In dealing with our European allies, and particularly the North Atlantic Treaty Organization, born of the triumph over fascism, which prevailed over communism and has kept the Western world relatively safe and prosperous for three quarters of a century, Trump is preparing to take on the role, not of a leader, but of an adversary.

NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte announced before the election that the alliance’s members would “dance with whoever is on the dance floor.” With Trump they will not be engaging with a partner, but with an imperious dance master intent on choreographing by demand.

Trump’s tandem threats

And what Trump has in mind is a square dance whose steps are so contrary to time-tested traditions and current, urgent needs that it will cause the dancers to crash into each other and fall — unless they can come up with an alternative dance step of their own.

On the top and bottom of this lopsided square, there are Trump’s tandem threats. The first is to not honor Article 5 of the NATO treaty, which requires all members to come to the aid of any that are attacked, in the case of any allies he deems are not spending enough on defense. The second is to impose high tariffs on countries if they do not import more American products.

Advertise with us

On the other sides of the square, there are his demands that Europe adopt policies towards authoritarian China that are in exact accordance with his dictates, and his determination to bolster the domestic political standing of the authoritarian rightwing European populists whom he regards as soulmates.

Quite apart from the fact that Trump will be dealing with sovereign democracies, not vassals, there are substantial reasons why such a dance program will only create chaos.

Even in normal times there are bound to be legitimate dissatisfactions that some aspects of a multi-partner international relationship are not working for some of the members. Washington has always borne a highly disproportionate share of NATO’s military burden, and transatlantic trade does skew considerably in Europe’s favor.

Yet to shock a vital alliance with the threat, “I’m not going to protect you unless you pay,” and aggravate that with economic pain is a reckless approach to problems that have always been resolved by negotiations among friends.

This coercion is all the more dangerous as it is being inflicted at an hour when the perils NATO was designed to protect all of its members — including America — from are more acute than they have been since the last time Article 5 was invoked — after the 9/​11 attacks on America.

Advertise with us

Putin’s war in Ukraine is a standing challenge to European security, since a decisive victory by the aggressor at the very moment that there will be a leader in Washington who has declared that the Russians can “do whatever the hell they want” to NATO allies he regards as deadbeats will embolden them to do just that.

There is also a real danger that Trump will try and end the conflict via a deal between him and Putin, freezing out the Ukrainians the way he did the Afghans at Doha, with similar results. The Kabul government was not a party to those negotiations, and was pressured by Washington to comply with conditions that had been imposed on them in the agreement while the Taliban were allowed to evade the terms they had agreed to.

It is not hard to imagine this pattern playing out again, with similarly disastrous results for Kiev.

Brutal transactionalism

Such brutal transactionalism restored Afghanistan as a safe haven for terrorists, and could have devastating consequences for the effectiveness of Euro-American counterterror cooperation at a time when the Oct. 7 attack on Israel, Muslim anger over the agony of Gaza, and power vacuums opening up across Africa and now in Syria have revealed the jihadist menace to be more potent than ever.

And it is the height of hubris to deny that the NATO country needing protection from the next major terrorist attack might very well be the United States, again.

Advertise with us

As for Trump’s other imperatives, weakening European economies and provoking genuine fears about the continent’s basic safety are hardly ways to get countries to cooperate on China, and attempting to deepen the divisions of already fractured societies by interfering in their internal politics in favor of his kindred rightwing populists will only provoke a backlash.

Confronted with this onslaught, Europe has three options: acquiesce, negotiate, or resist.

The swiftness with which leaders of different shades of its political spectrum moved to congratulate Trump on his victory, and gestures such as French President Emmanuel Macron inviting him to the reopening of Notre Dame Cathedral, indicate that they want to try to find a modus vivendi. Yet matters are so dire that there has been open talk of what a political nuclear option might look like if that fails.

The combination of Trump’s threats and the Russian menace have led the at-risk NATO allies to conclude that they do indeed need to ramp up military spending and strategic coordination among themselves, and to start by expanding their own formidable defense industries rather than “buying American.”

This will enable them to provide much more assistance of their own to beleaguered Ukraine should Trump follow through on his threats to cut off aid, and so strengthen their diplomatic position that they will not stand for being excluded from talks to end the conflict.

Advertise with us

Europe on its own

And the Europeans have also resolved that if Trump is going to wage trade war on the rest of the world, the rest of the world will have to trade with itself.

In early December the European Union announced a trade agreement with Mercosur, a South American trade bloc which includes relatively large economies such as Brazil and Argentina. That can be a strong template for other regions and their economic relations with each other as well.

The need for such visceral self-reliance was not what Europe bargained for when it accepted salvation at the hands of the United States over the course of the 20th Century.

And though four more years of Donald Trump will not end the historic ​a​lliance of Europe and America, Europe may have to endure on its own until ​America remembers that the tides of debt have always flowed both ways, and are vastly more moral than they are financial.

Vanni Cappelli, a freelance journalist, is the president of the Afghanistan Foreign Press Association and frequent contributor to the Post-Gazette.