “the other foot” test.

I first became familiar with this test some years ago when I read a piece called “What Did They Say When It Was a Democratic War?” It was about Democratic congressmen, and especially senators, during the Vietnam war, and how precious few of them spoke up when Lyndon B. Johnson was president. Yet, when Richard Nixon became president, when he owned the war, virtually every Democratic member of Congress became an outspoken dove.

Advertise with us

If you put the shoe on the other foot, you are almost compelled to be compassionate, or at least fair.

Think about what the Democrats would have said if the intelligence community during the George W. Bush administration had been spying on the presidential campaign of Barack Obama.

They would have cried foul. They would have spoken of abuse of power. And they would have called such abuse totalitarian — the mark of a police state, not one under control of the Constitution and the people.

They would have been right.

There was this sort of abuse under Nixon. The president had an “enemies list,” and so did the head of the FBI. J. Edgar Hoover spied on Martin Luther King and most of the leaders of the anti-war movement.

Advertise with us

If this was a shameful low under Hoover and Nixon, the spying on Donald Trump's campaign in 2016 was a shameful low under Mr. Obama and James Comey.

Think about what Republicans in Congress would have said if Mr. Obama, as president, had solicited help from a foreign government in investigating Mitt Romney, his eventual opponent in 2012. We would have heard the cries of impeachment from the halls of the Capitol without the benefit of any electronic megaphone whatsoever.

Impeachment seems to me to be one of few errors of the Founders, possibly a calamitous one. That's because impeachment is so vaguely defined and because it weaponizes political disagreement. Once we start saying our political opponents should be “locked up” (Mr. Trump unleashed the hounds that now dog him) we have lost the spirit of compassionate citizenship. Maybe for a long time.

Back in the Watergate days, a lot of people wanted Richard Nixon to go to jail. Not me. I thought Nixon should resign his office. But I thought Gerald Ford was a profile in courage, and truly presidential, when he put the healing of the nation first.

Was the pardon fair? To me, it was just because it was compassionate — for the nation as well as Nixon. And compassion is something we needed then and need now. For the nation.

Advertise with us

That means that occasionally someone in public life has to break the mold, defy the tribe and show some courage.

I have two favorite recent profiles in courage. One was when Republican John McCain defended Democrat John Kerry's war record. The other was when former Toledo, Ohio, Mayor Jack Ford, the city's first African American mayor, now deceased, defended then mayoral candidate, ex-beat cop and later mayor Mike Collins (also now deceased) against the charge of racism. What was so admirable was that, unlike McCain and Mr. Kerry, Ford and Collins were not friends. They didn't like each other much at all.

That's principle. And that's fairness anyway.

Keith C. Burris is executive editor of the Post-Gazette and editorial director of Block Newspapers (kburris@post-gazette.com).