As the protests in Los Angeles against raids conducted by ICE escalated, President Donald Trump took over California’s National Guard and sent them and federal troops to Los Angeles. He said he had no other choice to protect the rights of people, public and private property, and the security of ICE agents. He said the federal government has the authority to do so, even over the objections of local and state elected officials, Mayor Karen Bass and Gov. Gavin Newsom.

This raises important questions about the relation of the national government to state and local governments in our federal system. Is federal intervention within a state whose elected officials reject that intervention by itself contrary to democratic rule? No.

Presidential precedents

When in the early 1960s some states resisted desegregation orders, for example, the federal government stepped in to enforce court-ordered integration. Federal troops or U.S. marshals were sent to ensure the admission and the safety of Black students.

I call that democratic-constitutional governance. It did not matter that the officers at the state level were elected by the people of those states and that they opposed the federal orders.

Advertise with us

For example, in 1957, President Dwight D. Eisenhower sent 1,000 soldiers from the 101st Airborne Division and took control of the Arkansas National Guard to escort nine children in Little Rock to a formerly all-white school and keep them safe there.

The Supreme Court had outlawed school segregation three years before, in Brown vs. Board of Education, but Little Rock’s schools refused to let Black students into white schools. The president explained his decision on national television: “Mob rule cannot be allowed to override the decisions of the courts.”

Similarly, in 1962, President John F. Kennedy invoked the Insurrection Act of 1807 to send troops to the University of Mississippi, after segregationists rioted and attacked U.S. marshals to keep James Meredith, the first Black student admitted, from registering for classes. The state’s governor himself tried to keep Meredith out. They stayed there as long as it was needed.

Some people will always disagree with such an action, especially the local officials whose authority has been overridden. They often sue, and the courts will decide.

The courts decide

The relative relationship of authority between the states and the federal government is often a bone of contention. The president’s authority is not unquestionable or absolute. Our constitutional system gives the federal government some power over state and local governments, but it also gives state and local governments some power to resist federal demands.

Advertise with us

A president’s decision to send in federal troops may be a foolish or unnecessary or even dangerous decision. He may do it for the wrong reasons, to increase his own power or strike back at his enemies, for example. But he has the authority to do it, authority granted him by his being democratically elected.

Some conflicts are settled through negotiation and others through legislation. If neither works, they must be settled and can only be settled by the courts.

The courts will decide. That is the system America’s founders created to decide such matters and built into the Constitution with its balance and separation of powers. The executive power and the states must obey. They must obey even if they disagree with the decision.

Sometimes the courts rule against the president. For example, the Obama administration claimed the right to determine who were the ministers of churches and ministries, limiting the designation to pastors and some church officials, but not to service providers such as Catholic Charities or Lutheran Services.

The reason was to limit the power of churches to reject elements of Obamacare. Religious organizations sued, arguing this violated their First Amendment rights. Eventually, the Supreme Court ruled against the administration. That settled the dispute.

Advertise with us

The L.A. intervention

What about Donald Trump’s sending the troops into Los Angeles over the objections of the city’s and the state’s elected leaders? As with the examples of Eisenhower and Kennedy responding to resistance to desegregation, federal intervention per se is not anti-democratic, even if local officials object.

Could the courts eventually decide that federal intervention in California was not sound constitutionally? Yes. That is a possibility. It is also a possibility that the courts affirm the intervention as sound.

Is it right to say, as so many people have, that in ordering troops into the city, the Trump Administration is fascist or acting against democracy? No. It is doing what historically administrations have done.

The administration would be acting against the Constitution if, once the court makes a final determination, it ignores the decision. But to say that an administration has declared a war on democracy because it intervened in a city and state with elected officials is unsound, in my view.

If the Newsom or Bass administrations think that federal intervention in California is unconstitutional, they must go to court. As I write, a court has determined that the federal government is correct. The local governments have appealed. The case will probably be decided by the Supreme Court.

Advertise with us

But even if the Supreme Court sides with the governor of California, the action was not in itself anti-democratic or a war on democracy.

Ismael Hernandez is the founder and executive director of the Freedom and Virtue Institute and the author of “Not Tragically Colored: Freedom, Personhood, and the Renewal of Black America.”