I want Robert Bowers to live.

I want him to spend the rest of his miserable life alone in a cramped cell, contemplating, if he’s able, the horrors his hatred unleashed. I want the spirit of the 11 Jewish worshipers he fatally shot at a Pittsburgh synagogue on Oct. 27, 2018, to haunt him forever.

But the real reason I want Bowers, 50, to live has nothing to do with him and everything to do with us, and the government that acts in our name. Capital punishment is not about who deserves to die; only God can decide that. It’s about whether the government has the right to kill someone who no longer threatens society.

A state-sponsored execution in lieu of a mandatory life sentence is nothing more than a state-sponsored murder that legitimizes and promotes violence. Capital punishment is, as French philosopher Albert Camus argued in “Reflections on the Guillotine,” the most premeditated of murders, scheduled to an exact hour. As such, it is more reprehensible than most.

Advertise with us

Executions bloody the hands of the state and every one it represents. I don’t want Bowers’ blood on my hands, no matter how good it might feel. Vengeance -- an eye for an eye, as prescribed by the nearly 4,000-year-old Code of Hammurabi — should not be the business of a 21st century government.

Nothing, at any rate, could avenge the worst case of antisemitic violence in U.S. history. The state cannot kill Bowers 11 times. Nor can it, by his death, exact sufficient payment for his hate, his victims, the anguish of survivors, or the wound inflicted on the entire community.

As a Jew, I know that, in reading the Torah or Talmud, I could find reasons to oppose or support Bowers’ execution. Our faith tends to reaffirm what we already believe. I believe a justice system worthy of its name should rest on principles, not passions.

Testing convictions

No doubt, Bowers’ despicable crimes have tested the convictions of many death-penalty opponents. The pragmatic and social reasons for opposing the death penalty, such as wrongful convictions and racism, don’t apply to a white man whose guilt is certain.

Advertise with us

In arguing for Bowers’ life, it’s pointless to note DNA technology has proved the criminal justice system convicts many innocent people, and that the death penalty makes such mistakes irreversible. Since 1973, 190 people on death row, including 11 in Pennsylvania, have been exonerated. Nor is it pertinent that racism permeates the nation’s criminal justice system. African Americans make up more than half of Pennsylvania’s death row, for example, but only 12% of its people.

Finally, the enormous costs of capital punishment — millions of dollars in legal expenses to defend a conviction on appeals — aren’t relevant to a crime this horrific.

Bowers strips the case against capital punishment to its essence: A moral travesty that fails, absolutely, to deter further violence and hate.

If Bowers’ execution precluded one murder, I would support it. But it won’t. Most murders are not premeditated, and the death penalty does not provide sufficient deterrence for those that are. It certainly did not deter Bowers. No hard evidence — none — suggests the death penalty prevents violence. The 27 states with the death-penalty report higher murder rates than those without it.

Jurors will decide

Advertise with us

Tried in federal court, Bowers was found guilty on June 16, of all 63 counts. Now in the trial’s penalty phase, jurors will decide whether to sentence him to death or life in prison.

President Joe Biden has backed off a campaign pledge to end federal executions, but the federal government appears to lack consistent standards. In January, prosecutors did not seek the death penalty for a man accused of killing 23 people in a racist attack at a Texas Walmart in 2019.

Bowers can never atone for his crimes against humanity, but he may grow enough to understand the enormity of his deeds and feel a tormenting remorse. Only God has the right to close that door.

Whatever happens to Bowers, capital punishment is headed for history’s scrapheap. Since 2009, seven states have abolished it. Pennsylvania has a death-penalty statute but placed a moratorium on executions in 2015. In February, newly elected Gov. Josh Shapiro, a former death-penalty supporter, called on state legislators to abolish capital punishment. They should do so now.

Those of us who, unequivocally, oppose the death penalty must continue to speak out, even when it’s unpopular — even when it means pleading for the life of a monster like Robert Bowers.

Pulitzer Prize-winner Jeffery Gerritt is the editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.