Almost every American has suffered an annoying or even angering encounter with a bureaucrat. An obstructive response after a long wait at a DMV line. A curt refusal to explain why a government benefit was denied. An insistence on holding you responsible when an important piece of mail was sent to the wrong address. Clear incompetence for which they won’t take responsibility.

On the other hand, most of us can also conjure up even more examples of indignities inflicted by disrespectful or incompetent private sector employees who work for a bank, a telephone company, a health insurance company, or a construction company.

Though the Trump administration has singled out the federal bureaucracy as its favorite pinata, the truth is that the federal bureaucracy is not the root cause of the multiple problems that we face as a nation today. And cutting it down to a minimum will not help solve those problems.

Expertise and commitment

Bureaucrats possess valuable expertise and a commitment to public service, and more often than not, are problem-solvers, not problem-creators. Take fentanyl supplies from Mexico. Congress and several presidents have taken some steps to reduce the flow of fentanyl from Mexico to the U.S., but we need to do much more. The traditional ways of interdicting drugs haven’t stopped them into the country in great amounts.

Advertise with us

Three Department of Justice bureaucrats came up with an innovative idea. Why not restrict the flow of “precursor chemicals” — substances used to manufacture illegal drugs — to the dominant Mexican cartel?

Using innovative investigative techniques, the Chemical Prosecutions Team of DOJ’s Narcotic and Dangerous Drug Section indicted and convicted Javier Vazquez, a key link in a secret supply chain from China to Mexico. This stopped the illegal activities of a man responsible for producing 2 billion doses of fentanyl.

Years ago, I wrote a book called “Taming the Bureaucracy: Muscles, Prayers, and Other Strategies.” I identified many examples of dysfunctional bureaucratic behavior, including bean-counting (simplistic measures of success), proceduralism, avoidance, particularism (focusing on narrow interests), and defeatism (giving up too easily).

The funny thing about the dysfunctional bureaucratic behavior that I documented, though, is that it almost always was attributable to micro-managing legislators, impatient chief executives, or judges who no longer practiced judicial restraint. Most bureaucrats are constrained by multiple sovereigns.

When they zig, it’s because legislators, chief executives, and judges want them to zig. When they zag, it’s because these same bosses want them to zag. When they zig and zag at the same time, it’s because they’re receiving conflicting demands that are hard to resolve.

Advertise with us

When Hurricane Katrina struck New Orleans in August 2005, FEMA was blamed, with some justification, for being unprepared and for slow responses to meet the needs of residents. In truth, though, the FEMA administrator, Michael Brown, had pleaded for more resources. Neither his boss nor his boss’s boss nor his congressional appropriators were sympathetic.

Furthermore, Congress had pumped huge amounts of money into New Orleans for the wrong kinds of projects. Instead of protecting the wetlands, which act as buffers when a terrible hurricane strikes, they shrank them in favor of glitzy economic development projects. In short, Congress actually made matters worse.

When Hurricane Helene struck several Southern states in September 2024, FEMA bureaucrats and local emergency response personnel tried valiantly to respond but were stymied by Mother Nature and by misinformation from candidate Donald Trump.

For example, he falsely claimed that FEMA was spending emergency funds on housing for illegal immigrants. In response to these false allegations, local militias organized against emergency responders, forcing some to cease and desist their remedial efforts because of credible threats of violence. Once again, politicians were making matters worse.

Reforming the bureaucracies

Bureaucracies need to be reformed and some bureaucrats need to be replaced. But there are good and bad ways to do this.

Advertise with us

A bad way to tame the bureaucracy was the White House’s decision to fire 17 sitting inspectors general. These quasi-independent investigators perform the function that President Trump and Elon Musk say they support — ferreting out waste, fraud, and abuse.

I call IGs “counter-bureaucracies” because they exist to hold bureaucracies accountable. A certain amount of independence from the White House helps them to do that job because the White House has a vested interest in covering up its mistakes. The basic concept: checks and balances. Sound familiar?

When a president fires IGs and replaces them with loyalists or temporary appointees who lack clout, I sadly reach the conclusion that the president’s goal is not a more efficient, more effective bureaucracy but rather a more docile, more subservient bureaucracy. That is not in the public interest.

Another bad way to tame the bureaucracy was the attempted termination of the U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID), our government’s leading provider of humanitarian assistance.

Created in 1961, USAID has helped to eradicate malaria, small pox and other diseases, has offered food relief to victims of natural disasters and civil wars, and has helped to protect and evacuate civilians in Ukraine, among many worthy activities. Its AIDS clinics and interventions, thanks to the PEPFAR program started by President George W. Bush, have saved an estimated 25 million lives, mainly in Africa.

Advertise with us

Like other federal agencies, USAID is not beyond reproach. For example, a GAO report recently concluded that USAID could better manage fraud risks in high-conflict zones such as Nigeria, Somalia, and Ukraine.

USAID undoubtedly wastes some money, as large institutions (including major corporations) do, and it sometimes funds programs it shouldn’t, as large institutions do. But there is a vast difference between reforming and streamlining an agency so it does its work better and more efficiently, and bludgeoning it with a wrecking ball so that it can’t do the work it should.

We saw the same wrecking ball approach in the so-called “Department of Government Efficiency’s” assault on the Institute of Education Sciences and its four research centers, which produce the nation’s school report card and other data vital to understanding how our students are performing in reading, math, and science.

DOGE announced the termination of most IES contracts and multiple grants, threatening the valuable data reporting and analysis that these four centers perform. This move comes at a time when the data show a rapid, enduring decline of student test scores and attendance.

Without the solid, reliable education data that IES produces, it will be exceedingly difficult to know which students and school districts are doing well and which are doing poorly. The absence of good education performance data virtually guarantees that public officials will make crucial education policy decisions based on disinformation and misinformation.

Advertise with us

Public-spirited and sensible

Federal bureaucrats are more public-spirited and sensible than they are being portrayed in the current wave of attacks.

The White House and DOGE are ignoring the Constitution and numerous laws to punish bureaucrats whose main “mistake” is that they have followed legal directives from Congress when Congress has aroused itself to make public policy. It’s sad to think that that’s considered a crime in the new United States of America.

Bill Gormley, Distinguished University Professor Emeritus at the McCourt School of Public Policy at Georgetown University, is the author of “Too Many Bridges,” a murder mystery set in Pittsburgh. His previous article was “Learning to listen to Pittsburgh's 'bridge music'.”