In America, Hanukkah, which we’ve been celebrating this past week and which ends tomorrow, is about candles and presents, sufganiyot (jelly doughnuts) and dreidels. In Israel, it’s about the second century BCE victory over Greek culture. Not the military aspect, so much as the Maccabees’ success in taking back Jewish life from the Greek empire that had conquered much of the region and eliminating their idolatrous practices from the ancient Jewish Temple in Jerusalem.
The celebration of Hanukkah is a statement that “We are the Jews who lean into our history and tradition, and do not seek to assimilate into the surrounding culture.” In that, it offers a model or lesson for all those who want to sustain their distinctive beliefs and practices — their identities — in a pluralistic culture that tries to make everyone alike.
The dangers
Hanukkah offers two lessons. The first lesson is about the danger. In “People Love Dead Jews,” Dara Horn distinguishes what she calls “the Hanukkah version” and “the Purim version” of antisemitism. (Purim celebrates the story told in the book of Esther, when the Persian empire tried to annihilate the Jews, who were saved only by the heroism of the Jewish queen.)
Hanukkah antisemitism is that which destroys Jewish civilization from the inside by pressuring Jews to gradually become non-Jews. Purim antisemitism is more direct: kill all the Jews.
Assimilation has, throughout history, created a powerful gravitational force that has pulled many Jews away from Judaism and out of Jewish life. We have signed up eagerly for this kind of assimilation here in the Land of the Free. The Spanish Inquisitors, the Russian czars, the Nazis employed the Purim version to solve what they perceived to be their Jewish problem.
One lesson of Hanukkah is that those who seek to destroy Judaism have two methods at their disposal. Although we are most in danger of the Purim method — the murders at the Tree of Life building, Bondi Beach and the Hamas attack of Oct. 7, 2023, are a few examples — we are still in danger of the Hanukkah method, which is harder to see and surprisingly effective.
It is a danger that affects all those who try to maintain distinct ethnic, cultural and spiritual identities. So, for example, Christmas becomes mainly about family and football and presents rather than, say, Christianity.
The response to danger
But there is another lesson of Hanukkah, that also applies to others besides Jews. The second lesson is about the response to the danger.
Hanukkah is the holiday of light, reminding us to act in a way which illuminates the world. We light the candles of the Hanukkah menorah when the sun sets to commemorate the miracle of the Temple having only enough oil to keep the lamp lit for one day, and yet the small cruse of oil lasted for eight days.
Light is a symbol of the victory over the dark. Although we may suffer in dark times, redemption is always there around the corner. But symbols must lead to action.
That light represents the struggle, fought by the Maccabees against the Hellenistic invaders, of monotheism over idolatry, of the beauty of Torah over the Greek worship of the human body, of self-actualization over the tyranny of foreign power.
Theodor Gaster, a professor of comparative religion, characterized Hanukkah wonderfully in his classic work “The Jewish Year”: “Hanukkah affirms the universal truth that the only effective answer to oppression is the intensified positive assertion of the principles and values which that oppression threatens.”
Jews are called to be or lagoyim, a light unto the nations. It is our obligation in this world to bring light where there is darkness, that is, to reach out to those in need, to seek peace and pursue it, to protect God’s Creation zealously, to live the values taught by our ancestors, to apply the principles of Talmud Torah, of Jewish learning to illuminate this otherwise unenlightened world, to counter the forces of chaos, terror and hatred with love, equality, and reason.
In other words, the way that we stamp out oppression is to emphasize the values that we hold dear: for Jews, the freedom to live a Jewish life marked by engagement with Torah and Jewish values; the obligation to root out hatred and bigotry; the imperative to act on the responsibility that we have for needy people of all kinds, to protect and nourish the widow, the orphan, the stranger among us.
The Hanukkah goal
On Oct. 29, 2018, I went to Presbyterian Hospital to visit a congregant who was near death, unrelated to the shooting that had occurred two days earlier. I parked my car on the street, and when I stepped out, an African-American woman, who had been sitting in her car eating lunch, approached me. She was wearing a green outfit that is common for hospital employees.
“Are you Jewish?” she asked. Intuitively wary of that particular question, I tentatively nodded. “Can I give you a hug?” she said. “Absolutely,” I replied, and received what was among the warmest hugs that I have ever experienced.
Nothing needed to be said. The comfort that she offered was overwhelming and implicit. It spoke silently of shared persecution, of historical wrongs and overcoming prejudice. It was, if you will, a Hanukkah moment, of someone doing something to be a light to someone else.
If the Hanukkah candles do not lead us to a place where we do something concrete, something where we actually improve the quality of life of people near us, then we have missed the point. We have not heeded the message.
Our goal in this season should be both to maintain our traditions, to remember our covenant, to resist assimilation by passing on moments of joy and gravitas and prayer to our children, and to act. To make a difference. To cast more light through action.
May this ongoing holiday season be illuminated with love and tradition.
Seth Adelson is the senior rabbi and spiritual leader of Congregation Beth Shalom in Squirrel Hill and author of the substack The Modern Rabbi. His previous article was “For Jews, Oct. 7 was nothing new, but neither is Jewish resilience.”
Correction: The singular “sufganiyah,” an editorial error, was corrected to the plural “sufganiyot.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.