MUKACHEVO, Ukraine — Sirens, whistling missiles and explosions still rock the dreams of 24-year-old Alexander Tkalichev.

Even now, three weeks after he and his brother Pascha, 16, left their home in the city of Lyman in the Donbas region of eastern Ukraine, the raucous roar of war unsettles his sleep. Even here, where he is safe, on the outskirts of Mukachevo in western Ukraine, 800 miles from Lyman, he hears the cruel cacophony of exploding bombs.
In Ukraine, perhaps more than anywhere else on the planet, “safe” is relative. In truth, there is no safe place here — not since Russia invaded on Feb. 24. — no place missiles cannot reach or air raid sirens cannot be heard. In Ukraine, there is only “safer.”
Everyone in this battered nation of 44 million people lives in the shadow of war and the grasp of fear.

In limbo
For two months, the Tkalichev brothers tried to wait out the intense bombing in Lyman. Finally, they fled from the Donbas region, after Mr. Tkalichev sent his wife, Katrina, and their 7-year-old daughter, Kristina, to safety in Germany.
Read More
Now, the brothers are in limbo.
With little more than the clothes on their backs, they wait in a hotel in Mukachevo, roughly 150 miles from the Hungarian border, for a judge to decide whether they can leave Ukraine and rejoin Katrina and Kristina in Germany.

“It’s difficult to express what I feel,” Mr. Tkalichev, a railway worker, told me Friday. “I had a home, a future. We had a simple life, just trying to make something of ourselves. Now, I don’t know what to think.”
A nation in exile
Alexander and Pascha Tkalichev are two of Ukraine’s more than 6 million internally displaced people. And unlike the 6 million refugees who fled to Poland, Romania, Hungary, Moldova and other European countries, displaced Ukrainians are invisible to the outside world. They have lost, or left, their homes, but unlike the refugees, they cannot, or will not, leave Ukraine.
Altogether, the war with Russia has uprooted more than 12 million of Ukraine’s 44 million people.
Since April 26, Alexander Tkalichev’s wife and daughter have lived in refugee housing provided by the government of Bavaria, as countries across Europe have unconditionally welcomed refugees from Ukraine and provided shelter, free public transportation and other assistance.
Unless Mr. Tkalichev secures legal custody of his youngest brother, however, the two can’t leave Ukraine to rejoin their family; Pascha will return to an orphanage.
Mr. Tkalichev is Pascha’s only option for family custody. A third brother, Sergei, 22, serves in the Ukrainian military. Their mother is dead, and their 44-year-old father is an alcoholic in the throes of addiction.
“I would join the military and go to war, along with my other brother,” Mr. Tkalichev said. “But I don’t want Pascha to be an orphan. As the oldest brother, I am responsible for him.”
A Ukrainian judge is expected to decide within two weeks whether Mr. Tkalichev can obtain legal custody of his youngest brother. Until then, the two brothers await their fate in Mukachevo.

Hustle to survive
Alexander and Pascha Tkalichev are among the first people I met after entering Ukraine from Hungary last week. Through an interpreter, they told me their story — a familiar one in Ukraine, of loss, uncertainty and hope that refuses to die as they hustle to survive another day.
The day after bombs rained on the Donbas region, Mr. Tkalichev sent his wife and daughter to Germany. But he decided to stay, hoping to hold out in a crawl space under the house until the bombing stopped.
Mr. Tkalichev had bought the property and house six years ago with $2,000 he borrowed from his mother. He had been renovating the house to turn it into a home for him, his wife, their daughter and his youngest brother. He didn’t want to leave it.
Within a few weeks, however, the assault on the region started hitting civilian targets, such as the local hospital. Missiles destroyed a street adjacent to Mr. Tkalichev’s house, as well as a building next door.
“The firing and air missiles were nonstop,” Mr. Tkalichev said. “Military vehicles were everywhere.”
Finally, in late April, as the bombing grew more and more intense, he decided to take his brother and flee to Lviv in western Ukraine.
In Lviv, the brothers slept in the railway station. Forty miles from the border of Poland, Lviv had attracted refugees from throughout Ukraine.
Increased demand for shelter made housing costs and hotel rates unaffordable. Mr. Tkalichev still received a paycheck from his railway job, but it had been cut from the equivalent of 300 U.S. dollars a month to just 30.
While in Lviv, however, the brothers caught a break. Mr. Tkalichev learned from his wife, whom he contacts daily by cellphone and social media, that her sister Victoria had arranged for an attorney she knows in Kharkiv — Elkhan Abdullaiev — to help them.
Before the war, Mr. Abdullaiev had a lucrative law practice. Now he spends most of his time doing pro bono work for refugees and displaced Ukrainians.
The attorney knew the owner of a hotel in Mukachevo and arranged to have the brothers stay there, without charge. He also registered the brothers as local refugees and petitioned the court to appoint Mr. Tkalichev as the legal guardian of his youngest brother.
In general, men 60 and under are required to stay in Ukraine to help defend the country. As an essential railway worker, however, Mr. Tkalichev is exempt from mandatory military service and the Territorial Defense Forces. Still, he cannot leave Ukraine unless he gains legal custody of his 16-year-old brother.
For now, Mr. Tkalichev is resting and reflecting, content to be away from bombs and destruction.

Hope dies last
When I met the two brothers outside their hotel, they both wore dark track suits. Pascha had his hood up.
Mr. Tkalichev’s sleeves were slightly pushed up, revealing an intricate tattoo on his left forearm, a gift from his wife on his 24th birthday.
Despite his dark hair, Mr. Tkalichev resembles British actor Daniel Craig. He carries himself with the maturity and gravitas typical of young Ukrainians.
Children grow up fast here. In Ukraine, a 24-year-old male is a man. In the United States, he’s often a kid.
Unlike most Ukrainians I met in the last 10 days, Mr. Tkalichev didn’t appear to hate Russia. The Donbas region, historically, has close ties to Russia, and Russian is his first language.
“For me, Russia was just a neighboring country,” Mr. Tkalichev said. “I was indifferent. I knew people in Ukraine who went to Russia for seasonal work and then came back. I didn’t think anything of it.”
His brother Pascha sat quietly for most of the interview. But when I asked Pascha what kind of music he likes, he smiled and said, “Anything contemporary.”
Pulling out a battered phone from his jacket, he played a song that sounded like electronica, with an anemic overlay of Russian rap.
“Many swear words,” he said, flashing a broad smile.
Pascha was scheduled to graduate from the 9th grade this year, the last year of high school for many Ukrainians. Now, he won’t. Maybe he’ll continue school in Germany. After the last 12 weeks, it’s hard for him to see beyond tomorrow, but he still dreams of becoming a firefighter in Ukraine.
I asked Mr. Tkalichev if life will return to normal for his family.
“Someday,” he said. “I had many plans before. Now, I can’t plan anything. I don’t know what my future holds.
“But I still have hope. Hope dies last.”

Jeffery Gerritt is the editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.