It was dubbed the “Ripper Bill,” so named because it was designed to rip politicians out of office. Passed by the Pennsylvania state legislature with votes to spare, the new charter empowered the governor to impeach corrupt city mayors. In their place, he could appoint a mayor of his choice who had the discretion to reorganize the city’s leadership.

The day the law went into effect, March 7, 1901, could rightly be proclaimed as the official date of death of “the ring,” perhaps the most successful and lucrative political machine that ever controlled the city of Pittsburgh.

Magee and Flinn

Christopher Lyman Magee was tall and well-built, easily recognizable by his short mustache and jet-black hair. He was ambitious for power, hard-working, and by all accounts, extremely likable. Everyone called him, “Chris.” Born in 1848 into a respected Pittsburgh family, Magee began his political career at the age of 21 and quickly worked his way up.

City treasurer at age 23, then delegate to the state convention at 24. Determined to become the boss of Pittsburgh, he traveled to New York to study Tammany Hall’s machine methods, and upon his return, was convinced that a ring could be made “as safe as a bank.”

Advertise with us
Christopher Lyman MageeCarnegie Library of Pittsburgh

Magee also bought one of the city’s newspapers, The Pittsburg Times, in 1884 (the city’s name was spelled without the “h”). In 10 years, it reported a circulation bigger than its competitors. Ownership extended Magee’s influence on the city.

As part-owner of the large-scale contracting business Booth and Flinn, Magee’s political partner William Flinn held power of a kind unimaginable today. He employed thousands of men, had deep pockets and lined them even deeper by building almost everything in Pittsburgh at a time when the city was in a state of rapid growth, creating streets, sidewalks, curbing, trolley lines, bridges, buildings. He was a member of the Board of Fire Commissioners, the state’s House of Representatives, and chairman of the Pittsburgh Republican party.

Together, the two men would run the ring. Their idea was “not to corrupt the city, but to be it; not to hire votes in councils, but to own councilmen,” as the muckraking journalist Lincoln Steffens put it in his 1904 book “The Shame of the Cities.” He was still critical: “Minneapolis was an example of police corruption. St. Louis of financial corruption. Pittsburg is an example of both police and financial corruption.”

The ring in action

With the wards already organized to their liking, they elected relatives and friends to the select and common councils of the city government. For those they didn’t or couldn’t elect, the usual means of patronage would do the trick. They controlled the mayor, police chief, and director of public works.

If a business owner wanted to expand from one city block to two, councils ceded land either for free or for above market value and pocketed the kickback, depending on whether they were friend or foe.

Advertise with us

Businessmen allied to the vices were particularly easy to control. If a saloon-keeper or liquor dealer stepped out of line, they were swiftly subjected to the full force of police regulation. Meanwhile, disorderly houses and speakeasies owned and managed by ward syndicates were allowed to operate with impunity.

The two benefitted from these arrangements. Councils granted Magee’s Consolidated Traction Co. (which ran street cars) charters and street rights for 950 years, 999 years, and even “to exist perpetually.” Booth & Flinn built nearly all of Magee’s traction lines.

One admirer, a journalist at Magee’s own paper, explained the value of the consolidation. It “induced those who dwelt in crowded quarters to find homes for themselves on the outskirts of the city, where there was pure air, a touch of nature and freedom from many temptations for both young and old.”

Public contracts now went to the lowest “responsible” bidder. The stone which was specified for public buildings could only be found in Flinn’s quarry, but when another firm furnished a similar stone at a lower price, the city specified that the stone be of a “bluish tint rather than a gray variety.”

Flinn’s stone, of course, was of the bluish tint. Over the course of nine years, of the 193 asphalt paving contracts let, only nine were not awarded to Flinn.

Advertise with us

Magee knew that he could get “get the voters’ undying political loyalty,” says University of Pittsburgh historian Edward K. Muller, “by providing minimal services like a turkey in the pot at Thanksgiving or a load of coal when it was freezing or jobs in contracting companies.”

He “did not, technically speaking, rob the town,” wrote Steffens. “That was not his way, and it would be a carelessly unnecessary way in Pennsylvania.”

Great men or thieves?

During these years, the public’s attitude toward the ring was largely one of indifference. After all, at least progress was being made. Formerly dirt streets were now paved, and transportation on trolley lines was new, exciting and a great benefit to many. Public parks were created and entire East End neighborhoods developed.

Both men were generous in times of public distress. Magee personally funded the Pittsburgh Zoo, and upon his death, left his estate (after his wife died) for the establishment of a maternity hospital, now Magee-Womens. He died the day after the Ripper bill passed, worth over $4 million. It is reported that thousands lined the route from his funeral to Allegheny Cemetery.

Many in those days thought of Magee and Flinn as great men. An equal number claimed they outright stole from the city. Their legacy lives on throughout the city of Pittsburgh, but whether it is one that should be admired or reviled is still up for debate.

Eric Michalski, a resident of Munhall, is writing a book on the history of the Pittsburgh parks. His previous article was “When 9,000 people were forced out of Homestead.”