No matter how you feel about his policies or his health at the end of his term, there is one thing on which Joe Biden had it right. In his final year in office, he repeatedly talked about the world being at a historic inflection point: one of those times that changes history, for better or worse; one of those times when events either unroll or unravel such that it simply is not possible to go back to what has been “normal.”
Our response to that change will determine our collective future.
A defining element
Supreme Court Justice Felix Frankfurter once wrote that “The history of American freedom is, in no small measure, the history of procedure.” Process is, indeed, the defining element of American exceptionalism. Due process for every person (not just citizens) is uniquely embraced in the United States as the fundamental element of rule of law.
Without rule of law, no democracy can long survive. But what exactly does “rule of law” mean, and how do we know when and whether it exists in a society?’
Both the U.S. and the E.U. promote the rule of law around the world and each spends much on programs for that purpose. Yet neither has had a discernible public definition of just what rule of law means.
At a conference several years ago sponsored by the University of Pittsburgh’s Center for International Legal Education, which I direct, and the European Studies Center, the Europeans focused on substantive rights, like access to housing, food and healthcare. The Americans focused almost exclusively on process, describing the kind of rights protected by the first nine amendments to our Constitution: protection from overreach by the government.
The Europeans tended to focus on the societal ends of law and government. The Americans focused on the means by which government achieves those ends through the treatment of individual persons.
This American focus on process is being challenged today. Throughout our nation’s history, we have had strong differences on what are the proper ends to be enacted by law, but have joined in the belief that a robust, open and informed process should be the means to those ends.
A defining process
The inflection point former President Biden described is defined by the loss of a focus on the means by which we are to achieve the ends of government — a loss of focus on process.
In the first three articles of our Constitution, the framers intentionally created a web of limitations on each of the three branches of government. Their most significant concern was with the executive branch, because they were doing all they could to prevent the type of monarchy many had just died to free the nation from. As the other branches fail to exercise their authority, the executive branch becomes just what the framers sought to avoid and the process intended to rein in executive authority is lost.
If we claim to be a nation where rule of law matters — that is, a democracy — it is not appropriate for a president to believe he is limited only by “my own morality.” It is not appropriate to capture officials of other nations in their own territory in violation of the United Nations Charter’s prohibition on the use of force against the territorial integrity or political independence of any other country (an international enshrinement of a focus on process), nor to withdraw, without discussion, from alliances we created that have made us strong through our continued leadership in those alliances.
To engage in a politics of personality instead of politics of ideas is not appropriate, nor is responding to the death of a citizen caused by lethal force exercised by a government agent by calling the citizen a “terrorist” before the facts have been fully considered.
In a democracy, elections entitle those who win to lead the democratic process to decide, implement and enforce policies but only within the rules established for that purpose. They must achieve their desired ends through the means established by law, including the Constitution — and accept their failure when they cannot, when the process produces other results than they want.
Winning an election does not entitle those elected to exercise power in a manner that our forebears fought and died to prevent. It is acceptable to object to the policies others promote, but it is not acceptable to demonize, terrorize and prosecute the people who promote them simply because they hold different views. Looking at America now, at this inflection point, we must ask whether we are to continue to have a nation whose history is the history of procedure, of the rule of law.
A defining choice
The message of our founders for this inflection point in history is not that the ends sought by one group are to be achieved by any means possible, but that the means — the process— is in itself an end goal of our democracy. We must acknowledge that the means of process that demonstrates equality, respect, dialogue and discussion is the end to be sought in our democratic system.
Whether we embrace that process or reject it in favor of division, disrespect and the demonization, detention and destruction of others will define our future as a nation at this inflection point in history.
Ronald A. Brand is the Chancellor Mark A. Nordenberg University Professor and the academic director of the Center for International Legal Education at the University of Pittsburgh School of Law. His previous article was “Trump's depredations call for a civic uprising.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.