During the 1996 Atlanta Olympics, Nike ran a campaign ad that said,“You didn’t win silver, you lost gold.” It wasn’t a very successful ad — not nearly as successful as their earlier motivational pitch, “Just Do It.”
That one urged people to push back against procrastination, fear, comfort and all the reasons we have for just getting by, and instead strive to do their very best. Nike quickly pulled the silver-gold ad after encountering considerable public criticism for implying that finishing second in a world athletic competition was disgraceful. If that’s disgraceful, there is no hope for any of us.
Because most of us are mediocre and in a success-driven society like ours, mediocrity is often associated with failure.
A life of mediocrity
But why? It means having “moderate ability or value,” according to Merriam-Webster, or it used to. It now means “not very good,” as another dictionary put it. That a word that once meant average now means bad tells us something.
It doesn’t warm my heart to label myself mediocre, but the truth is I am. My life has taken me down several fulfilling career paths, writing for newspapers and traveling the country as a stand-up comedian for 16 years being two of them.
I can’t claim, however, that I was exceptionally talented as either a writer or comic. Compared to others working in the same fields at the same time, I was, wait for it (as a comic would say), mediocre.
I enrolled in the University of Iowa’s Writers’ Workshop 60 years ago hoping to become a novelist, or at the very least, a short story writer. Kurt Vonnegut was one of the instructors. Writers like Flannery O’Connor and John Irving were graduates of the program.
It was a big deal to be there. But my hopes were dashed when a short story instructor suggested that my literary ambitions could be better satisfied by penning words on menus and greeting cards. They wanted greatness. I was mediocre.
When I began a career as a standup comic almost 40 years ago, a club owner in a small midwestern city was so impressed with my talent that he told me that I could count on him rebooking me to work at his club as long as I was willing to accept less money each time I returned.
Now, some entrepreneur is selling on eBay head shot photos of me that decorated the walls of comedy clubs in the 1990s. The only people crazy enough to buy them must have a weird passion for collecting photos of mediocre comics.
Be Uecker, not Lombardi
In examining my own mediocrity, I’ve learned to appreciate that attempting to master a skill and failing is OK. The experiences I’ve had in the fields I didn’t excel at still brought me happiness. I really enjoyed entertaining people on a stage and offering my opinions in a column.
I’ve found that sharing my talents, modest though they may be, with strangers can be rewarding. I could please people telling jokes without being Robin Williams or Chris Rock. Most of the people in front of me were mediocre too, and maybe my mediocrity spoke to them in a way the stars’ greatness couldn’t.
Bob Uecker had a lackluster career as a major league catcher before he retired and became a sports broadcaster. He made fun of his mediocrity as an athlete and turned self-mockery into an art form.
He once said that he knew his career was over when his baseball card came out without his picture on it. He bragged that he helped the St. Louis Cardinals win a pennant by coming down with hepatitis. He said the team’s trainer injected him with it. Of course, he was great at being mediocre, so maybe he’s not so good an example.
The legendary football coach Vince Lombardi once said that “in chasing perfection you might catch excellence.” I can identify with Uecker’s self-mockery more than Lombardi’s desire to win everything all the time. I never chased perfection because I knew I wasn’t talented enough to catch excellence as a consolation prize.
Great but not great enough
Recently, I was sitting in a bar in East Nashville listening to up-and-coming musicians showcase their talents in the country and western music capital of the world. I left the bar thinking they were supremely talented, but in an entertainment industry bursting at the seams with gifted musicians, they seemed destined to end their careers as the same unknowns they were then.
Compared to musically talentless me, they were amazing. Compared to other gifted musicians, they were great. In terms of their ambitions, they were mediocre. They were going to miss gold, and probably silver and bronze too. But they could still have great lives. At least this mediocrity thinks so.
Just do it. Be mediocre. But be great at it.
Jay Wissot is a columnist for the Vail Daily in Vail, Colo., and occasional contributor to the Post-Gazette. His previous article was “If only Donald Trump had ever gotten into a fist fight.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.