Best known now for “The Jungle Books,” Rudyard Kipling was an unapologetic imperialist who coined the phrase “the white man’s burden,” yet his poem “The Gods of the Copybook Headings” goes to the heart of our contemporary troubles and suggests a way out.
Kipling wrote the poem in 1919 after a war that had killed as many as 22 million people (including his only son, John) and amid a pandemic that eventually claimed at least another 50 million. The poem contrasts the “gods of the marketplace” — the faddish ideas that periodically grip the public — with the “gods of the copybook headings” — pieces of popular wisdom printed on the top line of every page in school exercise books. Children were expected to copy them out, learning basic moral lessons while they improved their handwriting.
Optimistic but wrong
The end of the Great War released a flock of optimistic ideas about ending war forever, abolishing private property and downgrading nation-states. Kipling thought that such naive optimism would lead not just to disappointment but to the destruction of civilization. The poem concludes by contrasting humanity’s weakness for self-deception with the stern truths of the copybook headings:
As it will be in the future, it was at the birth of Man
There are only four things that are certain since Social Progress began.
That the Dog returns to his Vomit, and the Sow returns to her Mire,
And the burnt Fool’s bandaged finger goes wabbling back to the Fire;
And that after this is accomplished, and the brave new world begins
When all men are paid for existing and no man must pay for his sins,
As surely as Water will wet us, as surely as Fire will burn,
The Gods of the Copybook Headings with terror and slaughter return!
The end of the Cold War gave flight to another flock of optimistic ideas on the world. Many of them came from the left, like western capitalism as a racist project, a universal basic income and giving drug addicts free drugs.
Many of today’s most naïve ideas have come from the right. Neoliberals argued for linking CEO pay to their company’s stock price, abolishing borders and reducing inheritance tax, all in the name of market efficiency. The tech titans waxed lyrical about abolishing death, colonizing Mars and discovering “superintelligence.”
Tech titans such as Peter Thiel and Elon Musk are, in purely IQ terms, some of the planet’s cleverest people. Yet all this cleverness is as nothing compared with the common wisdom of the copybook headings.
A price to be paid
Consider three generic maxims and the price that we have paid — Kipling’s “terror and slaughter” — for ignoring them:
First: Pride comes before a fall. This is expressed in the story of Icarus, the young Greek who straps on a pair of wings, flies toward the sun and then, when the sun melts the wax holding his wings in place, falls back to Earth. Silicon Valley is full of Icaruses strapping on wings in the foolish belief that the wax will hold
The tech industry is betting hundreds of billions of dollars on AI. Fertility companies are selling genetic interventions to increase your odds of having a problem-free, high-IQ child.
The AI bubble may burst, like the railway bubble before it, with devastating economic consequences; an AI-driven future may produce terrible social dislocation; and eugenics has an infamous history that should provoke horror, not emulation. Taken together they may spell doom.
Second: A tree without roots cannot thrive. Left-wing academia paints our collective history, the history of the West, as growing from poisoned roots. The West has certainly committed grave sins, not least imperialism and slavery, but it is hardly unique in that.
Any reasonable accounting must balance these sins against achievements such as liberal political regimes (the limitation of powers, individual rights and toleration) and sustained economic growth. The left-wing view has demoralized the mainstream and empowered our critics in China and Russia.
Third: No civilization can survive without virtue. Both progressives and neoliberals have made the case for reducing self-restraint, progressives on the grounds that sexual repression is unhealthy and neoliberals on the grounds that pursuing self-interest leads to the common good.
The Epstein scandal is a historic moment because it demonstrates where this double liberation can lead: to a group of rich and entitled men exploiting young and vulnerable girls. The terrible details of this affair reveals the formation of a hereditary caste of the super-rich at the pinnacle of society and the breakdown of basic social institutions such as the family at the bottom.
Political theorists from the ancient Greeks onward have emphasized that self-restraint is particularly important in democracies. Plato argued that too much popular self-indulgence leads inexorably to demand for a dictator who can restore order.
The Founding Fathers believed that “parchment” barriers to tyranny would fail if the people lacked character. Scholars Joseph Schumpeter and Daniel Bell warned that the greatest danger to capitalism comes from a failure to control the appetites that it generates.
Reasons for hope
It is tempting to share Kipling’s pessimism. The world’s most powerful CEOs have added paying court to Donald Trump to their list of sins. The election of Zohran Mamdani as mayor of New York suggests that Trump’s extremism is empowering the left of the Democratic Party. But there are nevertheless reasons for hope.
The Epstein scandal is so toxic that it is likely to discredit not just the people who moved in his circles but a wider culture of entitlement. A growing number of universities, particularly in the American South, are establishing courses on Western civilization and civic virtue.
And a growing number of young people, exhausted by digital distraction, are looking for meaning in great books or traditional culture. There is even a revival of old-fashioned religion in secular Britain and in the United States.
Kipling warned that if we neglected the gods of the copybook headings, they would return with terror and slaughter. We still have time to appease them with moderation and wisdom.
Adrian Wooldridge is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist and author of “The Aristocracy of Talent: How Meritocracy Made the Modern World.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.