I’m a long-term registered Republican, and I agree with President Donald Trump, and many Americans, that the Affordable Care Act (the ACA or Obamacare) is broken. After more than a decade of Obamacare, healthcare costs and particularly insurance premiums have skyrocketed. As premiums go up, more people need Obamacare subsidies.
We need a plan that will fix this affordability crisis. I call it “Trumpcare,” and even though I’m a Republican, it will look somewhat similar to Medicare-for-all.
Trumpcare vs. Obamacare
I am in total agreement with Senator Bernie Sanders of Vermont that healthcare is a human right. Moreover, I think Medicare-for-All would be infinitely better than Obamacare. Trumpcare would move us a little closer to Medicare-for-All, but not all the way there. Instead, it has options, making it more like Medicare-for-Anyone, but only for anyone who wants it.
What is Trumpcare, as I see it? Unlike Obamacare, which focuses principally on the insurance market, Trumpcare has two major components. They are Trumpcare Accounts, which will reduce costs in the provider market substantially, and Trumpcare Insurance, which will do the same in the insurance market.
As soon as we enact Trumpcare — and to keep things fair, at least at the starting gate — the voters should have the option of transferring into their Trumpcare Accounts 100% of the Covid-enhanced value of the Obamacare subsidies and credits. Everyone with Trumpcare Accounts will then have the option of remaining uninsured so long as they wish.
Instead, the voters can use their Trumpcare Accounts to pay healthcare providers directly, such as hospitals and doctors—or insurers. If there’s money left over at the end of the year, those balances can roll over into the next year’s accounts.
To protect the value of the balances in the Trumpcare Accounts, Trumpcare will include provisions that all payments from Trumpcare Accounts must be at Medicare rates. (Sometimes Medicare providers charge uninsured people at rates that are higher than the prices the providers charge Medicare).
This Trumpcare provision relating to providers will mirror President Trump’s current and ongoing policies of insisting on “most favored nation” pricing for pharmaceuticals. In other words, all payments by consumers from their Trumpcare Accounts will be at the lowest prices charged by providers and by pharmaceutical companies.
What about the voters who earn too much to qualify for Obamacare subsidies and credits? Are they entitled to Trumpcare Accounts? Of course they are. But they will need to make tax-exempt contributions to fund their Trumpcare Accounts, which will be like health savings accounts but with fewer restrictions on use.
As a practical matter, most people will self-fund their Trumpcare Accounts only when they want to avail themselves of the lower provider and pharmaceutical prices for payments made out of Trumpcare Accounts.
Pre-existing conditions
As we’ve seen, the first major component of Trumpcare allows consumers to remain uninsured for as long as they wish. But what happens to people who are already sick or who become sick months or years after Trumpcare is enacted?
We already know how Obamacare covers this. Under Obamacare, people with preexisting conditions are entitled to pay insurance premiums calculated on a par with healthy people.
Under Trumpcare, people with preexisting conditions are similarly protected on the total cost of their premiums. But instead of paying one premium to the insurance company, new enrollees in Trumpcare Insurance will pay two premiums, one to the insurance company and one to Medicare. But the combined cost of these two premiums will be lower, probably much lower, than Obamacare premiums.
There are two premium payments because, under Trumpcare, all the medical costs associated with the preexisting condition will be paid by Medicare. And the insurance company will only pay for medical costs for future illnesses, if any.
Premiums
Under Trumpcare, the premiums paid to insurers will be lower because the insurers will no longer be covering preexisting conditions. As things stand now, under Obamacare many of the young and the healthy are foregoing insurance — because they’ve done the math and reasoned that they can wait until they get sick. Under Obamacare, this leaves insurance companies with a pool of older and sicker people.
The Obama administration, of course, foresaw this happening, which is why Obamacare was drafted with a mandate — and related enforcement penalty — requiring everyone to have insurance, including the young and the healthy. If this part of Obamacare had worked, there wouldn’t have been many people at all with preexisting conditions.
But the voters hated the mandate and the penalty. As it turned out the penalty was much lower than the cost of insurance, and as a result many of the young and the healthy skipped buying insurance. This scenario snowballed once the penalty disappeared. That’s why insurance premiums have skyrocketed under Obamacare. And as the premiums have gone higher, more people can’t afford insurance, which in turn has caused the Obamacare subsidies to skyrocket too.
