There is a single solution to two major issues facing the city of Pittsburgh: the desperate need for more homes available for affordable home ownership, and the city’s unwanted ownership of more than 13,000 repossessed properties.
We propose spending as much as $600 million over the next 30 years to put thousands of these properties back onto the tax rolls while also allowing hundreds of lower income families to access affordable home ownership, transforming entire city neighborhoods. The plan would put as many as 200 of these repossessed properties annually back on the tax rolls, about half of which would be reserved for subsidized affordable home ownership and half for market-rate housing for middle to upper income families.
Recognizing that the government is constrained in the level of subsidies it can provide, we believe these subsidies should be provided by the business and foundation communities through the creation of an entity similar to the Pittsburgh Promise. While the Promise was dedicated to advancing education, the entity we envision would be dedicated to expanding access to affordable homeownership and the rejuvenation of neighborhoods across the city. For now, let’s call it the Pittsburgh Affordable Home Ownership Program (PAHOP).
The benefits of homeownership
We are involved with Open Hand Ministries, one of numerous Pittsburgh non-profit organizations involved in the ownership aspect of affordable housing. Watching our clients move into homeownership for the first time, and hearing their acknowledgement of homeownership’s life-changing benefits, validates the reams of data about the personal, familial and social value of a culture of homeownership.
As current homeowners already know, the benefits of homeownership are powerful for the whole family, but especially for children. The chance to live in one home during their adolescent years offers a stability missing for children who are relegated to transient apartment living.
Children of homeowners are 9% more likely to stay in school and 7% more likely to graduate high school than children of renters. Math achievement improves by up to 9% and reading by up to 7%, while behavioral problems decrease by 1–3%. Daughters of homeowners have a lower probability of having children of their own as teenagers than those of renters.
Residents with stable housing have been found to be 5% less likely to report poor health or experience serious psychological distress compared to those with unstable housing.
Homeownership strengthens civil society. Homeowners are 15% more likely to vote in local elections, 13% more likely to know their U.S. Representative, and 12% more likely to work on community issues. Research also finds that new homeowners show increased engagement in neighborhood organizations, particularly in low-wealth urban areas.
Meanwhile, homeownership builds intergenerational wealth. The median net wealth of homeowners is $231,400, compared to just $5,000 for renters, while low- and moderate-income homeowners accumulate $6,000 to $10,000 more in wealth per year than similar renters. After 10 years, due to the fixed cost of a mortgage versus the variable rental market, typical homeowners spend 28% less annually on housing than comparable renters, allowing greater investment in savings and wealth-building.
Cracking the affordable housing code
Subsidies for affordable housing are usually made available to families making less than 80% of area median income (AMI). The bulk of these subsidies goes to rental housing, yet as many as a third of households receiving this assistance could become homeowners with similar or even smaller subsidies.
Affordable housing programs typically expect a qualified recipient to pay 30% of their monthly income toward housing, with subsidies (usually in the form of tax credits or Section 8 housing vouchers) paying the rest. But the subsidy required to provide affordable rental housing is at least as expensive as placing qualified families into home ownership — so why not favor homeownership?
Numerous well respected non-profit organizations and community development corporations focus on homeownership, but funding for such projects is hard to come by. Further, homes for affordable ownership tend to get built or renovated in ones and twos, while affordable rental units get built in twenties and thirties.
Pittsburgh can blaze a new and better path. We propose developing 100 additional affordable homes annually for 30 years, on top of those already being developed. Each home would be subsidized by a 0% interest second mortgage of up to $200,000, representing $20 million in yearly investment from local corporations and foundations.
Properties would primarily be sourced from the city's inventory of distressed real estate. Recognizing that neighborhoods need middle- to upper-income residents as well, this program should include an equal number of unsubsidized market rate homes. We propose the City give properties to those eligible for affordable housing and sell them to market rate housing developers. Combining PAHOP with market rate programs will help limit the effects of gentrification while also rejuvenating neighborhoods.
If the PAHOP investment is made in the form of an interest free second mortgage, repaid at future sale, the house will remain available to affordable ownership for the next buyer as well. The fund should be self-sustaining for thirty or more years.
An affordable renaissance
If PAHOP is implemented, in three decades Pittsburgh will have moved 6,000 properties back into the hands of homeowners, saving the city millions of dollars in maintenance costs. The taxable value created by those properties alone could be $2-3 billion in today’s dollars, with local taxing bodies receiving $25 million annually. Thousands of lower- and middle-income families will have become homeowners, and thousands more middle- to upper-income families will have moved into once-marginalized neighborhoods. Finally, thousands of school-age children will have moved from apartments to single family homes.
The benefits would ripple outward, including for investors in the program. In 2025, 80% AMI for a four-person household in Allegheny County was $85,850, and $68,700 for a two-person household. Tens of thousands of workers, especially in fields like health care, would be eligible for the program, enhancing their stability and reducing turnover and absenteeism.
The rejuvenation of neighborhoods — safer, more cared-for, more diverse — would attract more people and businesses, a feedback-loop of renewal and growth. The resulting stability would encourage more people to take the risk of starting new professions and businesses, leading to a larger middle class.
More stable homes for more families would boost enrollment and revenue for Pittsburgh Public Schools, giving them the long-awaited opportunity to reverse decades of decline.
For all these reasons, corporations and foundations should be very interested in supporting PAHOP. The beneficiaries include the city, its neighborhoods, its lower income families, its children and its schools, among others, all with one bold investment. And Pittsburgh could be the model that other cities follow.
Wayne Younger is co-founding pastor of Cityview Church in East Allegheny and the executive director of Open Hand Ministries. Fred Miller is a longtime community advocate and former treasurer of Open Hand Ministries.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.