Like a suffocating miasma, the death penalty will hang, for weeks or even months, over a reckoning of the most atrocious anti-Semitic attack in U.S. history. Life or death is the only real question in the federal Tree of Life trial, starting Monday, of the man accused of slaughtering 11 Jewish worshipers in a Squirrel Hill synagogue on Oct. 27, 2018. It is the only real issue that divides the community, which is united its grief, united in its outrage, and united in its resolve to overcome.
Given the centrifugal force of the death penalty in this case, I want to apologize to the Jewish community, especially those who favor the death penalty, for a misleading editorial I wrote on Sunday, April 9, urging the U.S. Justice Department to drop the death penalty in the upcoming trial. In making that case, I cited the opposition of some Jews to the death penalty.
Among other things, I noted, without qualification, that Congregation Dor Hadash, one of three congregations housed in the synagogue, has urged U.S. Attorney General Merrick Garland to retract the death penalty and accept a plea deal for a mandatory life sentence.
All that is true enough, but it is not true that a definitive majority of Jews in Pittsburgh, including victims’ family members, oppose the death penalty in this case. The editorial never said they did, but by using the opposition of some as an argument against the death penalty, I implied it. In doing so, I slighted Jews who favor the death penalty.
Getting it right
Accuracy is a big deal with me. In a more than 30-plus-year career, I’ve had to write only six corrections, fewer than one every five years. But sometimes a reporter, editorial writer or columnist can have the facts technically correct and still distort the truth by quoting someone out-of-context or excluding certain facts.
In this case, it was inexcusable, even for someone new to Pittsburgh. Commonsense dictates that any group of people holds varying views. Certainly, there are trends and tendencies. Death-penalty support is lower among African Americans, for example, but some Black people support it. Jews are more likely to oppose the death penalty than are white evangelical Christians, but some support it. As my rabbi in Detroit told me, “100 Jews, 100 opinions.” As a matrilineal Jew, I’ve argued with other Jews over the Middle East, drug policies, the death penalty, and which Coney Island in Detroit serves the best fries.
I make no apologies for my unequivocal opposition to the death penalty. It risks tragic and irreversible errors; it’s enormously expensive; and it’s racially discriminatory. I’m also not sure life in prison isn’t a greater punishment than a relatively quick death.
For me, the issue is not who deserves to die. The moral question is whether the government, state or federal, has the right to kill someone who no longer threatens society. I don’t believe it has. That doesn’t mean I’m a pacifist. I own a gun and would not hesitate to use it in self-defense.
I understand people who generally oppose the death penalty but would make exceptions for extreme cases like this one. Some members of the Post-Gazette Editorial Board hold that view. Even the state of Israel, which has generally abolished capital punishment, made an exception for Holocaust architect Adolph Eichmann, who was hanged in 1962 for genocide and crimes against humanity.
Vowing to do better
I try to hard be fair, to tell the truth, to be an honest broker. Sometimes, I fall short. Despite my best efforts, I’ve taken positions and said things I’ve regretted. No doubt, I will do so again. I’m not infallible and neither are Post-Gazette editorials. There have been some real doozies.
When we fall short, all we can do is take responsibility, apologize to those we’ve hurt, and vow to do better. That’s what I hope I’ve done here.
With jury selection starting Monday, the wheels of justice will finally begin to grind forward. The trial could continue through July. Whatever else divides us in this trail of trauma, we stand united in support of one another, and especially members of the Jewish community who have suffered so egregiously, confident in knowing they will emerge from this nightmare stronger than ever.
Shalom.
Pulitzer Prize-winner Jeffery Gerritt is the editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: jgerritt@post-gazette.com.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.