Across much of the industrial world, though not all, trust in government is low and declining. In the U.S., anti-establishment populists have turned politics upside down and elite expertise has become not just distrusted but disdained.

Last year a survey found that fewer than one in six Americans expect Washington to do the right thing “nearly always” (1%) or “most of the time” (15%). At the turn of the century, such measures for the U.S. were more than twice as high.

Many countries, including the U.K., the Netherlands, Spain, New Zealand and Chile, have also seen trust in their governments decline. But in several others, such as Finland, Ireland, Portugal and Mexico, trust has increased. The levels of trust in both types of countries also vary a lot.

Why is this happening and why, exactly, does it matter? The answers are somewhat unexpected and, in one way, more disturbing than you might have guessed.

Advertise with us

The real reason

On the face of it, the collapse of trust seems like a phenomenon of social psychology. That way of understanding human life tends to point to a confluence of cultural and technological factors.

In this case, social psychology explains trust in government by factors like the combined effects of social media, disinformation and misinformation, echo chambers, “epistemic bubbles” (when people only hear one point of view) and the like. That is the explanation frequently given by public commentators.

This view is mistaken, according to a study by Michael Boskin, Alexander Kleiner and Ian Whiton, all of Stanford University. Their new paper adds to a body of research that says straightforward economic factors are what count. Their paper, titled “A Note on Factors Influencing Trust in Government,” was published by the National Bureau of Economic Research and can be read online.

Looking at 34 countries between 2007 and 2023, the three found that per capita gross domestic product, debt, social spending, unemployment, and inflation all have pronounced effects on trust in government. In their analysis, the interactions and trade-offs among these measures largely explain the outcome, leaving non-economic factors to play “only a supporting role.”

Overall, an increase in per capita GDP (in real, after-tax terms) of $1,000 corresponded to a rise in trust of 0.2 percentage points. The effect of higher social spending was even more pronounced: An increase of $1,000 per capita is associated with a 1.4 percentage-point increase in trust.

Advertise with us

Higher inflation and higher unemployment both reduce trust, as you’d expect. Each increase of a percentage point reduces trust in government by 1.6 and 1.0 percentage points, respectively.

Half a century ago, the economist Arthur Okun coined the “misery index,” the sum of the rates of inflation and unemployment. Evidently, misery means distrust, and inflation is especially likely to induce it.

The trade-offs

More important are the trade-offs connecting these various measures. Other things equal, trust rises when social spending goes up. If higher spending coincides with a period of high unemployment and spare economic capacity, it’s likely to cut joblessness without pushing inflation up. The net effect, thanks to lower unemployment, would then be an even bigger improvement in trust.

But if the spending coincides with full employment and no spare capacity, it will likely drive up inflation — most likely by enough to yield a net reduction in trust. The authors surmise that this is what happened in many countries, especially the US, once the recovery from the pandemic was well under way.

One way to summarize the finding is to say that sound macroeconomic management — not the same as “big government” or “small government” — promotes trust, and that the main test of sound macroeconomic policy is low unemployment and especially low inflation.

Advertise with us

But there’s another more unsettling implication: Declining trust will be self-reinforcing if, as seems likely, it makes sound macroeconomic policy more difficult.

A vicious circle of macro mismanagement and declining trust is plausible. Inflation expectations are anchored by the credibility of policymakers’ commitment to keep prices under control. If enough people don’t believe they will, they will have trouble achieving low inflation.

And this risk isn’t confined to the decisions made by central banks. Fiscal policy is equally implicated.

Rising debt arouses distrust in its own right. At a certain point, it also calls into question the government’s preference for low inflation (because higher inflation would reduce the debt in real terms). Higher inflation means less trust and less trust makes higher inflation more likely.

Good and bad news

In other words, trust in government requires good government, but good government requires trust in government.

Advertise with us

The good news in this study is that restoring trust might be more straightforward than cultural revolution and/​or technological stasis. Plain old sound economic management — with particular stress on keeping inflation tamed — might suffice.

The bad news for countries like the U.S., which have seen trust in government fall so precipitously, is that sound economic management is now a lot more difficult than before.

Clive Crook is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist and member of Bloomberg Opinion’s editorial board.