Mine was a straightforward assignment. America and Canada had been friends, partners, and allies for a very long time.

Twenty years ago, Canada’s Prime Minister appointed me as his nation’s Honorary Consul to Western Pennsylvania. Some of my duties were ceremonial, but others were more substantive, building or reinforcing business, cultural and educational ties between Pittsburgh-based institutions and their counterparts in Canada.

With colleagues from the Canadian Consulate General in Buffalo, we were able to expand and strengthen the institutional connections between Canada and Western Pennsylvania. Any differences were of the sort you’d expect to find between good friends.

But things have changed, thanks to the Trump administration’s cavalier dismissal of Canada as a meaningful ally and valued trade partner.

Advertise with us

A different journey

This January, my wife and I visited family in Ontario. Over the last 34 years, since moving to Pittsburgh, we have made that journey dozens of times. This time was different.

Crossing back from Canada normally means waiting in a long line of cars at the Buffalo Peace Bridge. This time there weren’t any. No cars. Zero. A U.S. border guard checked our passports, and we were on our way home to Pittsburgh. In the past year, we have made three family trips to Canada.

Our impression is that Canadians have become wary of the United States. Last year, for instance, American whiskey was banned in most Canadian provinces. U.S. retail goods — if you can find them — have been moved to the lowest shelves in supermarkets, while Canadian goods display the Maple Leaf flag.

That change, again, reflects the Trump administration’s dismissal of Canada as an ally and trade partner. So what if Canada’s military had experienced 158 deaths during the NATO campaign against al-Qaeda in response to the 9/​11 attacks? To Trump, apparently, that meant nothing.

Nor, apparently, did the roughly $2 trillion in trade and services between the U.S. and Canada during 2024, the last year of Biden’s presidency. If it happened when Biden was president, or so the Trump administration’s reasoning goes, it must be bad.

Advertise with us

In the minds of Trump and his advisors, all that really matters is America’s power to impose its will on others. And if that amounts to “America First,” why not? After all, at least to Trump, the western hemisphere is nothing more than America’s backyard — its natural sphere of influence.

And South American countries, as well as the body of water formerly known as the Gulf of Mexico, would all fall under that U.S. hegemony — the “Donroe Doctrine,” as Trump branded it.

Making Canada subservient

That same subservient status would apply to Canada – our longtime friend to the north. Canadians’ neighborly trust of America is eroding.

In his speech at Davos, Switzerland, Canadian Prime Minister Carney made clear just how broken the U.S.-Canadian partnership has become. “Great powers have begun using economic integration as weapons, tariffs as leverage, financial infrastructure as coercion, supply chains as vulnerabilities to be exploited,” he said.

For “intermediate powers” like Canada, “must develop greater strategic autonomy, in energy, food, critical minerals, in finance and supply chains. ... A country that can’t feed itself, fuel itself or defend itself, has few options. When the rules no longer protect you, you must protect yourself.”

Advertise with us

Trump’s swaggering boast that Canada would become the 51st U.S. state, one way or another, had a tremendously corrosive effect on our partnership. So did the hostile tariffs that Trump imposed on Canadian goods entering the U.S.

Even Warren Buffett, the normally apolitical Oracle of Omaha, condemned the damage caused by the administration’s policies to tourism, trade, investment, work and study arrangements between the two countries. Trust is hard-earned, Buffett observed, but it’s easily lost.

The net result of the administration’s policies has been to alienate the U.S. from essentially all our former allies and to drive them into closer relationships with Russia and/​or China — both of whom are major rivals of the United States. That includes Canada.

For example, advanced Chinese electric vehicles will soon be imported into Canada, although they’re currently banned from the U.S. And Canada recently announced an ambitious program to become a global leader in electric vehicle production.

A broken relationship

Nobody, not even the United States, is better off without friends or allies, especially without a friend and ally that has been as close and as loyal as Canada has been. But America’s broken relationship with Canada won’t be quickly or easily healed. The foundation of trust upon which alliances are built has been too badly fractured.

Advertise with us

As Western Pennsylvania’s former Canadian Honorary Consul and a naturalized U.S. citizen for the past 30 years, I am heartbroken and appalled at the losses we have inflicted on ourselves. I’m saddened that so many of my Republican friends apparently fail to appreciate the depth of our loss.

Roger O. Cranville, who served as Canada’s Honorary Consul to Western Pennsylvania and as Pennsylvania’s Deputy Secretary for International Business Development in the Ridge Administration, is the chairman of Britsburgh. He was named to the Order of the British Empire by Queen Elizabeth II in 2003. His previous article was “80 years after the end of World War II, England says thank you to America.”