I have been asked to prepare a lecture (not too long!) for incoming Freshmen at the University of Pittsburgh on the history of antisemitism in the city and region. I’m happy to do that, but what do I say to a group of young adults who have been raised on social media, exposed to a host of conspiracy theories and allegations against minorities, especially against Jews.

How does one deprogram innocent young people who might have been caught up in that web of hate?

Antisemitism then and now

I can certainly talk about how Pittsburgh, like many other cities, has had its share of discrimination against Jews. I can cite chapter and verse about exclusions from social clubs, hotels, certain neighborhoods, quotas in elite schools and universities, in higher education (including Pitt Medical School). I can point out how many corporate jobs, law firms and hospital staffs were generally off limits to Jews.

I can talk about some of the crackpots, the radicalized antisemites who came to town in the 1930s and 40s, the hate groups that existed in this city during that era, the Nazi propaganda that was spread, propaganda that was actually printed in Germany and shipped across the Atlantic.

Advertise with us

But what am I to say about antisemitism in the 21st century? The antisemitism out there today is much more pervasive and concerning. Then, Jews could start their own social clubs, their own businesses, even their own hospital, live in more welcoming neighborhoods, rely on the good graces of local politicians and community leaders. Jews can’t get around it so fast today.

It comes not just from the traditional right, but now from the left as well. From both sources it has led, and will lead, to intimidation and violence against Jews.

The right wingers are the heirs of those who touted the hateful conspiracy theories of the Nazis in the 30s. They are convinced Jews seek to take over one way or another — hence the chant, “Jews will not replace us,” heard in Charlottesville in 2017. Jews, they think, are somehow behind the immigration of black and brown people in an attempt to overthrow white supremacy.

In Pittsburgh, we had Richard Baumhammers starting off this new century in 2000 with a killing spree, murdering his Jewish neighbor, setting her house afire, vandalizing her synagogue and another synagogue and then killing four Asian or Black individuals. He was hellbent on starting a race war.

Then in 2018, we had the Tree of Life massacre of 11 worshippers on a Sabbath morning, just a mile or so down the road from Pitt. Their “crime” was in honoring the work of the Hebrew Immigrant Aid Society.

Advertise with us

But hatred is coming from the left of the political spectrum too, from the so called liberals who have generally supported minority rights and the underdog. They still do — except when it comes to the Jews.

Hatred from the left

The worldwide BDS movement — to boycott, divest from and sanction Israel — was pushed hard in Pittsburgh by a number of political figures to be a model for other cities. It failed due to counter action led by the Jewish community and its friends.

To them Jews are the perpetrators, not the victims. Their venom is spawned by the actions of Israel, the Jewish state that was established in 1948 after two millennia of Jewish exile from their ancient homeland and sixty years after the start of the modern Zionist movement.

But that Jewish state is surrounded on all sides by hostile Arab nations, who starting in 1948 have fought three wars to destroy Israel. There have been multiple terror attacks against Israelis over the years, culminating with the October 7 attack by Hamas, the terrorist organization in control of Gaza. Almost 1200 people were killed in that attack (the equivalent of 42,000 Americans) and 250 (equivalent to over 8700 Americans) were taken hostage.

Young people know nothing of Israeli’s vulnerability, nor the intention of its neighbors over the years to eradicate the state. When people yell, “From the River to the Sea, Palestine will be Free,” they are calling for the destruction of the state of Israel, not just criticizing the actions of the government or the military, which is not antisemitic.

Advertise with us

What is antisemitic is denying Israel’s right to exist or verbally or physically attacking Jews on American campuses or anywhere for supporting Israel and its right to defend itself. People forget or refuse to acknowledge that Hamas started the war and that they could end the war at any time by surrendering the hostages.

Ground zero

No other state, no matter what they have done to their own citizens or to others, has ever faced such a sustained and global campaign of economic and cultural isolation. That’s antisemitism.

There have been a record 193 incidents against Jews or Jewish institutions in Pittsburgh since the start of the new year. That’s close to one every day. Synagogues and other Jewish spaces have armed security guards. Metal detectors and panic buttons abound. A whole security establishment has grown up.

As we consider antisemitism in the lifetime of these students, this city sadly, has become ground zero.

Welcome to Pittsburgh, freshmen.

Advertise with us

Barbara Burstin (burstin@pitt.edu) teaches history at the University of Pittsburgh and Carnegie Mellon University and has written a biography of Pittsburgh mayor Sophie Maslof. She is researching a book entitled “Nineteenth Century Pittsburgh VIPs who you probably have never heard of.” Her previous article was “America has gone back 100 years, and that's not good.”

Barbara Burstin (burstin@pitt.edu) teaches history at the University of Pittsburgh and Carnegie Mellon University and has written a biography of Pittsburgh mayor Sophie Maslof. She, is researching a book entitled “Nineteenth Century Pittsburgh VIPs who you probably have never heard of.” Her previous article was “