Three conversations. And three warnings. Cautionary tales. Or so they seemed to me. There may be rough seas ahead.
The first conversation was with a veteran public servant. Holding public meetings is like breathing to him. But he doesn't want to do them anymore. He feels like he is facing a mob each time he holds one. People emote. They rail. "They just yell,” he said. “No one wants to hear me or converse."
I thought of Sen. Eugene McCarthy telling a friend some years ago that he was going to call his next book, "Nobody's Listening."
And people then, in the late 1960s and early 1970s, were not as angry as they are today.
I thought of Reinhold Niebuhr's book, "Moral Man and Immoral Society." People do in groups what they would never do or say one-on-one. People say on social media what they would never, ever say to someone's face — at least if they are normal people and not sociopaths.
The internet is a mass gathering — and an instrument of mobs. And too many of us are turning into members of angry electronic and ideological mobs.
Read More
Nobody's listening.
And I thought of retired Marine Gen. James Mattis (the former secretary of Defense and so called “warrior monk”). He has a book just out. But what he says about military and foreign policy is not as important as what he has to say about domestic politics: We'd better learn to listen to each other again, and respect each other again, and accept and respect our differences, or we will tear our beloved country down.
Conversation No. 2: I spoke on the phone with a very old friend and someone you would not suspect of having a soft spot for Donald Trump. Indeed, I doubt many of his other friends and colleagues suspect it, because he is no fool and not about to be “canceled” by old classmates and professional associates and family over politics. He is a novelist, a scholar, a Ph.D. — a retired professor. He is a highly literary and cultured man. And he lives on the West Coast. He said this about the president: I think he is doing a credible job. I think most of his foreign policy decisions have been sound. I think he is learning and moderating.
These statements would drive at least 50% of those who heard them to red-faced rage, maybe even temporary insanity.
He also said of the president: "He's crazy."
How to reconcile the two positions?
This way — with this amazing statement: "I trust Trump's instincts over the totality of official Washington's wisdom."
There it is.
In other words, the elites have not been toppled or reformed yet. They still don't get it and still cannot be relied upon to listen, adapt, or change. What they say and think at the Brookings Institution, The Washington Post, the World Bank, the Democratic Club and the Madison Hotel in Washington is not only a world removed from middle America, but middle America no longer believes any of it it.
Interventionism, internationalism and “free trade” are widely agreed upon in Washington. But in much of the rest of country, these pillars of conventional wisdom look like colossal, tragic failures that have cost us dearly in lives and treasure.
Many independent voters don't believe in our elites any more. They don't believe in their assumptions or solutions.
My friend is not a "deplorable," he is a highly nuanced observer of our politics. He would prefer Bernie Sanders, he told me. But he doubts Mr. Sanders will be the Democratic nominee. Could he vote for Mr. Trump's re-election? He certainly could. He does not want to go back to the establishment — the Clintons and the Bushes and a government that is of, by and for an arrogant and still clueless ruling elite. He told me that the left's failure to accept the outcome of the last election seemed to him far worse than any of the president's feuds or outrageous tweets.
Conversation No. 3 was with a patriot, a soldier who now does holy work. He helps the down and out — feeds them, prays with them, walks with them. I asked him a question I didn't know I was going to ask and had not planned to ask: Do you feel optimistic about the country?
Some years ago, an old pal of mine asked a car full of men that question as we were driving home from a University of Michigan football game. It took us all by surprise and rendered us all temporarily speechless, just as I took myself by surprise by asking it these many years later.
Do you feel optimistic about the country?
The good man just shook his head no.
When people don't believe in God any more, he said, don't believe enough to take time to worship God and give thanks, it's pretty hard to get them to treat each other well; to do justice in small ways or large. It's hard just to get them to obey the law and behave civilly.
So we need a moral and religious awakening?
We do.
It is unlikely to come from the traditional churches as now constituted. It is perhaps unlikely to come from any one source.
Americans are divided and alienated. We have little confidence in each other, or in our institutions, and less in our leaders. The faith that many hold in Mr. Trump is an act of desperation: Clean it out. Drain the swamp.
But that has not even begun to happen and the swamp is broad and deep.
We need, to begin, a national healing and we know it will probably not come from our politics which, in the short run, may get more divisive and absurd. Maybe we start with small acts of kindness and by creating enclaves for listening.
Keith C. Burris is executive editor of the Post-Gazette and editorial director of Block Newspapers (kburris@post-gazette.com).






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.