Critics have scoffed at Donald Trump’s Executive Order renaming the Department of Defense as the Department of War. But his doing so was not mere flimflam. It could bring much-needed candor to American foreign policy.
For decades, the U.S. has engaged in dozens of invasions, bombing campaigns, drone attacks, police actions, sabotage, and assassinations far from our borders. The suggestion that these attacks constituted “defense” was laughable — a public relations maneuver to excuse bloody, expensive, failed interventions.
If Trump’s renaming the Department of Defense clarifies the longstanding militarization of U.S. foreign policy, good. But why stop there? Why not extend the name changes for even greater transparency?
Abuses and complicity
Bureau of Human Rights Abuses. Start with a Bureau of Human Rights Abuses and Genocide Complicity to tell the American people a little more of what has happened in the many wars we have started, prolonged, or supported.
We are all too familiar with the tragic toll of dead and wounded GIs in these aggressions. (Just under 7,000 were killed and almost 53,000 wounded in Afghanistan and Iraq.)
But most Americans are blind to the masses of foreign civilians killed. Democratic and Republican administrations have fired drones at people far from battlefields suspected — but not found guilty — of terrorism.
Poor intelligence and mistaken identity regularly turn innocent civilians into “collateral damage.” This month the Trump administration extended the tactic to people suspected of smuggling drugs.
In our many post-9/11 wars, including Afghanistan, Iraq, Libya, Syria and others across Asia and Africa, 4.5 to 4.7 million civilians have died directly or indirectly, according to Brown University researchers.
As for genocide complicity, the U.S. provides Israel with billions of dollars in weapons each year. We are often its main defender against human rights criticism at the UN.
Yet respected human rights organizations, both international and Israeli, have issued reports finding that Israel’s actions in Gaza amount to genocide. Before October 7, 2023, they reported that Israel’s treatment of the Palestinians constituted the crime of apartheid. The major Israeli newspaper Haaretz has repeatedly documented the ways that Israel has triggered a hunger crisis and famine in Gaza.
Subversion and spending
Agency for Constitutional Subversion. But abuses are not only for foreigners. Americans are victims too. An Agency for Constitutional Subversion and Bill of Rights Violations would make that clear. The Constitution states that only Congress has the power to declare war. Yet since World War II Congress has never passed a Declaration of War, despite all the warmaking and combat deaths.
Using these conflicts as rationales, both parties have hacked away at our Constitutional rights—the very things that make America unique and special. The decades-long bipartisan war on terror has resulted in illegal detentions, restrictions on activism, and pervasive surveillance against our own people.
Today, we see further erosion to shield Israel from criticism of its actions in Gaza. The Trump administration, with support from Congress has broadly expanded the definition of “antisemitism,” making it risky to protest or boycott Israel’s actions. Even the definition’s own author, a scholar working for the American Jewish Committee, has repudiated Trump’s use of it as an attack on First Amendment freedoms.
Bureau of Wasteful Spending. Then there are the monetary costs of U.S. foreign policy. Trump should establish the Bureau of Wasteful Spending to alert more Americans to Pentagon misuse of taxpayer money. Last year, just like the previous six, the Department of Defense failed its own audit. Tens of billions of dollars remain unaccounted for. In the misbegotten Afghanistan war alone, $2.3 trillion was wasted over 20 years of futile fighting.
Yet Trump, continuing the pattern of the Biden years, has blithely thrown ever more taxpayer dollars into the military maw. In 2026, the military budget will be over one trillion dollars. Meanwhile, the much-vaunted Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) made only modest trims to the Pentagon.
Agency for Fearmongering and Threat Inflation. How, despite all the waste and abuse, has the Pentagon continued to build its budget? An Agency for Fearmongering and Threat Inflation would tell the tale.
Staffed with spin-meisters, serial exaggerators, and outright liars, the Agency would oversee the latest fear-of-the-day rollout. Today it is Iran and immigration, in the Biden administration it was climate change and disinformation, always it’s China and Russia — all despite the U.S. remaining one of history’s most secure countries.
Toward Realism
What might result from the newfound frankness of these or similar agencies within Trump’s Department of War? Maybe nothing, given the lock-hold that the Pentagon has over Congress and given the mainstream media’s usual cheerleading for war.
Still, if the government were honest about what it really does, Americans might object. There would at least be a chance for something different — a more humble, realistic, rights-abiding foreign policy reflective of our nation’s Constitution, respectful of international law, and prudent with Americans’ lives and pocketbooks.
Clifford Bob is professor emeritus of political science at Duquesne University. He is finishing a book titled “The Fear Industrial Complex.” His previous article was “Donald Trump is not a fascist.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.