I have been traveling outside the United States for much of the time since Donald Trump’s inauguration. That has not kept me from the news of the many changes he and his chosen few have brought to our country. It has, however, provided the opportunity to speak with others from many countries. This includes people in high-level government positions, academics, lawyers, foreign justice ministry officials, taxi drivers, restaurant service persons, hotel clerks and others.
Those with whom I have talked, like many Americans with whom I have had discussions at home, are confused. They don’t understand how a country that has been their beacon of hope for so many years and the champion of democracy and rule of law can now be led by someone who seems to reject these principles. Someone many believe is a puppet of Vladimir Putin. Some Chinese are said to refer to “Comrade Trump” as they buy ceramic statues of the man they call the “all-knowing Buddha of the West,” whom they believe is doing their country’s bidding in the United States.
Fear and retribution
It is easy to conclude that Donald Trump, Elon Musk, and their companions are bent on establishing a new order based neither on law nor the Constitution, but rather on power, retribution, fear and a complete disregard for the due process limitations that have held our nation together since its birth.
Large law firms, where every lawyer has taken an oath to uphold the law and abide by basic ethical standards, now sign agreements that seem to include a quid pro quo that fits the definition of prohibited bribery in our federal statutes. Congressional leaders in Trump’s own party are admitting they “are all afraid” of what Trump might do as they bow to his will to avoid reprisals.
It’s easy to cite times in American history when the Constitution has survived extreme divisions in our society. But is the proper comparison one that considers our own internal divisions on issues such as slavery or one that looks outside our own history to other examples of “democratically” chosen dictators who have used their power to cause massive violations of human rights, deaths and destruction?
The day after
Neither leaders in the Democratic Party nor elsewhere have found the path to a proper response to Donald Trump’s cult-like ability to justify any means by telling his followers the ends are what they should want. Sen. Bernie Sanders of Vermont and U.S. Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez of New York have brought out large crowds at rallies. Even some conservative commentators have come to the conclusion that there must be “a civic uprising” to stop Trump. But no one has picked up the mantel to lead the change.
We need a strong and united response to Trump’s actions — not repetitious and reactive reporting and criticism, but pro-active preparation and engagement. The United States has been rightly criticized for entering military conflicts without a plan for the “day after.” Vietnam, Iraq, and Afghanistan have taught us the costs of that approach to military engagement. We need both a civic uprising and a day-after approach to Donald Trump.
But what must a pro-active day after approach entail? Democrats in Congress must establish a shadow cabinet. Along with officials in state governments, and with like-minded colleagues in the Republican Party who are willing to overcome fear of retribution, they must provide daily reports on the damage done in every department of government in the current administration.
But they can’t stop there. They must prepare and present clear policies and goals for each department in order to inform and educate the population about considered alternatives to the Trump administration’s approach.
Preserving the rule of law
Various media outlets and “influencers” have distorted truth and provided opinions designed to enrage rather than facts submitted to inform. We must all be critical thinkers who seek to discern what is “news” and what is distortion for the purposes of ideological influence and personal gain.
The problem runs deep, but the solution begins with stopping a President who believes he is (and with Supreme Court assistance is in some events) above the law.
We need to move from confusion to purpose. The goal must be true equal treatment of everyone, including the president. We must engage in discussion based on policies and principles, not on degradation and denial. Until we expect all to follow the law, we will not have a society based on the rule of law.
Without a society based on the rule of law, democracy is a shallow hope. Unless our president follows the law, none of us is safe.
Ronald A. Brand is the Chancellor Mark A. Nordenberg University Professor and the Academic Director of the Center for International Legal Education at the University of Pittsburgh School of Law.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.