Recently, Vice President JD Vance was quoted on X as saying that “Judges aren’t allowed to control the executive’s legitimate power.” Given the president’s current efforts to turn upside down the executive branch and dismantle certain independent agencies, such as the Agency for International Development and the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, this brings up two interesting questions.

What is the President’s legitimate power in directing the executive branch of our federal government? Who is to decide what that power is?

The foundational source of the president’s power is found in Article II, Section I, Clause I of the U.S. Constitution: “The executive Power shall be vested in a President of the United States of America.” The Constitution created what is referred to as an “unitary executive.” Only one person has executive power and that is the president.

However, even though the Constitution has been with us since 1789, it is still not clear whether the President wields exclusive control over the executive branch and thus all federal employees must always bend to his will or, alternatively, Congress may pass laws that limits that power.

Advertise with us

The wrecking ball

For example, Congress can create independent agencies that are part of the executive branch, but whose leaders are legislatively shielded from the will of the president.   These agencies include not only USAID and the CFPB, but the Federal Reserve System, the Central Intelligence Agency, the Federal Trade Commission, the Environmental Protection Agency and the Securities and Exchange Commission, and many others.

By taking a wrecking ball to independent agencies, President Donald Trump is definitely viewing his power as absolute. He does not consider these agencies to be independent of his authority and feels empowered to fire their employees, withhold funding and cancel programs without restraint.

Moreover, he does not see it to be his duty, as required by Article II, Section III of the U.S. Constitution, to “take care that the laws be faithfully executed.” Rejecting this duty, he has frozen federal spending authorized by federal statutes.

It is possible, though unlikely, that the president has correctly interpreted the Constitution such that a strong form of the unitary executive exists, making all or most of his actions legal. He deserves his day in court to determine whether his actions are constitutional.

But that is the key point: while the president certainly has the right to have his own understanding on the constitutionality of his actions, he is not the final arbiter of what is constitutional. It is not within his legitimate power to play that role. That role is to be played by our federal courts.

Advertise with us

Separated powers

As he knows, the Constitution built the federal government on the “separation of powers” doctrine. Under this doctrine the legislative branch (Congress) has the power to enact new laws and appropriate funds for use by the executive branch.

The executive branch is bound to faithfully execute those laws enacted by Congress and faithfully spend the money it appropriates. The judicial branch, headed by the Supreme Court, is granted the authority to interpret the Constitution and determine the legality of Congress’s laws and the president’s actions.

It is critical that the president respect the role played by the judiciary in our Constitution’s separation of powers. Without such respect the job of what is constitutional is turned over to the executive branch.

Under such a regime, there is nothing stopping the executive branch from coming up with whatever flawed interpretations of the Constitution it requires in order to disobey the wishes of Congress or violate the rights of its citizens. The Constitution, most notably in the form of the Bill of Rights and other constitutional amendments, as enforced by the courts, is our chief defense against a federal government that wants to persecute its citizens.

Unfortunately, the Trump administration is willing to defy temporary courts orders requiring it to hold off on some of its actions. This is not a good sign.

Advertise with us

Such orders allow the courts time to determine if these actions are constitutional. As Chief Justice John Roberts stated just before these actions, “elected officials from across the political spectrum have raised the specter of open disregard for federal court rulings. These dangerous suggestions, however sporadic, must be soundly rejected.”

He understands the slippery slope our country will fall down if the authority of the judiciary is not respected by our unitary executive.

Preserve the Constitution

Like President Trump, I believe our government is bloated, lacks adequate alignment with presidential authority, and over-regulates. However, establishing an authoritarian presidency is not the way to solve these problems.

So, Mr. President, litigate as much as you want to identify what are the upper limits of your executive authority. Utilize all the executive authority that the courts have determined is legitimately at your disposal.

But don’t destroy our Constitution’s separation of powers. Stay within your legitimate power and thereby allow us and the rest of the world to continue to believe in American exceptionalism.

Bernard S. Sharfman is a research fellow with the Law & Economics Center at George Mason University’s Antonin Scalia Law School. The opinions expressed here do not represent the official positions of the Law & Economics Center.