Trumpcare fixes this disaster. Yes, absolutely, we need to protect people with preexisting conditions. Sick people need healthcare. But Trumpcare acknowledges the obvious: Namely, protecting people with preexisting conditions is an entitlement.
And that’s why under Trumpcare, anyone with a preexisting condition is entitled to have the preexisting condition covered by Medicare, which has always covered preexisting conditions, and at very low premiums.
And why will the Medicare premiums under Trumpcare be so low? Because the federal government has never used Medicare premiums to cover all the costs of care. Instead, it uses the funds generated by the Medicare payroll deduction. And who pays the Medicare payroll deduction? The young and the healthy.
In other words, the entire architecture of Obamacare is crumbling because tens of millions of the young and the healthy have done the math and decided to postpone buying insurance until they get sick. But Trumpcare is fine with this. In other words, Trumpcare is structured exactly the opposite of Obamacare, which tried to force every single person in the country to buy health insurance from the insurers.
All about options
Trumpcare allows, and even encourages, the young and the healthy to wait—so long as they’re paying into Medicare via the Medicare payroll deduction, at least for a while. A month or two should suffice — because we want to encourage the underground economy to join the official economy, paying income taxes and Social Security, along with the Medicare payroll deduction.
And what about their family members? They are entitled to all the benefits of Trumpcare too.
Under Trumpcare everyone has the option to buy Trumpcare Insurance at any time — or never. But for someone who has a major health crisis, Trumpcare Insurance will be there.
In fact, because Trumpcare is all about options, Trumpcare will allow retroactive enrollment where needed, for example, when someone is hit by a bus and goes into a coma for two months. After all, the timing of signing up for a healthcare plan shouldn’t be like a roulette wheel — black you win, red you die (or go bankrupt).
Trumpcare will have an immediate impact on affordability for all voters. First, for those who need insurance, the premium costs will go down dramatically. And once this happens, subsidies will go down too.
Under Trumpcare, there will of course still be subsidies for the needy. But they should be lower than the Obamacare subsidies, because the underlying insurance company premiums should be lower.
Second, for those who are healthy enough to skip buying insurance, they will save tens of thousands of dollars annually. Even those with employer-sponsored insurance might negotiate to receive, in taxable salary, the value of their untaxed employer-paid insurance, coupled with a promise by the employer to buy Trumpcare Insurance for any employee who gets sick.
And yes, the Medicare payroll deduction will probably go up, but this will be a broad-based tax, totaling a lot less than the amount many families are currently spending on annual insurance company premiums.
Moreover, unlike today, where the young and the healthy must typically wait until they turn 65 to see any return on their Medicare payroll deduction, under Trumpcare they’ll see immediate benefits in the form of Trumpcare Accounts for everyone and Trumpcare Insurance for those who need it.
Enacting Trumpcare
As for Trumpcare, it of course doesn’t exist yet. Nevertheless, we Republicans are entitled to a fair fight too. That means we need to enact Trumpcare quickly.
I don’t think we should impose Trumpcare on the voters by adopting a “repeal and replace” approach to reform. The voters like options, and some might like to stick with their Obamacare plans. We should let them do so, while simultaneously giving everyone the chance to opt-in to Trumpcare.
My Democrat friends might be suspicious of this approach. They’ll complain that my Republican colleagues have hamstrung Obamacare by failing to extend the Obamacare ACA Covid-era enhanced insurance subsidies and tax credits.
And my Democrat friends are absolutely 100% correct. I urge Republicans to give the Democrats everything they want, including three-year extensions of the Covid-era enhanced subsidies and credits. After all, we Republicans want a fair fight.
Given what’s been going on in the Congress, it’s become clear that President Trump is the only person in the country who can save us from the disaster of Obamacare. That’s why the replacement for Obamacare is going to be called Trumpcare.
Trumpcare is also the best possible route for the Republicans to survive the 2026 midterms, and that will in turn save the second half of President Trump’s presidency. In short, we all need Trumpcare, but we Republicans need it more.
Melinda Roberts is a retired antitrust litigator, who practiced in New York and Los Angeles. She lives in Sewickley Heights. She can be contacted at melindajaneroberts@outlook.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.