President Donald Trump claims crime in Washington and other cities is out of control. Gallup polls through the decades show that most Americans are convinced that crime is rising no matter what the statistics say. But it’s going down nationally.
FBI estimates show violent crime (murder, rape, robbery and aggravated assault) at half-century lows relative to population and property crime possibly lower than it’s ever been. The Major Cities Chiefs Association, Real-Time Crime Index and Council on Criminal Justice data shows almost every category of crime down in 2024 in the cities they track, and subsequent reports show continued declines in 2025.
The biggest takeaway is that violent crime in the U.S. is mostly not of the random, impersonal sort that dominates headlines and nightmares. Instead, it usually involves familiar people in familiar places doing terrible things to one another. A second takeaway is that you might want to be most careful between midnight and 1:00 a.m.
Crimes after midnight
The data aren’t perfect. The Bureau of Justice Statistics’ annual Crime Victimization Surveys show marked declines over the past two decades in the share of crimes respondents say they reported to police, and those are the only crimes the FBI knows about. It even changed the name of its annual report from “Crime in the Nation” to “Reported Crimes in the Nation” this year to reflect this.
Property offenses have been migrating online. That renders the historical FBI property-crime trio of burglary, larceny-theft and motor vehicle theft less relevant in an age of phishing, catfishing and other digital crime.
The new new National Incident-Based Reporting System (NIBRS) does make room for digital crime and lots of other offenses. The most fascinating information I found among the 2024 NIBRS spreadsheets, though, had no obvious takeaway other than: Watch out between midnight and 1:00 a.m.
I wasn’t able to find anything in the existing crime literature that explains this explosion in crime just after midnight. Darkness encourages certain crimes, but except perhaps in Alaska in summertime its no darker at 12:30 a.m. than at 11:30 p.m. Bar closing times also affect criminal activity, but few places in the U.S. mandate last call as early as midnight.
It is possible that midnight is when a lot of people who have been out on the town decide to head home, but it’s also possible that it’s an especially memorable time marker that victims and police use when they’re not entirely sure when a crime happened. I look forward to the research aimed at sussing this out.
NIBRS sorts crimes differently from the FBI’s violent-property divide. It also defines assault and sexual assault far more expansively than the aggravated assault and rape categories found in violent-crime estimates. Assault offenses include intimidation, including those in cyberspace.
Here are the major findings.
Where and who
Location of crimes: By far the most common location for crimes against persons was people’s homes, which accounted for 57.1% of the 4.1 million crimes against persons reported in 2024.
The 8.2 million property crimes reported in 2024 were much more dispersed, although home was still the No. 1 location, with 33.5% of offenses, and highway/road/alley/street/sidewalk No. 2, at 12.1%.
The 2 million crimes against society — drug offenses, pornography, prostitution, etc. — were more of a streets-and-sidewalks phenomenon, with 50.9% of reported offenses occurring there.
Who commits crimes: The overwhelming majority of crimes against persons were committed by someone known to the victim.
Robberies are more likely to be committed by strangers. But the reported robbery rate is down 60% over the past two decides. It is not a growing problem.
Murder and assault. The national murder rate jumped to a 25-year high in 2020, and while it has gone back down, and in 2024 was slightly lower than it was two decades earlier. The latter goes for aggravated assaults as well. By far the most common circumstances reported for murders and aggravated assaults in 2024 were arguments and domestic violence.
The big distinguisher between assaults and murders is the weapon used. The most common weapon for all assault offenses are hands, feet, teeth and other “personal weapons.” For homicide offenses (which include negligent manslaughter as well as murder and nonnegligent manslaughter), it’s guns by a mile.
Race. The NIBRS statistics also delve into crime by race, a deeply fraught topic. They show that Black Americans are overrepresented among known offenders of all the crimes tallied except extortion/blackmail, where their 13% share of offenders is a bit lower than their 13.7% share of the population.
Some of this is the direct product of stereotyping and racism — victims often identify offenders as Black even when they’re unsure, and police are more likely to stop and arrest members of racial minorities than white people engaged in similar behavior.
But that’s not enough to explain all the disparity. Black Americans really do make up a disproportionate share of homicide offenders, for example. They are even more overrepresented among homicide victims (48.8% compared with 47.2% of offenders).
Basically, Black Americans are more likely to be stuck in high-crime places, and especially places with high gun violence. They’re also much poorer on average than white or Asian Americans, which explains some of the gap between their share of property-crime offenders and property-crime victims.
Men as offenders and victims
Sex. Men’s 49% share of crime victims was more or less in line with their share of the population. The crimes where the offender-victim gap was biggest were the ones you’d expect — sex offenses, kidnapping, human trafficking.
Men are almost as overrepresented among homicide victims as among offenders (76.6% compared with 86.4%). For all the attention understandably paid to mass shootings, random killings, assassinations, murders for hire and other headline-grabbers, homicides in the U.S. are mostly prosaic tragedies involving men with guns, especially younger Black men, getting into fights with one another.
I can think of some policies that might reduce the odds of this happening. Sending the National Guard into the streets of Washington isn’t really one of them.
Justin Fox is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist and author of “The Myth of the Rational Market.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.