In 1998, when I was in my mid-20s and the World Wide Web was just beginning to shape daily life in this country, the Post-Gazette published an essay I wrote from my perspective as part of the last generational cohort to grow up entirely offline.

Describing my “fellow middle Generation-Xers” as “all who can remember being escorted by parents to the premiere of the original Star Wars but never knew firsthand of the war in Vietnam,” I explored the confluence of our hippie-infused 1970s childhoods with the “plastic mass culture,” lesson-oriented television and advertising-driven consumerism of the 1980s.

I urged my peers to recognize that we occupied a particular position in time. “Oh how fortunate we are, to remember a time before the information age,” I wrote. “Unconstrained by software and hardware limitations, we grew up free to cultivate dreams for our world that were more about people than technology.”

Concrete dreams

Those dreams were concrete: more morally engaging public debate, clearer thinking about material excess and restraint, a revival of everyday politeness, more durable and socially responsible consumer products, smarter patterns of growth, and a strengthening of community that extended beyond the individual household. I urged my peers to nurture those dreams and work toward them, warning that they “very well may be what will save this society from losing itself, click after click, link after link.”

Advertise with us

My peers are now leading universities and nonprofits, running businesses large and small, shaping public policy, practicing law and medicine, teaching, engineering, governing, and caring for others. By most conventional measures, our cohort did not stall or opt out. We grew up, we stepped up and we built lives of consequence.

And yet it would be hard to argue that the world around us now feels more capable of handling disagreement, error, or strain. If anything, it feels more brittle.

From where I sit today, inside institutions rather than observing them from a distance, the consequences of losing shared, non-siloed spaces for exchange are no longer abstract: disagreement is often interpreted as calculated or betrayal; ordinary efforts to engage and mistakes along the way take on outsized meaning; and people become more guarded — not because they are unwilling to learn, but because the risk associated with public missteps has metastasized.

In that environment, goodwill is steadily depleted. Cynicism, by contrast, is often mistaken for realism, even as it quietly undermines trust, cooperation and the possibility of collective problem-solving.

The result is a growing difficulty in reaching consensus — not the kind of groupthink that glosses over differences, but the kind of consen-sus that emerges when people feel heard and taken seriously. True consensus building depends on a willingness to assume good faith long enough to understand what is actually being said. When we begin instead by assuming the worst, disagreement hardens into identity, and cynicism fills the space where understanding might otherwise grow.

Advertise with us

Durable good faith

Generosity remains essential to keeping public problem-solving alive, but in the face of increased risk or exhaustion, it becomes harder and harder to sustain. Humanity’s resilience becomes threatened when its systems over-rely on goodwill or make it difficult to contribute generously. The challenge is to pair generosity with structures, norms, and shared spaces that make good faith durable rather than extractive.

This realm is where institutions like the Post-Gazette once mattered so much. They mattered because they created shared civic space — places where ideas could circulate beyond self-selected audiences, be challenged publicly, and refined in common view.

As a society, we have lost more of that capacity than we tend to admit. The cost is not merely polarization but a diminished ability to correct ourselves before small failures compound into systemic ones.

If the instinct behind that 1998 essay was sound, it still points somewhere useful. But the stakes are clearer now. Human agency is not just effort or intention; it is the capacity to act meaningfully within systems where one’s good faith is not quietly undermined.

Goodwill, once exhausted, may not be easily replenished. Cynicism, when allowed to become ambient, is not a harmless posture. It is a direct threat to the conditions that make cooperation and collective problem-solving possible.

Advertise with us

This critical junction is where Generation X has something genuinely distinctive to offer. We remember what mattered before constant digital filtering, before algorithmic sorting, before immediacy was treated as proof of seriousness.

We remember when technology was a means for advancement rather than a status symbol, a distraction or a shortcut around judgment. That memory is both nostalgia and perspective — and it matters now more than ever.

Many of us absorbed those core values early through voices that treated dignity, fairness, and care for others as practical necessities rather than moral posturing. In Pittsburgh, one of those voices belonged to Fred Rogers, who insisted, quietly and persistently, that respect for others was not sentimental but foundational.

Artificial intelligence will only intensify the dynamics I’ve described. Used well, AI can surface patterns we miss, reduce administrative burden, and free human attention for judgment and care. But it cannot determine what to value, when to slow down or how to preserve trust across difference. Those choices and charges remain human ones.

Stewarded spaces

This is not yet a moment for Generation X to pass the baton to Y or (barely pre-AI) Z. It’s a time for finishing the work that puts any future handoff on solid footing. What we choose to preserve — or allow to erode — will quietly shape what those coming next assume is normal.

Advertise with us

This is not a call to nostalgia, nor a plea for endless generosity. It is a call to stewardship: to protect shared spaces where ideas can still be exchanged in good faith; to treat cynicism not as sophistication but as a warning sign; and to ensure that the tools we build, including AI, serve human ends rather than replace them.

I ended my 1998 essay by urging my peers to nurture their childhood dreams for the world and work toward them. I still believe that instinct was right. What I would add now is this: Remembering what really matters is not regression.

It is leadership. And paired with the tremendous responsibility we now carry, that awareness may be one of the most important resources we have left.

Elizabeth Irwin grew up in southwestern Pennsylvania and has spent her career in public-sector oversight. Her 1998 article was titled “Barely pre-Web and loving it.”