Twelve years ago, Max Browne was on top of a world that he had spent his entire life preparing for. Recruiting services like Rivals.com ranked him the #1 high school quarterback in the country and he was being wooed by every top tier program in the country.
He eventually signed with the University of Southern California, and expected his time at USC to be spent preparing for the NFL stardom so many “experts” had predicted for him.
It turns out that the “experts” (yes, those are scare quotes) were wrong. It turns out that the “experts,” including many parents, are often wrong about the kids.
Judging the kids
Within a year of signing with USC, he was told that he would never start. His response was to work even harder. It didn’t make a difference, at least on the field. Then came injuries, and a period of emotional turmoil. In five seasons — four at USC and one at Pitt — he started only eight games and threw only seven touchdown passes.
Then, a few years after he left college, the same Rivals.com that had anointed him as the best high school quarterback in the country labeled him “one of the biggest busts of the 2010s.”
Let’s be clear what exactly the label “bust” means: Browne was a failure because he didn’t live up to the expectations Rivals.com and others had created for him when he was 17 years old. The only failure, if there was one, was theirs, not his.
But it doesn’t matter that, as a recent profile in The Athletic chronicles, Browne eventually found success as a TV analyst and motivational speaker. He still carries the ignominious label of being one of the greatest “busts” in high school football recruiting history — a label he has learned to bear with grace even as it annoys his wife.
Browne is a high-profile example of the pressure we put on kids who are barely old enough to drive, and the phenomenon isn’t limited to football or even just sports: College admissions follow a similar trajectory. We are pronouncing the doom, in the sense of “a predetermined state or end,” on 18-year-olds based on which elite school they get into or, much worse, don’t get into.
Pushing the kids
Our insistence on judging people’s life trajectory based on what they do between the ages of 18 and 22 is so strong that we will go to absurd lengths to ensure things “go right” for our children. The most notorious example is the “Varsity Blues Scandal” where more than 30 parents paid at least $25 million to secure an auspicious academic doom for their offspring.
Even when the conduct is legal, it can be toxic. According to CNBC, parents can spend over $100,000 in consultants and test preparation to get their kids into what one consultant unironically called “a life changing college,” where “life changing” is a euphemism for “elite” or “prestigious.”
The pressure and stress this emphasis on an auspicious academic doom puts on our kids should be obvious. But it doesn’t seem to be. And then we wonder why so many of them are depressed and anxious.
Scott White, writing at Forbes, sees the connection. He insists that one factor driving the deteriorating mental health of American teens that parents and other adults “can do something about ... [is] the pernicious trend to push students harder and faster, from a young age, to excel in the college admissions sweepstakes.”
White, who has worked in college admissions and counseling for four decades, described the toll that the process takes on the kids he works with: “Many of the students who I talk to ... describe being out of control, of unrealistic expectations, of fear that any setback, from a bad grade to a poor athletic performance, will be indelibly etched in their future aspirations and ambitions.”
Blaming the kids
The depressing question is: do adults want to “do something”? The answer seems to be “no.”
There is no evidence that the toxic combination of unrealistic expectations and the perfectionist demands we saddle teenagers with will abate anytime soon. If anything, the opposite is true — the “college admissions sweepstakes” seems to be intensifying as an increasing number of kids apply for a static number of admissions to “life changing” schools.
This shouldn’t surprise us. Outfits like Rivals.com continue to saddle 17-year-olds with the same expectations they did Max Browne, long after it became obvious that they had no reliable way of predicting who could live up to these expectations.
Since 2014, the only quarterbacks who unquestionably lived up to expectations, at least the college level, were Trevor Larence at Clemson and Bryce Young at Alabama. The next time I read someone questioning this insane process will be the first.
Adults seem to derive a perverse kind of satisfaction in saddling kids with unrealistic expectations. It’s almost as if they believed that, in the end, it’s all about them and their sense of self. And if the kid fails, well, the failure is the kid’s, not theirs. He’s obviously a “bust.”
Roberto Rivera is a retired editor and writer.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.