Canada’s belief that its neighbor is the shining city on the hill, the big brother that would always stand on guard for democratic values, is no more. Canada feels it and harbors a sense of betrayal.

Canada has always answered the call to help its neighbor. Canadians joined the U.S. in the Afghanistan war. Though not their war, 158 Canadian soldiers died and another 2000 were injured.

The same can be said when Canadians opened their homes and kitchens to thousands of Americans stranded across Atlantic Canada on September 11, when Canadians risked their lives to save six American diplomats in Iran, or when Canadians soldiers joined U.S. forces in North Korea.

These are not isolated cases and Canada never even thought of sending an inflated invoice to recover cost.

Advertise with us

We do not understand

Canadians do not understand why the American president, with no forewarning or explanation, turned friends into foes and foes into friends and why the U.S. would side with Russia to oppose a U.N. resolution condemning Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. There are irrefutable facts — Russia invaded Ukraine, Zelenskyy is not a dictator, Putin is, and the United States did not provide $350 billions in aid to Ukraine, far from it.

Canadians do not understand why an American president can operate in a fact free world. The U.S. does not have a $200 billion trade deficit with Canada. Facts: the U.S. is a net exporter of manufactured goods to Canada, notably in the auto sector; energy accounts for the U.S. trade deficit with Canada; and the U.S. trade deficit with Canada is the second lowest among its trading partners.

Canada is not flooding the U.S. with fentanyl, the President’s cited reasons for imposing tariffs. According to his own border officials, less than 1% of the deadly drug that flowed into the U.S. in 2024 came from Canada.

History has shown, time and again, that no one wins in a trade war and a country cannot solve its deteriorating fiscal situation through tariffs. It requires looking in the mirror and making hard decisions at home about spending levels, taxation and economic growth. Nothing else works.

Why does the American President denigrate the trade agreement that he himself negotiated and proudly declared on the day that he signed it as a “colossal victory for American workers”? Why does he one day unveil new tariffs on Canada, only to have a change of mind, never a change of heart, the next day? Why does he take delight in insulting a neighbor by calling Canada “the 51st state” and its Prime Minister, “Governor”?

Advertise with us

This is in sharp contrast to how President John Kennedy saw Canada: “Geography has made us neighbors, Economics made us partners. And necessity made us allies” or President Reagan: “We are more than friends, neighbors, and allies, we are kin, who together have built the most productive relationship in the world today.”

President Trump sees Canada, and indeed the world, differently than his predecessors. For him countries are little more than a piece of real estate where the ones with the most cards win. For him political sovereignty and territorial integrity no longer matter, not realizing that real estate without friends, allies and economic partners hold little value.

America must change

In several short weeks, Trump has destroyed the goodwill between two neighbors built by American and Canadian political leaders over two centuries based on respect, trust and shared democratic values.

The risk now is that America will wake up one morning with no friends in Europe or in the Americas. In a pinch, Americans will see that they cannot rely on Russia or other countries to the extent they once did on Canada and Canadians.

What can be done to rescue a special relationship between two neighbors sharing a 5500-mile border? Canadians are tolerant and a forgiving people but, at this stage, it is for Americans to engage with their political leaders to repair the relationship while their political institutions, at least for the time being, still matter.

Advertise with us

Canadians meanwhile are left trying to make the past several weeks make sense.

Donald J. Savoie, who holds the Canada Research Chair in Governance at the University of Moncton, was made a Companion of the Order of Canada in 2022 and has served as an advisor to the World Bank, OECD, and the United Nations.