The United States is losing “our power to draw in a disproportionate share of the world’s savings, which allowed us to live beyond our means for decades,” writes the New York Times’ Thomas Friedman. We could spend money we didn’t have because we could borrow it from other nations.
These nations have been using a portion of the dollars they have earned by selling Americans goods and services to buy the bonds our government issues to finance its deficits and some of the stocks and bonds our firms have issued to finance their investments.
Obviously, if American citizens saved more, and if our government didn’t need to borrow so much, American debt issues would not look so attractive to foreigners. Then they would use more of the dollars they earn to buy American products and services, rather than its bonds and stocks.
Can America borrow less?
One obvious way to get foreigners to spend more dollars on American products and services is for American citizens, firms and government to reduce their own borrowing.
We can do this, but it will require hard choices. Our federal government already spends more than it collects, and without changes in current law the debt will only grow. By 2029, the ratio of debt to national income will grow larger than it was at the peak of World War Two and it will continue growing into the indefinite future. The growth in outlays for Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid and the interest payments on the debt are projected to exceed the growth in national income.
The Trump administration is committed to changes that would possibly make the size of the deficits even larger than projected. These would reduce the revenues collected from the personal and corporate income taxes to amounts significantly lower than the tax income projected by the Congressional Budget Office.
In particular, the administration wants to extend reductions in the income tax laws that are scheduled to expire at the end of this year. The president has also proposed eliminating the treatment of social security benefits from the calculation of taxable income under the income tax.
It is important to note that this administration, like previous ones, has vowed not to cut benefits for Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid — three of the four expenses whose costs will grow most — and this by itself will make debt reduction almost impossible. For at least two reasons.
First, the House of Representatives’ bill will cut over a trillion dollars from Medicaid and SNAP over the next ten years, but — if this cut survives the Senate — the payments are being cut to pay for other cuts and may not affect the deficit at all.
Second, under current law, Social Security Benefits will be cut after the reserves in the Social Security Trust fund are exhausted. At the current rate of depletion, that will occur about eight years from now. So, while the current administration may not change social security benefits, unless the law is changed before 2033, Social Security benefits will be reduced by about 21% in 2033.
In sum, if nothing changes, we will be even more dependent on borrowing from abroad than we are currently.
Will tariffs solve our deficit problem?
Tariffs generate tax revenue. But not enough. Revenues from tariffs are not going to be sufficient to reduce more than a small fraction of the deficits the federal government is projected to generate without any other changes in policy.
Moreover, taxes on goods tend to make the purchase price of those goods higher for consumers. So, very high tariff rates are likely to so discourage purchases that more revenue could be generated by low tariff rates. For this reason it is best not to think of the tariffs currently imposed on imports from China as a source of revenue.
Rather, they are a tool designed to get China to change some of its policies. That is true of virtually all of the so-called “reciprocal tariffs.” Reciprocal tariffs are imposed on imports from a specific country, rather than on specific goods. A reciprocal tariff is meant to be a bargaining chip that will be reduced or removed when the country on which it is imposed changes its policy.
The only tariff recently imposed by the Trump administration that is not a reciprocal tariff is a 10% tariff imposed on virtually all goods imported by the United States regardless of the country of origin. This tariff is meant to raise revenue. Products imported to the U.S. in fiscal year 2023 were valued at $3.3 trillion. If they were all taxed at 10% they would have generated $333 Billion.
While that’s a large number, the federal deficit in fiscal year 2033 was $1.7 trillion, or five times as large as the tariff revenue that would have been generated by a 10% tariff on all imported goods.
There is a question of whether or not it might be better to use some other tax than a tax on imported goods to reduce the federal deficit. President Trump believes that a tariff will be effectively paid by the exporter by lowering the price charged by the exporter.
However, the evidence on who bears the burden of tariffs is that they are passed through to the importer and to the final customer. They function much as a sales tax would be added to the customer’s bill.
America’s problem
In short, America, we have a problem. It is a problem that won’t be solved by tariffs. The problem is that we spend more than we earn, leaving our children and grandchildren to pay for our debts.
When we show a willingness to pay more taxes ourselves, or for our government to spend less, we can do away with the illusion that our profligacy is the fault of foreigners and that they should be forced to pay for it. Until then, we should be grateful that foreigners spend some of the dollars they earn from exporting goods to buy some of our debt issues. We’d be in great trouble if they didn’t.
Jack Ochs is professor of economics, emeritus, at the University of Pittsburgh: jochs@pitt.edu. He lives in Point Breeze. His previous article was “The president's made up trade emergency.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.