A wise friend told me that when you point your finger at someone else, three fingers point back at you.
His maxim came to mind when I was thinking about Warden Orlando Harper’s op-ed (“Media fail to tell success stories”), published in the Post-Gazette on July 14. It attempted to counter a barrage of bad news about the jail with some information and success stories the media had ignored.
Instead of mollifying Mr. Harper’s critics, however, the op-ed tossed gasoline on the fire. It ran virtually on the same day a 39-year-old Allegheny County prisoner — the fourth this year — died. It also included erroneous information on the county jail’s death rate. On Thursday, the Post-Gazette called for Mr. Harper’s resignation (“County needs new leadership”).
As a public relations gambit, the op-ed failed miserably. But in the aftermath, not all of the warden’s critics got it right. Nor was I, as a peddler of misinformation, blameless in this drama.
I owe you an explanation and an apology.
When an Allegheny County official asked me two weeks ago about publishing an op-ed from Mr. Harper, I said, hell, yeah. Because I had written several editorials and columns criticizing jail operations, I wanted the warden to have his say, even if he put the Post-Gazette on blast.
Unfortunately, the timing for publishing the op-ed turned out to be terrible. Touting the jail’s successes, hours after a prisoner, Victor Zilinek, died, seemed like a sick joke to many readers.
So let me set the record straight: The warden and county had nothing to do with when the op-ed was published.
County officials sent me the op-ed almost a week before the prisoner’s death. I decided to hold it until Thursday, July 14, so that the piece could run in print as well as online. Had I known an inmate would die late Wednesday, the day before the op-ed ran — and possibly less than an hour before the op-ed went online — I would have delayed its publication, out of respect for the inmate’s family.
I didn’t learn about the death until the day the op-ed ran, after reading a tweet from Bethany Hallam, a member of the Allegheny County Jail Oversight Board. The tweet posted at about 11:15 p.m. Wednesday — roughly 45 minutes before the op-ed went online.
Making matter worse, in disputing charges that the jail had an unusually high death rate, Mr. Harper calculated the county’s 2021 death rate by using the number of annual admissions, instead of the average daily population. The jail’s admissions for 2021 — more than 9,000 — were five times higher than the average daily population of about 1,800.
Using the higher number of admissions resulted in a deceptively low death rate — 65 per 100,000, which would have been less than half the latest nationwide death rate for jails. A county official told me Wednesday that using admissions numbers is standard for calculating jail mortality rates. But the U.S. Bureau of Justice Statistics uses average daily populations to calculate those rates. So the county was comparing apples to oranges.
I suspect it was an honest — if careless — mistake. At any rate, I should have caught it and asked the county to revise the figures. The editorial page seeks a wide range of opinions, but in editing op-eds and letters, we are still obligated to make sure writers have their facts straight.
I’ve been here for only about six months, but that’s no excuse. I’ve written about prisons, jails and the criminal justice system for 30 years, advocating for human rights. I’ve been in at least 60 prisons and jails. If any editor in the country should have caught that mistake, I should have. For that, I’m sorry. (I didn’t do the warden or county any favors, either.)
The op-ed, however, had little to do with the editorial that called for the warden’s resignation. That stemmed from the warden’s longstanding failure to acknowledge problems. It was the right call for the community, even though I, personally, like the warden and think he’s a dedicated, decent and capable man.
I’m sure he doesn’t feel that way about me. I’m not happy about that, but here’s another maxim I’ve learned to live by: Journalism isn’t a popularity contest.
Pulitzer Prize-winner Jeffery Gerritt is the editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.