The attorney general of the United States gave an interview to Jan Crawford, the legal correspondent for CBS News, a few days ago and caused the heads of many people to explode.

The Honorable William Barr is being excoriated by the left, indeed he is the whipping boy of the moment.

Some say this is an attempt at pre-emptive discrediting because Mr. Barr wants to know how “spying,” on the Trump campaign in 2016 by U.S. intelligence agencies got started.

He told a rather visibly aghast Ms. Crawford that spying was indeed the word he meant to use. But also that he was not against such spying if there was good reason for it.

Advertise with us

He wants to know if there was.

He also said that bias toward Mr. Trump by some at the FBI — not most FBI agents, he emphasized — was “appalling.” He said a similar bias against Barack Obama by employees of the FBI and CIA, circa 2008, would have drawn howls of recrimination. And he is surely right.

Others say what really makes Mr. Barr threatening is his independence and intellectual honesty. The most notable thing in the interview was his tenor — a complete lack of posturing or virtue signaling. His answers were all “straight, no chaser.”

I want to zero in on two particular things Mr. Barr said.

First, he talked about the people Thomas Sowell once dubbed “the anointed.”

Advertise with us

Mr Barr said: “Republics have fallen because of the Praetorian Guard mentality where government officials get very arrogant, they identify the national interests with their own political preferences and they feel that anyone who has a different opinion, you know, is somehow an enemy of the state ... they know better … that can easily translate into essentially supervening the will of the majority and getting your own way as a government official.”

The problem is not the evil intent of the anointed, but good intent married to an absence of self-awareness and self-doubt.

The FBI spying on the political campaign of Barack Obama, or of Bernie Sanders, would have enraged the left. Back in the day, when the FBI spied on Martin Luther King Jr. and many other leaders of the civil rights and anti-war movements, the left, and liberals, and conservatives true to conservative principles, were enraged.

Most of the press was enraged.

In the case of Donald Trump, domestic spying was apparently OK.

Advertise with us

Mr. Barr holds that the rule of law — a government of laws and not of mobs, or social media, or the political orthodoxy of the moment — is what counts.

It’s our procedures and institutions, not the personalities of the day, that matter.

The second thing Mr. Barr said is that he is indifferent to his reputation, and even his place in history. “Everyone dies,” he said. He allowed that he did not believe in “... the Homeric idea that immortality comes from having odes sung about you over the centuries.”

I have written in this space before about my family connections to the Department of Justice — my mother’s cousin, a great uncle, my own cousin and my mother all worked there. I think millions of Americans want the Department of Justice and the FBI to be above politics and above reproach. The DOJ has been tainted, and not for the first time, and its reputation must be restored.

Looking over the names of attorneys general, going back to the 1940s, the great ones, the names that brought honor to the department — Robert Jackson, Elliot Richardson, Bill Saxbe, Edward Levi, Richard Thornburgh — are not necessarily the ones who were never in politics, but the ones who, when they were in this job, attorney general, were indifferent to their reputations and their future political fortunes. They donned a mantle not unlike that of a juror and stepped into an independent role — loyal to the Constitution, the law, and the common good alone.

Advertise with us

I do not know if Mr. Barr will be such an AG or not, or whether he can heal the Department of Justice. But I do know that indifference to what people might say about you, especially in the here and now, can be a powerful weapon. Mr. Barr did not need another line on his resume, and that makes him a dangerous man.

And one destined to be misunderstood. For history almost always proves that what was once the accepted wisdom was upside down wrong all along. Harry Truman was not a small, little man. Ike wasn’t detached. Reagan was not “an amiable dunce.” Truman had greatness in him. Ike was sly. Reagan was wise.

Once I interviewed the great, progressive civil rights governor and later president of Duke University, Terry Sanford. He was running for the U.S. Senate in his beloved North Carolina, and it was many years since his political prime. He was an old man. It was widely expected that he would lose. He was asked if losing his final race would tarnish his reputation. He was asked if he was diminishing himself. He shrugged and smiled. He said something like this: We all die. And people forget us. The important thing is to be in the arena, to serve, to try to improve your community and your world when and while you can. He said it was a wonderful thing to be free of ambition — to be indifferent.

And Terry Sanford won that race.

Keith C. Burris is executive editor of the Post-Gazette and editorial director of Block Newspapers (kburris@post-gazette.com).