A few weeks ago, I had the chance to speak with Sen. Dave McCormick about the Tree of Life synagogue’s rebuilding project to remember the tragic attack in 2018 — a plan with a $75 million price tag. He raised his eyebrows. “Seventy-five million dollars?” he repeated.
It wasn’t criticism. It was astonishment, the kind I’ve heard echoed in quiet conversations throughout the Pittsburgh community. Not because we don’t want to remember, but because, as a young adult deeply invested in the future of Jewish life, overlooking the needs of a struggling community feels to me like losing the plot.
Charity is one of the foundations of Jewish practice. But it is not the only guiding principle. Yet, for many American Jews, this is the primary way they express their Jewishness: through vocal and financial support. For many, this is Judaism.
After the Tree of Life shooting, the community — Jewish and non-Jewish alike — sprang into action. A new organization was formed, and millions of dollars flowed in from both private donations and public support. Plans were drafted to rebuild the synagogue as a memorial, house of worship and a Jewish center.
In a vacuum, it’s a beautiful and admirable response to tragedy. But taking a step back, we have to ask: If we’re willing to spend $75 million to remember the past, what would it mean to invest even a fraction of that in securing the future?
Fortifying the future
The philosopher George Santayana said, “Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.” This seemingly justifies the many Holocaust memorials erected over the past 80 years.
But we don’t need to remember the past if we don’t have a future, and the demographic reality is that unless something is done now to fortify a future for Jews, there may soon be few people left to remember at all.
In Pittsburgh, synagogue affiliation has dropped by more than 50% in the last two decades. Intermarriage rates have never been higher. Among younger generations, many children of intermarried couples aren’t being raised with a strong Jewish identity.
These trends have been heading in the same direction for 50 years and the minority of Jewish people who seek to preserve our traditions and pass their heritage down to the next generation are hamstrung by the ever-growing financial burden of doing so. Jewish education often comes with a price tag many families simply can’t afford.
In response to these demographic shifts, Reform Judaism sought to adapt, easing barriers to conversion and broadening the definition of Jewish identity in an effort to become more inclusive. At the time, it was a necessary response to an evolving American landscape.
But while accessibility increased, continuity did not. These well-intentioned changes were meant to preserve Judaism, yet without a strong foundation of Jewish learning and living, many communities continued to shrink.
With that, I want to speak directly to the many donors and philanthropists who give generously to the fight against antisemitism. First off, thank you. I, like many others, have benefited profoundly from your generosity. But being a young Jewish adult concerned for the future, I’d ask you to reconsider what we prioritize in Jewish philanthropy.
For decades, hundreds of millions of dollars have been spent trying to teach America about the Holocaust, antisemitism, and what could happen when Jewish people are vilified. These efforts have been made with the best of intentions. But it has become painfully clear that they haven’t curbed hatred toward Jews.
The only answer to hatred
I’d argue that hate never truly went away. It was subdued for a generation by the society-wide shame that was felt in the aftermath of the Holocaust, but it has reemerged as strong as ever.
Only now it’s spread through social media, and is justified on the streets as anti-Zionist activism and campus protests. Jew hatred has been made fashionable — even virtuous.
Just last month, two Israeli embassy members were murdered in Washington, D.C., while many in the pro-Palestinian community applauded. At Temple University, college students paid for a nightclub sign that read: “[Expletive] the Jews.” Dave Portnoy, a proud Jew who owned the club, responded by offering them flights to Auschwitz — the idea being that if they could see where six million Jews were murdered, they might come back changed.
This used to be our playbook: when someone expressed antisemitism, we responded with education, memory or a trip to the museum. And once, that might have made a difference. But the world has changed and that playbook is no longer as effective.
Convincing others not to hate Jews has largely failed. But the recipe to remain strong and to flourish as a people has been with us for over 3,000 years — and that is to teach Jews why being Jewish is worth holding onto.
Rabbi Jonathan Sacks put it simply: “If we do not learn what it is to be a Jew, nothing in our environment, except antisemitism, will tell us. And antisemitism, while it may remind us that we are Jews, provides no reason for us to want our children to be Jewish.”
And he continued: “Jews survived, quite simply, because they devoted their best energies to education, their money to schools and their first concern to the tuition of their children.” It was Torah-based education that anchored them, and through it, they taught their children not just how to survive, but how to live proudly as Jews.
When I was growing up in an Orthodox school, the message that echoed louder than any other was this: You are the future of the Jewish people. Not when I was 23, but when I was five — a kid who wanted to be a baseball player, not the bearer of 3,000 years of history.
I didn’t understand it then. I thought the responsibility belonged to adults in positions of leadership. But now, I’m starting to grasp the urgency of what I was being taught.
Investing in the living
As early as 1952, the Lubavitcher Rebbe, Menachem Mendel Schneerson, warned against this exact pattern: the impulse to build monuments to Jewish suffering while neglecting the spiritual and educational needs of living Jews.
“It is difficult to justify spending thousands of dollars on stone and earth,” he wrote, “when thousands upon thousands of Jews … are crying out for urgent help.” His message was clear: if we want Jews to live, we must invest in the living.
There have been many moments in history when Jewish continuity was at risk, and yet, somehow, we pulled through. The common denominator wasn’t a campaign, a memorial or a moment of global sympathy.
It was Jewish education. Prioritizing it in every generation has been the only proven path to Judaism’s survival. This is Pittsburgh’s chance to choose continuity over symbolism and invest in the community that’s still here.
Mendy Cohen is a Pittsburgh native and recent University of Pittsburgh graduate. He covered the Pittsburgh synagogue shooter’s trial as an independent journalist and founded The Cohen Notebook on Substack.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.