The world’s second-biggest economy, China, is run by a proud Marxist-Leninist. The world’s most populous country, India, is in the hands of an illiberal strongman, Narendra Modi.

China and Russia have built an axis of authoritarian states that are determined to push back against Western liberalism. Some security officials believe that we are now engaged in an undeclared war with the “axis of autocracy.”

Donald Trump has hinted that he will pursue a policy of America First and may well destroy the institutions that undergirded postwar security. The EU is in a state of paralysis, with the leaders of the two most powerful countries, France and Germany, discredited and their economies stagnant.

Tens of millions of people are likely to flee Africa and Latin America in the coming years, driven by a combination of economic stagnation, political fragility and climate change, empowering the far right and undermining the stability of the West.

Advertise with us

What has gone wrong with the 21st century?

An economic-political problem

The problem lies with more than just the world’s governments’ policy mistakes. It lies with the broader development of the global economy-cum-polity.

Back in the 1990s, we looked forward to a world of entrepreneurial vigor, public sector discipline and spreading peace. What we got, instead, was the very opposite: oligopoly, government splurge and militarized blocs.

The consolidation of capitalism is most advanced in the U.S. and tech and finance, the cutting edge of the new economy, suggest that oligopoly is the way of the future. Over the past two decades, three out of four U.S. industries have grown more concentrated.

Five tech companies are each worth more than $1 trillion, and Apple Inc. is worth more than $3 trillion. Three big investment houses, BlackRock Inc., the Vanguard Group Inc., and State Street Corp., collectively manage around $22 trillion in assets.

Advertise with us

This may be the result of excellence: Alphabet Inc.’s Google and Apple are superbly run, and Microsoft Corp. is undergoing a renaissance. But would anyone argue that America’s airline industry is a model of innovation and customer service?

The success of the superstar companies slows the rate of innovation and thwarts competition. The success of second-rate companies contributes to a general sense of frustration. It’s notable that the world’s first great age of populism, before the First World War, coincided with the rise of giant companies, particularly in the U.S. and Germany.

Meanwhile, Clinton’s pronouncement in his 1996 State of the Union Address that the era of big government was “over” has proved hollow. Americans tax themselves like a small-government country but behave like a big-government one.

The U.S. deficit is roughly 6% of GDP, twice the average of recent decades. The U.S. Federal Register expanded to an average of 73,000 pages a year in the 2000s compared with 11,000 pages a year in the 1950s. The U.S. government stepped in to save failing companies such as Citigroup Inc. and General Motors Co. in 2008, as small-government bankers suddenly became fans of state intervention.

The situation is even worse in the EU, where government sprawl is not balanced by economic vigor. European countries spend beyond their means on welfare while the bureaucracy in Brussels prides itself on its role as “regulatory giant” rather than its ability to ignite growth. More than half of Europe’s SMEs (small and medium-sized enterprises) flag regulatory and administrative burdens as their biggest challenge to growth.

Advertise with us

The most serious threat to the global order comes from China, which has an economy 10 times the size of Russia and a much more disciplined leadership. From its admission into the World Trade Organization in 2000 onwards, China poured a portion of the “globalization dividend” into building up its military might. China’s navy is now the biggest in the world, and its nuclear arsenal may reach 1,000 warheads by 2030, according to the U.S. Department of Defense.

It is also roaring ahead in tech. China has overtaken the West in hypersonic missiles — those capable of traveling at five times the speed of sound and evading air defenses — and is pioneering lasers, orbiting space robots and high-altitude balloons.

Flailing liberalism

The 21st century has seen the two most compelling ideologies of the 1990s malfunction horrendously. These are neo-liberalism, the belief that markets are more efficient than governments in organizing economic life, and neo-conservatism, which started as a corrective to the left’s overconfidence in the power of the state to fix everything.

The great danger in the coming years is that we will see the further decline of a third ideology: liberalism. Across the west, liberal leaders are flailing.

Kamala Harris decisively lost to a candidate who has broken one of the most important liberal rules: giving up power graciously when you lose an election. The two most flamboyant liberal politicians of the past decade — Macron in France and Justin Trudeau in Canada — are failing. Keir Starmer won a landslide election victory in the UK on the promise of reviving the pragmatic center only to make a mess of governing.

Advertise with us

Liberal elites have prepared the way for a populist backlash by a combination of commission and omission. They have fixated on cultural issues such as pronouns at a time when regular people are suffering from stagnant or declining living standards.

They have betrayed the principle of race-blind meritocracy by embracing race-conscious policies, a trend that is most pronounced in the U.S. but has spread around the world. And they have paid too little attention to growing worries about immigration even as expanding populations put pressure on housing and public services.

The result has been to cede ground to populists such as Trump in the U.S., Nigel Farage in Britain and Marine Le Pen in France.

There are some reasons for optimism about the future.

The AI revolution has the potential to cut administrative costs while giving everyone the equivalent of a smart assistant. The collapse of Bashar al-Assad’s regime in Syria is a serious setback for the “axis of autocracy.” The Republicans’ triumph in 2024 could prove self-correcting, creating opportunities for a new generation of middle-of-the-road Democrats.

Advertise with us

Yet all this potential could go the other way.

AI may destroy the jobs of millions of knowledge workers, creating a radicalized middle class, while handing more power to a few tech giants. A newly liberated Syria may fall into the hands of Islamic extremists. Trump and his allies may well destroy the rules-based international order that has largely kept the peace since 1945.

An intriguing study of 120 years of populist governments suggests that the most common reaction to the failure of populism is for voters to demand yet more populism.

The challenge to liberals

Which future we choose depends, above all, on whether liberals revitalize their beliefs or continue to drift and dither. Can they address the causes of populism or will they continue to repeat empty phrases?

Can they think like regular people or will they continue to act like members of a global elite? Can they adapt classic liberal ideas about open competition and freedom of speech to radically new circumstances?

Adrian Wooldridge is a columnist for Bloomberg Opinion and author of “The Aristocracy of Talent: How Meritocracy Made the Modern World.”