WASHINGTON — We’ve seen this plot before. The question is whether the ending will be the same. The second session of the 119th Congress, which gets underway Monday, looks a lot like six years ago with Republicans trying to keep their majorities in a midterm election traditionally seen as a referendum on the president, even as a November Gallup poll put his job approval rating at 36%, with 60% disapproving.
Polls show voters disapprove of President Donald Trump and his signature tax and spending law, just as they did in 2018. Health costs, which was a major issue that year and helped Democrats win the House, again is high on voters’ minds.
Just as Trump brings out infrequent voters when he’s on the ballot, he energizes the Democratic opposition when he’s not, as he did six years ago.
“There are a lot of similarities,” said former Rep. Tom Malinowski, D-N.J., elected to the House in that 2018 Democratic wave. “It’s the same president, an even more acute version of the same problem and the same potential solution — Democrats winning House seats.”
Same as last time
The new session also will look a lot like the just-concluded one, with another government shutdown looming on Jan. 30 when the temporary spending bill that reopened the federal government ends.
House and Senate appropriators of both parties are trying to fund the government through Sept. 30. But last fall, Trump told Republicans not to negotiate with Democrats, leading to the record 45-day shutdown that Americans blamed on the party that controlled the White House, Senate and House.
Read More
“Trump only has one playbook and that’s to stubbornly pursue his personal grievances and try to win by dividing people,” Malinowski said. “It doesn’t work as well when he’s president and responsible for how much my health insurance costs or how much things cost at the store.”
A November Gallup poll put Trump’s job approval rating at 36%. In Pew Research Center poll from August, 46% of Americans disapproved of his signature legislation while just 32% supported it. Both Trump and his original tax law were unpopular in 2018, too.
Republicans began calling the tax law as the Working Families Tax Cut rather than the One Big Beautiful Bill, even as the Tax Policy Center found 51% of its benefits going to the top 10% of U.S. taxpayers. Just one-fifth went to the bottom 60%.
The measure gave the richest 1% of Pennsylvanians — those earning at least $833,700 — an average tax cut of $56,510, according to the Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy. That’s 35 times more than the $1,590 going on average to those making between $53,700 and $88,800.
“Unless Americans see a substantial difference in their own economic well-being, they are not going to support it no matter what the administration might say,” Rutgers University pollster Ashley Koning said.
Sour voters
Republicans also face the same sour mood that led voters to give them the White House and both houses of Congress in 2024.
“If voters are feeling, as they feel now, unhappy, the status quo won’t help you,” said Christopher Borick, a political science professor at Muhlenberg College. “That’s the problem Republicans face.”
Still, the Democratic lead in the generic congressional ballot on Tuesday was only 3.9 percentage points, according to Real Clear Politics. On the same day four years ago, the Democratic margin was 12.8 points.
And a December Quinnipiac University poll gave congressional Democrats a record low 18% approval rating among registered voters, compared with 35% for Republicans.
“On day one, President Trump and House Republicans took decisive action and are already delivering historic results,” said Mike Marinella, a spokesman for the National Republican Congressional Committee. “The work isn’t finished, but America is moving in the right direction, and the best days are ahead.”
Here’s more of the work ahead.
Railroads and health care
The economy. It’s now called “affordability,” and it helped spark strong Democratic turnout across the country in the November off-year elections, helping to keep a Democratic majority on Pennsylvania’s Supreme Court.
“This upcoming session, if it does not focus on affordability and come up with a way to make folks’ lives better, you will definitely see a repeat of six years ago,” Democratic strategist Modia Butler said.
The economy is now Trump’s problem to fix, not Biden’s. And just like Biden and then Kamala Harris found out, Trump’s won’t convince voters that the economy is great simply by insisting that it is.
“Public perception is often reality to the public,” Koning said. “The public has perceived the economy as poor whether or not indicators think it is.”
Rep. Summer Lee, D-Swissvale, said she expected some Republicans to join Democrats to address the problem. “I think you’ll see them remembering that they represent real people who do need to see some action on our affordability crisis, which is not a hoax,” she said.
Health care. Rep. Chris Deluzio, D-Aspinwall calls the conflict over health care “one of the major cost-of-living fights that the Congress has to take on.”
In withholding their votes from the Republican-drafted spending bill, congressional Democrats insisted the measure take steps to avoid major increases in health care premiums for those buying insurance on the Affordable Care Act marketplaces and to roll back the Trump tax law’s Medicaid cuts.
Lee said it would be a “dereliction of duty” to not tackle health care this year. “We recognize how many people are underinsured, how many people are rationing care because they can’t afford their co-pays, they can’t afford the premiums,” she said. “We’re in the wealthiest nation on Earth, and I feel like we have just a responsibility to focus on that.”
Failing to extend the increased health insurance subsidies enacted during the pandemic could mean 447,000 more uninsured Pennsylvanians, according to the Center for American Progress. As many as 538,000 Pennsylvanians could lose Medicaid coverage under the Trump tax law, according to the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities.
Railroads and agriculture
Railroad safety. Following the February 2023 derailment of a Norfolk Southern freight train in East Palestine, Ohio, lawmakers of both parties in both houses — including then-U.S. Sen. JD Vance, R-Ohio — introduced legislation to require stronger safety measures for railroads.
Deluzio, the lead sponsor of the latest version of the Railway Safety Act, said he was hopeful that some elements of the measure would be included when Congress renews programs to fund roads, bridges, transit and other surface transportation modes. It is “a real must-pass piece of legislation.”
Agriculture. While elements of the new farm bill were included in Trump’s massive tax and spending law, House Agriculture Committee chair Glenn Thompson, R-Centre, said there was plenty more to do
The agriculture elements enacted comprised about 90 pages of a thousand-page bill, he said, and the unfinished business included rural economic development, rural broadband and community facilities. “There’s just a lot like that that is left to be finished.”
Jonathan D. Salant has covered Washington for almost four decades, including for the Post-Gazette. He is a former National Press Club president and a member of the Society of Professional Journalists D.C. chapter's Journalism Hall of Fame. He writes every other Friday. His previous article was “Five years later, a new effort to rewrite Jan. 6.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.