Before moving to Pittsburgh in 2015, I was a rabbi of a synagogue on Long Island, where about one-third of the members were Persian-Jewish families who had fled Iran during the revolution in the late ’70s.
They told me that life was, on the whole, not bad for the Jews under the Shah. Yes, there were some of the regular indignities suffered by Jews in Muslim societies, subject to restrictive laws for the treatment of non-Muslims, known in Arabic as dhimmi.
But during the revolution, virtually overnight, Jews lost their Muslim friends. One older Persian man talked about how one day his close Muslim classmates, with whom he played soccer and otherwise hung out, simply would not speak to him any more. He was shunned, even by his teachers.
Suddenly, the 100,000 Jews of Iran were no longer welcome, and 90% of them fled. To flee was not necessarily easy. Many left quickly and crossed borders on foot with nothing but the clothes on their backs.
The ones that remain today in Iran are welcome to stay, as long as they regularly and publicly denounce the State of Israel despite the fact that they are known to be enthusiastic supporters of the Zionist cause. They have frequently been persecuted and even executed on trumped-up charges.
The other victims
They are not the only victims of the revolution. The reality of life for average Iranians for these last 47 years has been deeply challenging.
Women are constantly subject to harassment by the “Morality Police,” who can fine them and worse for not being properly covered up. The case of Mahsa Amini, a 22-year-old Iranian woman from a Kurdish family who was apparently beaten to death while in police custody for improperly wearing her hijab in public, sparked the “Woman, Life, Freedom” protests that rocked Iran in 2022.
Furthermore, it is illegal to be gay in Iran, punishable by death. Former Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad famously stated in an address at Columbia University in 2007 that “In Iran, we do not have homosexuals like in your country.”
Meanwhile, Iran is the leading state sponsor of terrorism in the world. Iran has not only supplied Hamas, Hizbullah and the Houthis in Yemen with money and arms, but also it has committed terrorist acts throughout the world. One of the most deadly attacks on Jews in recent history, the 1994 bombing in Buenos Aires of the Associacion Mutual Israelita Argentina, which killed 85 people, has been traced back to Iran.
And although we have no exact number of how many protesters were killed in cold blood by the Iranian Revolutionary Guard Corps during anti-government protests two months ago, the Iranian government admits to over 3,000, but many reports suggest it may exceed 30,000.
Many Americans are deeply upset at our own government for killing two protesters in Minneapolis. Our outrage should be multiplied manifold times at Iran’s murderous treatment of its own people who seek freedom from fanatical religious oppression posing as law in Iran.
Judaism and war
What do we think about war? Judaism is not a tradition that is reflexively pro-war. On the contrary: The highest goal for life on this planet is shalom, and the fundamental meaning of that Hebrew word is the absence of war. It is a cognate of the word “shalem,” meaning whole. Only in a world without war can we all be whole.
I could never stand before my congregation as their rabbi and rattle a sword. Judaism is not a bloodthirsty tradition. However, Judaism is also realistic about war, which is a naturally occurring feature of human existence.
One theological stance, certainly present in the Torah, is that when God is on your side, you win. Shirat haYam, the song of redemption our ancestors sang upon having crossed the Sea of Reeds to escape Pharaoh’s battle chariots, describes God as “Ish milḥamah,” a warrior. That is, God is the one who leads the Israelites in battle.
On the other hand, the Torah exhibits clearly the dangers of war. A few chapters earlier, the Torah explains that the reason they take the long way through the Sinai to Israel is to avoid war with the Philistines. And that is a 40-year detour!
There are principles in the Torah and in later Jewish law about creating a standing army, conduct in battle, taking captives and loot, maintaining army bases, and even which trees may be cut down to build armaments. Our tradition codified guardrails in battle long before the Geneva conventions.
But more importantly, the Jews have been a practical people focused on life throughout our history. Maintaining human life is an essential value in Judaism. The principle of “piqquah nefesh,” the preeminence of saving a life in all of our choices, comes from a Talmudic interpretation of a verse in Leviticus: “You shall keep My laws and My rules, by the pursuit of which humans shall live: I am YHWH.”
So even though there are times when war is necessary, the bottom line is “vahai bahem” — you shall live by this framework — so that human beings should live and thrive. The Torah understands that loss of some life in war is absolutely permitted if we know it will save many more lives.
The war in Iran
Regarding this war in Iran, there are many challenges ahead. American public opinion is certainly one of them. So too the challenge of what happens on the day after the war is over, a challenge which our government has often faced and frequently bungled.
Nonetheless, the potential is there to radically reshape the Middle East. Bringing democratic rule and eliminating the nuclear threat, if we can somehow pull those things off, will save lives in Iran, in Israel and around the world.
And not just lives, but it will also nourish the spirit of millions of Iranian citizens who have been crushed by an oppressive regime which forces them to bow to the idol of fundamentalist religious control.
Beth Shalom member Jennifer Murtazashvili, who is a Fulbright scholar at Tel Aviv University this semester, captured this idea in the Pittsburgh Jewish Chronicle: “Israelis talk about this conflict not as a war against the ayatollahs but as a war for something: for a better future, for a better region, for the freedom of the people of Iran.”
Judaism has thrived under democracy. That is one reason that American Jews have not made aliyah (moved to Israel) en masse. The nations where religious freedom is not guaranteed are, by and large, places that the Jews have fled when they are able. And religious freedom will certainly be a good thing for the women of Iran, gay and lesbian Iranians, and many others as well.
We must stand for that freedom, and we must stand with the people of Iran as we help them throw off the yoke of their oppression. And meanwhile, we continue to pray for peace, for wholeness, for shalom in the world: “May the One who makes peace in the heavens make some peace for all of us down here on Earth, and let us say, Amen.”
Seth Adelson is the senior rabbi and spiritual leader of Congregation Beth Shalom in Squirrel Hill and the author of the substack The Modern Rabbi. His previous article was “The only way to defeat your oppressors.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.