In 1986, on the 20th anniversary of Pittsburgh’s International Poetry Forum, the great Polish novelist Jerzy Kosiński asked me about the history of Pittsburgh and its Polish immigrants. I told him that my father died at the age of 34 when I was 8 years old. He was a son of a Polish immigrant, fought on the front lines in World War II and worked at Carnegie’s first mill in North Braddock.

I explained how the steel mills that once lined the banks of the Mon and Ohio rivers were being demolished and how Pittsburgh was transitioning to a technology and medical economy.

Kosiński was the emcee for the event. He began his remarks by saying, “Who would have thought, here in the city of Pittsburgh, poetry would outlast steel?” While his remark was a bit hyperbolic, it was a profound statement of the enduring power of the arts and creative expression.

Arts and democracy

Why does that matter? Why should we as citizens be concerned about poetry and the arts? History has shown that so go the arts, so goes democracy — and that when democracy goes, so does the quality of art.

Advertise with us

In 1934, Joseph Stalin convened the First Congress of Soviet Writers in Moscow. It was a milestone in the history of Russian literature and art — and the Soviet propaganda machine. He gathered all the great Russian writers together, and in no uncertain terms told them what was acceptable and what was not acceptable in literature and the arts, based on his personal vision of the ideal Communist state.

He banned abstract and surrealistic paintings. He forbade realistic depictions of peasants and factory laborers, especially any that showed the hellish world of the Russian working class.

It had been and was different in Europe and America. Working-class life had been the focus of European and American painters and novelists since the 1830s, and with the Depression had become a popular subject. Writers like Dickens, Flaubert and Dreiser, artists like Courbet and Millet, others like the great American journalist/​photographer Jacob Riis (with his haunting images of the lower East Side slums of New York) portrayed the world as they saw it, not as a dictator demanded.

Stalin would have none of that.

There were no poverty or oppressed workers in his glorified view of the Soviet Union. So what if he forced the starvation of millions of Ukrainians in the Holodomor between 1932 and 1934, a horrific widespread famine many historians agreed he engineered. That’s not the stuff artists need to worry about.

Advertise with us

Art’s higher mission

He declared that writers and artists have a much higher mission: to portray Russian life in a glorified manner and promote Communist ideology and values.

Soon after the congress, posters appeared throughout Russia showing the great Stalin embracing cheerful young children presenting him with bouquets of roses. Healthy smiling peasants in horse-drawn wagons overflowing with golden bundles of wheat. Sweating, muscular factory workers forging hammers and sickles out of molten steel. Russian soldiers in tanks saluting the Soviet red star.

That was acceptable art. Somewhat ironically, Stalin called it Soviet Socialist Realism. (Fun fact: Stalin was born with the name Joseph Dzhugashvili. He changed his name to Stalin, which means steel.)

His predecessor Lenin taught him the importance of controlling the arts in order to control the populace. Of all the arts, Lenin said, cinema is the most important. At the time, Russia was a highly illiterate nation, and imagery — be it posters, or more powerfully, cinema — had a major impact on molding what the average Ivan thought and believed.

To reach the masses who stretched across two continents, Lenin created a fleet of “agitprop” trains equipped with film projectors and screens. The trains traveled from village to village, showing Communist propaganda films and distributing posters and flyers.

Advertise with us

Understanding the power of cinema to “engineer the human soul,” he recruited the services of Sergei Eisenstein, the inventor of manipulative montage editing. Eisenstein in turn exploited the psychological conditioning theories of Ivan Pavlov to make films that contributed to the mass indoctrination of the Soviet people.

Art in America

We are living under an administration that wants to define what is acceptable and what is not acceptable as art.

This is not to say that Trump is a tyrant on the same level as a Stalin. It’s only to say that he has an authoritarian appreciation of the power of imagery, visual media and the arts — and also understands the effect of putting on a good show for the people, as exhibited by his recent made-for-TV, manufactured emergencies and “shows” of power in L.A. and D.C. Is it in any way surprising that he chose former Fox media stars for many of his cabinet members and advisors?

It is one thing to have a subjective disagreement about what is acceptable in the arts. But it is another thing all altogether to ban free expression through coercion.

Our president has taken control of the Kennedy Center. He will decide who is worthy of being a Kennedy Center Awards nominee (“woke” artists need not apply).

Advertise with us

He is commanding museums in D.C. and elsewhere to display only what is “uplifting” and sweep under the rug slavery, his impeachments and the many historical facts that do not support his vision of America.

Disagree with his sense of aesthetics, say, in the architecture of the nation’s capital, or his gilded ballroom? Such dissent will not be tolerated as six of the seven members of the U.S. Commission of Fine Arts discovered when he fired them in October.

The draping of his portrait from government buildings in the nation’s capital is eerily similar to the faces of Mao, Stalin and Hitler hung from the monuments of their nations. Equally eerie and reminiscent of Stalin’s portraits of the ideal Communist are the posters recently issued by the Department of Labor, celebrating the American worker.

Fortunately, democracy will win out. As Kosiński said that day in Pittsburgh, poetry — and cinema, literature, theatre, the visual arts, symphonic and even popular music — are stronger and more enduring than the tenure of one president.

Karl J. Skutski, the retired founder of a Pittsburgh public relations agency, served as an adjunct professor of International Film Studies at Duquesne University for 15 years.