In assessing the other side ahead of a contract campaign, unions often try to determine if the tone of negotiations will be economic or ideological, and that depends on what the bosses want. Organizations and institutions would be wise to think harder about which type of “boss” they’re now confronting in President Donald Trump.

Some bosses simply want to settle a contract and defend their bottom line. These negotiations tend to be easier and issue-based.

Other bosses are ideologically opposed to the mere existence of the union, and these negotiations are rarely settled via contract proposals alone. Instead, they typically resolve only when one side buckles under pressure, often in response to a strike, lockout, or credible threat thereof.

A power struggle

The president is described as transactional and easily swayed with flattery, but this is not necessarily true about his response to perceived threats to his power. He believes that many institutions constitute threats by their very existence — unless he can dominate them.

Advertise with us

His barrage of attacks on important institutions in business, philanthropy, education and civic life was predictable, but many leaders appear dazed and beaten down. Unions offer a valuable lesson for every organization, institution and industry now confronting an administration intent on snuffing them out as independent enterprises.

First, you must recognize you’re in a power struggle. There is, and will be, a tendency for organizations to acquiesce or “lay low” to avoid the ire of a vengeful administration. Many see this as the safe path — and they may be right in the short-term — but so-called “company unions” have tried this and failed, losing decades of progress that they’re only regaining after internal revolt.

President Trump isn’t acting to advance policy goals, but to consolidate power. And because institutions represent one of the last remaining checks on his power, no institution — unless or until it fully subsumes itself into the apparat — will be safe.

Power only respects power. Executive Orders, investigations, litigation threats, and extralegal deportations must be read as tests of power, not just matters of policy.

To be clear, I’m not arguing against minimum necessary compliance where it is unavoidable under the law. I’ve spent enough time with corporate lawyers to know that would be unrealistic. Rather, I’m urging civic leaders to flex muscles — to signal power — as both a deterrent and a survival strategy.

Advertise with us

This will be particularly important in sectors like “eds and meds,” which are a focal point of power struggles masked as culture wars and cost-saving initiatives. As government functions are dismantled and defunded, these institutions become even more vital civically. Therefore, they are likely to be challenged and undermined at every turn.

Send the right signals

Second, you must understand how crucial is the right signalling. Jane McAlevey, a former union colleague who helped organize thousands of Pennsylvania nurses before she passed last year, was obsessed with power. Wearing a sticker wasn’t just a message; every union tactic, no matter how small, was a test. How many of our members would participate? How would management respond? How would we adapt and escalate?

Zeynep Tufekci, Princeton professor and author of “Twitter and Tear Gas,” applies signaling theory to describe how parties jostle for power via direct and indirect displays of intention and capacity. Signaling theory, she says, is applicable “especially [in] adversarial situations where the parties do not have perfect information.”

Thus far, the signal from many organizations and institutions has been: We’re ready to lay down (and/​or donate $1 million to the Inaugural).

Civic institutions, especially businesses and apolitical organizations, should get comfortable signaling power if they want to weather the onslaught with intact missions and values.

Advertise with us

Signaling power isn’t the same as reflexively “fighting back.” Citing examples from biology, Tufekci points to the bright colors and markings of many venomous animals, and the evolutionary behavior of “strotting”: where grazing gazelles will periodically spring high into the air to display athleticism and signal predators to chase easier prey.

Workers and their unions have learned to signal in traditional and innovative ways, from simple stickers and grievances to full-fledged walkouts and everything in between, plus sophisticated media campaigns and massive “strike and defense” funds, some in excess of $150 million.

Don’t hide

Hiding is an implausible strategy for major institutions. While taking necessary steps to ensure minimum mandatory compliance, leaders should also find ways to strot and signal power, just like the unions they typically try so hard to avoid.

The tactical menu is wide, but the signal should be clear: We have power, too, and testing ours risks exposing vulnerability in yours.

Even his fierce critics concede that the president has mastered power signals to great advantage. Institutions must learn to do the same while we still have them, and unions can teach the rest of civil society great lessons, if organizational leaders are willing to treat them as serious and worthy of study.

Zack Rearick worked in strategic campaigns with the United Steelworkers and as head of communications and government relations for PASNAP, one of Pennsylvania’s largest unions of health professionals.